Tuesday, November 18, 2008

Persuasive Appeals in the Crucible

Compare a scene or element from The Crucible (1996, movie) with a related scene from the play*. Evaluate the rhetorical effectiveness of these two scenes or elements; to evaluate the effectiveness, you must consider the purpose of each version. Essentially, you need to determine which version is more persuasive and discuss WHY that scene is more persuasive. Make sure you indicate which appeal(s) is(are) incorporated into the scene.

*You may compare the same scene/element in both versions (if they contain significant** differences) OR two different scenes/elements that serve similar purposes or incorporate similar ideas. ONLY choose different scenes/elements if the play does not have a corresponding scene/element for the movie scene/element (in other words, if you have chosen a scene added for the movie).

** "Significant" does not necessarily mean that the movie scene/element must have been greatly revised from the original; sometimes a seemingly minor change can totally alter your reaction to a work.

Two final reminders: Do not discuss in isolation from each other - reply to each other's evaluations (disagree or add in new insight to support the other person). Do not discuss your scenes/elements in a vacuum - they are not placed into the play/movie at random, so consider their surroundings.

Monday, November 10, 2008

The Crucible Blame Game

Throughout The Crucible, the characters often make choices to bend, distort, ignore, and even breach the truth. These decisions, though sometimes seemingly minor, create the atmosphere and conditions that allow the witch trials to run amok. Choose ONE character whose actions/words (or inactions) help the trials to flourish. Discuss how and why this character influences the events; include the extent of the blame that falls on your character's shoulders. DO NOT limit yourselves to the obvious characters - the less obvious characters generally will yield more interesting discussion ideas.