Tuesday, November 18, 2008

Persuasive Appeals in the Crucible

Compare a scene or element from The Crucible (1996, movie) with a related scene from the play*. Evaluate the rhetorical effectiveness of these two scenes or elements; to evaluate the effectiveness, you must consider the purpose of each version. Essentially, you need to determine which version is more persuasive and discuss WHY that scene is more persuasive. Make sure you indicate which appeal(s) is(are) incorporated into the scene.

*You may compare the same scene/element in both versions (if they contain significant** differences) OR two different scenes/elements that serve similar purposes or incorporate similar ideas. ONLY choose different scenes/elements if the play does not have a corresponding scene/element for the movie scene/element (in other words, if you have chosen a scene added for the movie).

** "Significant" does not necessarily mean that the movie scene/element must have been greatly revised from the original; sometimes a seemingly minor change can totally alter your reaction to a work.

Two final reminders: Do not discuss in isolation from each other - reply to each other's evaluations (disagree or add in new insight to support the other person). Do not discuss your scenes/elements in a vacuum - they are not placed into the play/movie at random, so consider their surroundings.

13 comments:

Caitlin said...

I guess no one likes this journal entry. What a shame.

Anonymous said...

I know Caitlin. I really don't want to use another skip but this entry is tough.
When is it due? Does this count as an entry? Two paragraphs, persuasive, short and to the point. I vote yes!

Ms. Alexander said...

Hmm . . . so far, only non-entries have been posted. To answer Ed's question about the due date - you have until Tuesday morning, 12/2, to post a response. Don't think of the entry as a challenge! Think of it as your chance to review the movie in terms of how well it captures the spirit of the play . . . in the context of rhetoric, of course!

Shohom said...

Well I don't know about the rest of you guys, but I felt inspired to finish the assignment after I looked at it from Ms. Alexander's point of view. That's why I'm going to sit at home on a Saturday night and do AP English work.

Ms. Alexander said...

And yet . . . no homework was posted! Does this mean that I, perhaps, detect a sarcastic tone in Shohom's reply???

Kate said...

So I'm totally going to give this a shot:

The scene from the play is when the girls are by Betty's bedside. Abigail, Mercy, Marry Warren, and Betty (in bed,shocked) are upstairs. Abigail is threatening the other girls, saying "Let either of you breathe a word... I will bring a pointy reckoning that will shudder you.."(17) Abigail turns to Betty and tells her to stop her foolish nonsense and to wake up. She does not wake. When reading this scene I thought that Miller was trying to convey a nervous, forboding mood and to show the true characters of the girls. Abigail was tough and bossy, she would do anything to clear her name. Mary Warren although she follows the crowd, she wants to tell the truth and come clean.
In the corresponing scene from the movie, Abigail, Mercy, Mary, and Betty were upstairs along with multiple other girls. Abigail threatens all the girls similarily like the book. Shortly after Abigial stops speaking, Betty rises out of her bed,starts screaming and runs towards the window. While watching this I almost jumped out of my seat, Betty's actions came as a surprise and shock to me. As Betty runs toward the window all of the girls run toward her trying to pull her away from the window. Now this symbolized, to me, that all the girls are working as a team. If the do not want to confess the truth, they are going to have to act like a team, lie as a team, and fall as a team. It shows the forboding and anticipation of the upcoming witch trials.

I gave this entry a shot, I don't know if I answered it correctly.

Caitlin said...

way to be brave Kate!

Anonymous said...

To me the scene with Abigail talking alone with Proctor in the movie version of The Crucible displayed the scene’s purpose much clearer than the corresponding one in the written play. In the movie version, where Abigail comes up to Proctor when he’s alone near his horse, it is very clear to me that Abigail is telling him the truth when she says that all of the girls made up the witch story to get out of trouble for dancing in the woods. Since she likes him so much, she will tell him the truth while she lies to everyone else. The movie makes it clear that she likes him because in a different scene with Proctor and his wife, they pretty much say that he committed adultery with her. However, in the written play version, I was not sure how far the relationship with Abigail and Proctor had gone, or if she was telling Proctor the truth when she said condemning people as witches was all an act. There is a lot of chaos going on with the girls in the forest and Abigail drinking blood that I thought for a while that Abigail might actually think that there are really witches and that she was rightly condemning them.
Because this scene in the movie made Abigail’s purpose clear, that she was making up the witches story to get out of trouble, I realized that the girls were just using pathos to get the townspeople to believe their stories about witchcraft, so that they would not get into trouble for dancing in the forest. I realized that they were just using the emotions of the moment to get the people on their side when they called out people’s names as witches. In the play, the purpose of the scene was the same, but I could not tell whether or not Abigail was telling Proctor the truth when she told him that there really were no witches. The emotions in the faces and voices of the movie made me realize that Abigail and her friends were just scared of getting in trouble, and that she only told Proctor the truth because she liked him so much and wanted his love back. This purpose drives Abigail to keep lying and condemning more witches, and ultimately Proctor’s wife, which sets up the ending of the play.

Lydia said...

Before I begin my comparison, I would like to start out by saying that generally, I think that watching the 1996 movie version of 'The Crucible' definately helped me put a clearer image of the story in my head. Seeing it actually put on screen and acted out helped me understand it better. Though the stage directions in the written version were incredibly helpful while reading, seeing the picture was incredibly beneficial to me.

The multiple paged example that I have chosen is the final scene. (Act IV: Pages 124-139)In the written version of this scene, it seems incredibly stoic and professional in the court room during the questioning of Elizabeth Proctor. Throughout this scene Reverend Hale is trying to convince Danforth (the head of council) that all of these people who are admitting to being bewitched are merely saying not to be sincere, but to protect their own lives. However, I often got confused when Hale said confusing sayings such as "I come to do the Devil's work. I come to counsel Christians that should belie themselves. There is blood on my head! Can you not see the blood on my head?!" In the stage directions, it states that "His sarcasm collapses" as he says this. I did not understand this sarcasm by only reading it. At first while I read these types of statements of Hale, I thought that he was 'switching sides' and going to tell the courts that he too was possessed by the devil. Only after the following quotes did I once again grasp onto the concept of his sarcasm. I believe this to be incredibly confusing and unnecessary while just reading the text, but when acted out (such as in the movie) it was much easier to understand this kind of sarcasm.
A physical example of the different setting was of the dialogue between Rev. Hale and Elizabeth Proctor. This conversation was in the court room, whereas in the movie it had a more 'thrown about' manner where Elizabeth was dirty, tired, and incredibly pregnant. The pregnancy, I feel, was not stressed in the book version as it was in the movie (her physical appearance that is).
I am on the written version's side in saying that the conversation between John Proctor and Goody Proctor was more thorough and easier to understand. It was direct and we knew exactly what was happening. I felt as if Miller's rhetoric was incredibly strong in this scene because (along with the stage directions) he told us exactly what was going on and how each character was feeling! It can't get more persuasive and straightforward then that!
The movie, I believe, was stronger in the scene where John Proctor was signing the accusations that were to be posted on the church doors. His agony, embarrassment, and the fear of being rejected from society and having his name slandered upon was clearly apparent through his facial expressions. The rhetoric of the producers and directors of the movie SHONE through that scene. I believe that when women cry, it is most definately more common because we are a more sensitive being. When MEN cry, it hits me especially hard. Seeing such a strong being crumble is mind boggling to me. The directors and producers of the 1996 version of 'The Crucible' put a large amount of PATHOS in their movie. An example is at the end of the movie, as Rebecca Nurse (an elderly woman) was to be hung, her husband (also an elderly man) stood in the crowd in horror and sorrow as he saw his wife being condemned to her death. I felt as if I were about to cry! Scenes such as this, I believe, support my ideas to say that the movie version of this classic is incredibly more persuasive. It hits you in the soft spot, whether that be hatred for Abigail Williams, or sadness for John Proctor.

:] sorry its so long, i just had a lot of thoughts and thought i'd share!

Anonymous said...

Like Ed said, I'm sorry to diss another entry so early but I'm sorry Ms. Alexander, but I am going to have to skip this blog too.

courtney said...

I think that the final scene in the movie when John Proctor is talking to his wife, Elizabeth, is a fairly significant part of both the movie and the play. It is normal, as Matt said, that the movie scene was clearer because of being given a visual. I was able to recognize John’s true desire to be forgiven for his sin of adultery. In the written play, you obviously could not see the true emotion put behind his famous quote, “How may I live without my name? I have given you my soul, leave me my name!” This could have been a turning point in both the play and the movie if John had stuck to signing his confession and chose to live. However, he believed inside, after talking to Elizabeth, that the only way to be fair to himself and achieve his justice, was to be hanged.
Matt also mentioned the use of pathos in the scene that he used. Pathos is used greatly throughout the written play and also I could notice it in the movie, as well. When Elizabeth talks to John about him confessing to being subject to the devil, she truly makes him look inside himself to make the best decision. The expression on John’s face showed that he knew what was the just thing to do, but as any human would want, he wanted to live. Elizabeth makes her husband look inside himself to discover the answer and show that only he can make the decision. This scene is a very emotional scene between the spouses and it displays the great use of pathos. Overall, I think that the movie provided a better understanding of all the events that took play in the play.

Shohom said...

Sarcasm? Ms. Alexander, I am hurt. I did start working on the blog on Saturday night, but—as you know—all great works of literature require patience and time. The reason I waited until Monday night to post my comment is because I wanted to refine my response well enough so it would bolster the depth of the discussion in our class.
For my discussion, I chose to analyze the scene at the end of Act I in which the girls start to randomly roar the names of the Salem “witches.” I guess it will be more effective to start with the version which I thought was less effective—the book (while the book’s rendition is effective, I believe the movie’s interpretation was more telling). The bedlam in the bedroom starts with Tituba’s accusing Sarah Good. Then Betty and Abigail join in the festivities—but just Betty and Abigail. I think the main flaw of the book’s version is that it fails to fully capture the irrationality that plagues Salem from the beginning of this whole ordeal. The fact that only two girls joined the frenzy seems anticlimactic and does not (in my opinion) appeal to the reader’s senses because it fails to emphasize the extent of the town’s foolishness. However, one thing that I believe the book did do well is illustrate the many emotions that thrived in the room at that moment. From the joy, triumph, and relief of Parris, Putnam, and Hale to the confusion, frustration, and excitement of Abby, Tituba, and Betty, the many emotions that swarm the room (seemingly at the same time) are representative of the chaos and turmoil of the entire witch trials, which convinces the reader that Salem is a really perplexed place.
In the movie, it seems like every teenage girl in Salem enters the tumult at the end of Act I. Of course, the scene itself is completely ridiculous—but that is what makes it so effective. We as an audience see tons of girls yelling the names of random people and realize that such a phenomenon is completely unrealistic. But we then see that the leaders of Salem actually believe this trash and we (subconsciously, at least) realize that the people of Salem are dreadfully misled; the craziness of the situation allows us to comprehend the craziness of Salem. Another reason the movie was more effective than the book is that the character’s motives in the movie are more easily distinguishable. As Matt said, the girls in the movie were merely concerned with their own safety—and it shows, not only on their faces but also in their voices. Because we, the audience, know what the girls’ motives are, we can truly understand the wickedness behind their actions.

jen said...

I imagined the scene where Proctor brought Mary Warren to the panel of judges to confess differently than how it was portrayed in the movie. I didn’t expect it to play out like it did. When I read that scene, I don’t think I really had a grasp on what was going on. In the play when the judges begin to question Mary, I was able to tell that she was afraid but not to the degree she was in the movie. She was terrified, which I wasn’t able to see in the play. Her speech is almost exactly the same but I think being able to see Mary’s body language helped. In the movie, she was shaking because she was so afraid and I think seeing that helped understand her fear.
Then later on in that scene, the “afflicted” girls are called into the court. In the play, only four girls are present. I’m not sure how many were in the court during the movie but it looked to be close to twenty. The amount of girls made a difference to me. When the girls are being “attacked” in the play, it was easy for them to pull if off because there was only four of them. It’s not that hard to be completely in unison with three other people, especially when they’re only copying short sentences. In the movie, there’s so much more of them that I didn’t think it was going to be believable, but it was. Even while I didn’t believe they were being attacked, I could see why the judges and other people in the room did. It’s hard for twenty people to be completely in unison and look that scared. It was also clearer in the movie how Abigail was able turn the “attacks” on and off. She used them to her advantage and then stopped as soon as the “attack” had done its purpose.