This week, your assignment is simple. Take a position on the following question: Is Gatsby a hero?
Support your position with clear, well-supported arguments (think quality of ideas/ evidence over quantity) and with persuasive rhetoric. Develop your position in relation to those of your classmates (at least of the classmates who post before you). You will, of course, need to decide what makes a person a hero (in your opinion) before you can answer this question.
All responses are due by 5:00 p.m. on Wednesday, March 10th.
Wednesday, March 3, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

11 comments:
I personally believe that the character of Jay Gatsby is not a hero. Yes, he did achieve his own goal of becoming rich and gaining material goods, but he did so with the purpose of impressing Daisy, and by participating in illegal activities. He also gained his goal by ignoring the very important values in life, which is why I do not believe Gatsby is a hero. For example, towards the end of the book, after Daisy, who was the driver of the car, hit and killed Myrtle, Gatsby was the one who intended to take the blame for the accident merely for Daisy’s sake. Though this shows us the true amount of love Gatsby has for Daisy, it also shows us that he ignores all of the moral values we should all live by. After the accident, Gatsby did not force Daisy to stop the car, or go back to offer any help to the situation. Though both of these characters may not have realized what had happened or they were simply afraid of what may happen, they did commit a crime, and the person who was truly guilty should take responsibility for their actions and face the consequences, not cover up the truth.
I also don’t believe Gatsby is a hero character because he shows no respect for the character of Tom and his marriage with Daisy. For example, when Nick, Tom, Daisy, Gatsby, and Jordan meet for lunch and Gatsby’s secret love for Daisy is revealed to Tom, Gatsby begins to turn on Tom saying that his wife never loved him for she was in love with him all these years, not even taking into consideration Daisy’s true feelings. That same night, Gatsby stares at Daisy’s window, like he has done for all these past years, just hoping that he will see her at her window. Gatsby refuses to accept the truth, and therefore, he refuses to move on. He has been in love for all these years, and his love has blinded him from the truth. After all, every single one of the fancy parties held by Gatsby were only an attempt to impress Daisy, which shows that he was willing to break up a marriage simply to gain what he desired most. All of these reasons are why I do not believe that Gatsby is a true hero.
First of all, what is a hero? Well, a hero does not necessarily need to have superpowers or even have to save anyone; rather, a hero is an individual with extraordinary courage and morals. A hero is a leader; a leader who stands up for what is right and shows an example. Gatsby, however, does not fit under this category. Rather, he is quite the opposite: a coward and a selfish liar. At first, Gatsby seems to be a great person, a kind and gentle man who hosts free parties every week, but, really, his parties only hide his real personality. The only reason Gatsby held his weekly parties was because he thought that he would someday encounter someone who knows Daisy, the woman he loves, or even Daisy herself, rather than going to Daisy’s house himself and facing her like a man. In other words, he just wanted to impress Daisy, as Meghan said. However, he tried to impress her by choosing the villainous method of luring the prize (Daisy), with his elaborate parties—and later with his marvelous mansion. Also, Gatsby reveals his true cowardice during the first encounter with Daisy. He nervously kept refusing to allow Nick set up the meeting and attempted to hide from Daisy as she walked into the house, and yet, his ultimate goal and dream in life is to be with Daisy. He can never accomplish that goal if he avoids Daisy, especially if he’s even too frightened to talk to her.
Furthermore, Gatsby’s selfish lies and thievery fall under the category of cowardice, which is certainly not a characteristic of a leader—or, a hero. Let’s use Meghan’s example during the scene of the driving incident… Even though Daisy drove the car, accidentally running over and killing Myrtle, they did not stop. They moved onward. Even though he was not driving, Gatsby did not prove to be a leader by telling Daisy to stop driving. A leader is an individual who leads through example. By this, I mean that a leader should, not necessarily lead a group of people, but, rather, a leader should stand up for what is right and provide an example for others by using their morals. In this case, Gatsby could have been a leader if he did not cover up for Daisy, as Meghan stated, and do the right action—revealing the truth and the cause of the incident. Rather, he thought that it was more important to protect his lady than to be a leader. Gatsby, once again, hid away from the conflict and kept the truth secret, because of his fear to tell the truth, revealing his cowardice and fearfulness. After all, a brave individual would prove his courage and stand up for what is right and not be frightened to reveal an accident. Honesty and bravery are the keys to being a hero. Not cowardice and lying.
Is Jay Gatsby a hero? Well, before I can answer that question we must first find out what makes a hero. The dictionary says a hero is a man of distinguished courage or ability, admired for his brave deeds and noble qualities, but I don’t think anyone can define heroism. Every person as a different idea of what makes a person a hero, and every one of those ideas is correct. I can’t tell anybody that their opinion of a hero is right or wrong, in many of my blogs, I correct Dave, but this time he has to be right. So now the question is, in my opinion is Gatsby a hero? Gatsby illegally sold alcohol during prohibition, which was wrong. Anytime someone acts against the Constitution of the United States of America it is a capital offense and unpatriotic. One of my heroes is the 35th President of the United States, John Fitzgerald Kennedy. Kennedy cut taxes, made our country safer, and stood up to the USSR and communism. Kennedy was born into a rich family; his father was an entrepreneur, making his money from the sale of bootlegged alcohol. Kennedy lived and prospered from illegal money just like Gatsby but some, especially me, regard him as a hero. What makes Gatsby any different?
My next example is from a fictional story, but then again Gatsby is fictional too. Meghan said that Gatsby didn’t respect the value of the Buchannan’s relationship. I’m not disagreeing with her, there is a unwritten rule known among men that prohibits going after another guys girl which Gatsby broke. The Titanic, the movie not the actual ship, was a tragedy turned to love story. My example is that love story; Jack (Leonardo DiCaprio) and Rose (Kate Winslet) meet on the titanic and spend the night together. This sounds like a good story, proven by the eleven awards won including best picture, however; Rose is engaged to Caledon Hockley (Billy Zane) and Jack’s charm steals her away from her fiancĂ©. Jack didn’t respect the value of Rose and Cal’s relationship, but who could blame him Rose was clearly unhappy. Jack is the hero of the story; he saves the girl from her unhappy relationship and shows her true love even if for only one night. The premise sounds familiar, it sounds oddly like Gatsby and Daisy. Although you would have a hard time finding anybody who didn’t like Jack Dawson, yet Meghan doesn’t like Gatsby for the seemingly same reason. What makes Gatsby so different?
Ok I’ll admit that I’ve asked more questions than I answered so I guess I had better start. Gatsby’s background is no different from Kennedy’s or Jack’s and they are considered heroes. You may think that the next thing I’m going to say is “I think Gatsby is a hero”. Well if that is what you are thinking then you are wrong. I don’t like Gatsby at all he is a criminal and he deceives everyone he meets. But most of all he is a liar, that is what makes Gatsby different from Kennedy and Jack. Kennedy accepted his heritage and never covered it up, Jack won Rose over because of his personality, not riches or lies. Chronic liars should never be considered heroes, but due to the risk of sounding like a hypocrite, I can’t argue anyone who thinks that they are. I believe that a hero is a person of unconditional and unrelenting character. Heroes may exhibit different qualities but as long as they stay true to themselves and observe a code of ethics then they are heroes. Gatsby lied and lied and when you think he couldn’t possibly lie anymore, he found a way. Lying in any form is never acceptable and should never be admired or respected.
For someone to be a hero they must base their actions entirely on what is right, or else they are considered a villian. As Dave said they do not neccessarilly need superpowers and I agree entirely... for once with Dave. They must display their actions in a moral and right manner. Putting others ahead of yourself also is what makes a hero, along with the bases of courage and bravery. But as Mike said who can determine what heroism exactly is? The answer is no one. Heroism is entirely opinion oriented. So now that I have said what makes a hero, and that no one can can give the exact definition of a hero I must answer whether or not Gatsby is a hero. Just as Meghan has said that Gatsby is not a hero i agree as well. Heroes do not use deception to obtain what they want; they are good, honest people. Gatsby only wanted the wealth he had to impress people to give them a false perception to be accepted. That doesn't seem very heroic to me.
So in total perspective Gatsby is not a hero. I wouldn't neccessarily call him a villian either, but he is not a hero. He does not fit any of the qualities of a hero, nor does he display any righteous acts or motives. He has used deception to get what he wants no matter who he has to step over. Gatsby amy been seen as a hero because he fulfilled to American Dream, but as an individual person he is anything but a hero.
I believe a hero is someone who is moral and is looking out for the well-being of those around them. I don't believe Gatsby fits into this description of a hero because, like Mike said, got involved in illegal practices. He is also immoral because he is seeing Daisy even though she is married to Tom. Even though I do not believe Gatsby is a hero, I do not think of him as a villain, either. When I think of a "villain", I think of an absolutely terrible person, but I don't think Gatsby fits into that category any better.
I think of Gatsby as a normal person; not like a hero, or like a villain. Everybody has done things that they are not proud of, that are not viewed as "good". But we do not view everyone as bad or evil, so why should we view Gatsby as such? I don't think Gatsby is a hero or a villain, I think he is just a person that makes mistakes, like everybody else.
The word hero has always had negative connotations for me. In books or any type of story, the hero character is the one who always prevails in the end, gets the girl, survives all of the trials put in their way and emerges from the conflict better from the experience. I hate characters like this. There is no value to a story about a character who always wins. Since Gatsby looses what he wanted (daisy) and then gets murdered, he does not fit into my idea of a hero. Personally I couldn't be happier about that fact. The impact of the story would have been lost if Gatsby was a hero.
I have to agree with Mike when he says that Gatsby is more like a real person than anything else. The best stories are about real people, not heroes and not villains. Gatsby is a person in my eyes; maybe that’s why he was great.
I believe that Gatsby is a hero. Yes, he did get involved in illegal actions like Mike G. said, but overall he was a good person. Heroes do not always have to do the right thing for them to stay heroes. Gatsby saved Daisy from getting into trouble about hitting Myrtle. I do not think a villain would care about someone enough to take the fall for a murder. Gatsby was good to his friends and he cared about people. Villains generally do not care about their friends nor do they have friends for that matter.
Gatsby died for someone he loved. Do heroes do that? Yes they do. Villains are usually the ones who are taking away people we love. What would have happened to Daisy if she said she had killed Myrtle? She would have been arrested and sent to jail. What would have happened to Daisy’ daughter when she was arrested? She would have grown up with her mother in jail and later in life; she would have understood that her mother had killed someone. Gatsby dying was a terrible thing, but he died because he was protecting Daisy from being arrested. This is what a hero does. He protects those he loves and his loved ones loved ones.
I’m going to go against the crowd here and disagree with Dave, because I do not think anyone can give a concrete definition of a hero. As Ant said, it is completely opinionated. No one person can tell another person who their hero is. To some, yes, Gatsby may be a hero. To me personally, he is not.
A person who may see Gatbsy as a hero is probably interested in making a lot of money, or owing lavish homes and cars, and there’s nothing wrong with that. Many people would see Gatsby as a hero because of his ability to host parties that dazzled guests from both East Egg and West Egg. Very shrewd business men may see Gatsby as a hero because although he was not moral, he was a great example of entrepreneurship.
I, personally, do not view Gatsby as a hero. My opinion is that a hero is someone who works for the good of others, and someone who freely offers self-sacrifice. Gatsby does not fit my personal definition of a hero because he shows no regard for the good of the people around him, and the accident in which Myrtle was killed is a prime example of this. Although to me he’s not a hero, he’s not completely evil either. He made some morally questionable decisions, but who hasn’t? Dave described Gatsby as “a coward and a selfish liar”. I believe this is FAR too harsh, as he was simply human, and we, by nature, are imperfect. When criticizing Gatsby for him immoral behavior, we should remember what Jesus said when defending the woman who had been committing adultery, “Let he who is without sin cast the first stone.”
A hero to me would be someone who does good for all people and receives no reward for this good. A villain would be someone who does evil and has no forgiveness fo this evil whatsoever. I believe that Gatsby was neither a hero nor a villain. To agree with everyone, Gatsby was involved in many illegal activities but at the same time, every one makes mistakes. I believe Gatsby was a very confused person and unsure on many things. He let his emotions take a hold of him causing him to do irrational things. I'm not saying that this should be an excuse for some of the things that he had done, but what I am saying is that just because be make bad decisions doesn't mean that their intentions were bad or that we should judge them as being a bad person. At the same time, he does not deserve the title of a hero because when all these issues came into play, he didn't use his better judgement to do what was right. When he found himself falling for Daisy again he could've immediately ended all communication with her, but he didn't. There are many ideas that could point to Gatsby as being a hero or not being a hero. I stand behind him being neither.
I agree with Katie because I believe that Gatsby was a hero. He was a hero in the eyes of Nick Carraway. Nick looked up to Gatsby and thought he was an incredible person. To me, that is what makes someone a hero. Someone that can influence another in a positive way and create a lasting impression on them. Now, of course, Gatsby wasn't a prime example of a role model due to his involvement with bootlegging and illegal activity. But those weren't the things that made Nick look up to him so much. His superiority, while still being down to earth and as confused and messed up as Nick is what compelled Nick to him. Nick learned many things from Gatsby, whether intentional or not. Such as the devestation the want for the American Dream can bring.
Gatsby is not your typical hero. He didn't save any lives, he doesn't have any special powers, and he most certainly wasn't a moral man. But Nick thought he was great for his own reasons, and that is why he is a hero in the eyes of Nick Carraway.
A hero is a person who helps others, acts gallantly and is (bisically) the good guy.
I believe that Gatsby is a hero. He did what he could to help others and he had strong morals. He never gives up loving Daisy. When she runs into Mrs. Wilson, he loves her so much, he was willing to go to jail for her. He even watches outside her house all night to make sure she is all right. When Nick moves in, he feels lonely. Gatsby is one of the first people he makes friends with. Gatsby helps Nick fit in.
Compared to most others Gatsby is a hero. Everyone else is a villian or bystander. Daisy kills Mrs. Wilson and was cheating on Tom. Tom is cheating on Daisy. Mr. Wilson kills Gatsby. Nick never really does anything good or bad. Compared to the rest of the characters, Gatsby is the most heroic.
Post a Comment