Wednesday, February 24, 2010

What's so great about The Great Gatsby?

This week, you get a more open-ended assignment than most weeks. You need to post a mini-reaction to The Great Gatsby. What did you like? Dislike? What episodes, characters, style, etc. reminded you of other novels, movies, shows, etc.? What questions do you have now that you're finished the novel? These questions should provide you with a starting point for your reaction; you will not respond to all of the questions, you will add in other thoughts, and (of course) you will interact with your classmates' ideas without repeating them.

As always, your response should include approximately 2 paragraphs of well-crafted and well-organized thoughts (no "filler" wanted!).

All responses are due by 5:00 p.m. on Wednesday, March 3rd.

9 comments:

MikeG said...

I personally liked The Great Gatsby; the story reminded me of what is happening to our country today. Gatsby and his other rich friends spent money, which they earned illegally, lavishly on expensive cars and flashy clothes. Their materialism consumed them and led to unhappiness. Greed, a major motivator in the roaring twenties, fuels some of today’s businesspersons. You may have heard in the news about bank bailouts, taxpayer money going to failing banks. Banks are failing due to bad loans to individuals with no credit or bad credit. These people defaulted on their loans because they didn’t have the sufficient funds to pay them back. The bankers only thought of their big bonus checks and had no concern with where the money was coming from or where it was going. Just like Gatsby and his friend Wolfsheim, the bankers don’t care how they get rich as long as they are rich, and they don’t care who gets hurt in the process. Gatsby’s funeral was relatively empty because his money preceded his friends and “co-workers”; no one cared enough about him to show up to his funeral. In The Great Gatsby, the rich people weren’t happy, today the bankers are laughing with an obscenely large check in their hands. Whose is unhappy and hurting because of their greed, every tax paying American whose money is going to fund banker’s greedy ways.

The American Dream, the driving force of immigration and a fundamental part of our greatness, happens to be a major theme of The Great Gatsby. I love the American Dream, it provides a wall against socialism and communism and gives equal opportunity to every hard working American. Every so often Americans lose sight of this dream, in which case we need to fight to get it back. F. Scott Fitzgerald writes about such a loss, which came right before the Great Depression. He did exactly what American needed, show us where we are going wrong because that’s the only way we can fix it. Fitzgerald could have written his book in the 1960’s, 1980’s, or right now and it would have had the same effect. We are losing, if we haven’t lost already, the part of us which makes us great, the identity that all Americans posses, the American Dream. The characters in The Great Gatsby lost sight of what’s important, the American Dream cannot exist as an individual alone. We must consider our neighbors when striving for success; we must come together under one goal, the goal to better ourselves and our country, That is the American Dream. That is why I liked The Great Gatsby as much as I did; Fitzgerald speaks for the betterment of all and what we must never forget, because if we do only bad can come from it.

Federica C said...

I honestly thought The Great Gatsby was going to be one of these boring, classic books that we are forced to read in high school. Turns out I was wrong; I really enjoyed the book. It really captured my attention in a way that made me eager to know what was coming next whether it was exciting or not. Everything Nick went through: moving to New York, which he finds lonely, meeting Gatsby, seeing how the rich and famous live; I found fascinating. Even though this was a fictional piece of work, hearing about the ups and downs a person goes through in life really interests me.
F. Scott Fitzgerald describes the city of New York as lonely. In his mini narrative of the city, Nick imagines himself picking up women and entering their lives with not a care in the world. I had never really seen this type of imagery in a book before, but I immediately connected with it because I, too, sometimes picture impossible situations.
As Mike said, The Great Gatsby is very much like today’s world. Especially when comparing the rich of the 1920s to the rich of today. They led unhappy lives in spite of their wealth and under the surface they dealt with many problems. As Nick entered into the lives of the rich and famous he was able to remain himself and not become a clone. However, he lost sight of the American Dream, as did many, which gave them no hope for success. It’s important not to lose sight of your dreams because at the end of the day your story is an inspiration to others.

Anonymous said...

Just like Federica, when I got The Great Gatsby, I thought I would be rather boring, and unable to keep my attention. Unfortunately, unlike Fred, I was right. Of course it's just a matter of opinion, but I felt like the description in the first few chapters lost my attention rather quickly. Nick's description of himself and his new home in Chapter 1 lost my attention. The description on the ashes and the giant eyes on the billboard in chapter 2 were equally boring. To finish off chapter 2, I had to read through a shouting match between the McKee’s. Books are supposed to build, however, this opening was just a little too slow for me, and therefore made me unfavorably biased for the rest of the story. The book became more interesting as it went on. The affairs that were going on, and the suspense of what would happen when Mr. Wilson and Tom found out their wives would cheating on them made the end more interesting. Then, it all had to be ruined when Myrtle, Wilson, and Gatsby dies and Daisy and Jordan parted ways. We saw how shallow all of the wealthy people were who wouldn’t even come to Gatsby's funeral, and the it left a bad feeling in my gut knowing everyone had just died. Life is hard enough. I don't need to read a book where all but two of the main characters die.

I do agree with Mike, however, that this book is closely related to some of the greed we see in our society. The greed back then caused a depression, and the greed today caused a recession. I also have to give Fitzgerald credit that he was able to switch from flashback to present without confusing me. This is not an easy task. Other than that, a slow opening with a sad ending made for an unhappy reader.

Bianca D said...

Like Federica, I thought it was going to be boring and I would just have to read it and get it over with. During the first chapter I was afraid what I thought would be right because it started out slow and boring. Nick’s move to New York didn’t do anything for me; it drug on and on. He kept talking about his loneliness and not fitting in but I knew that was going to change because the novel would not be a great hit if that’s all it was about. As the book continued I began to enjoy it more and more. Once Nick went to Gatsby’s party and began talking to him I started wanting to know what would happen next. I wanted to know how Nick’s life was going to change now that he knows Gatsby. Gatsby is sells illegal paraphernalia like people today and all throughout history have to get by, he however is far better then the others because of how well off his is. Also how can this not want you to proceed all the seeking around you know someone is going to get caught later on, so I had to keep reading.
Tom cheating on Daisy with Myrtle, Daisy cheating on Tom with Gatsby, and Nick and Jordan’s romance throughout the book really helped keep my interest. It reminds me of today’s society. Some couples are not happy with what they have so they seek someone else. They are just looking for The American Dream, but all the wrong way; which is what corrupts society as a whole.

natalieo said...

Going along with the popular first opinion, I also thought that, because The Great Gatsby was a book we have to read for school it would be boring and wouldn't be able to hold my interest, like most of the books I have ever had to read for school are. I was afraid I was right when I started reading the first chapter and began to space out and not pay attention to the words because my interest was lost. In all honest I didn't really care about the introduction because I wanted to get to the interesting part: Gatsby. If he's great like the title says I wanted to read about him, I could care less where Nick's family came from or how they lied about their heritage.
The thing I liked most about the book was that there is no hero. No one seems to ever do the right thing: Gatsby made all of his money from organized crime, Tom has an affair, Daisy runs a woman (Tom’s affair) over and proceeded to drive away and Nick, while he doesn’t do anything horrible in the book, he doesn’t stop anyone from doing wrong. I hate when a story is being told (whether it’s a movie, a book or a television show) and there is that one character who is the embodiment of good. They have good intentions, their morals are always straight and no matter what, they always prevail in the end. The Great Gatsby was devoid of any characters like this, which is why I liked it so much.

Anonymous said...

I agree with Bianca. I thought the Great Gatsby would be boring because we had to read it for school. The first couple of chapters made me sleepy. I almost could not keep making myself read the book. Once Gatsby was introduced though things started to pick up and get more interesting. I still do not think it was a very exciting book, but at least it did not put me to sleep anymore. The most exciting part was the end. It had action like Myrtle getting it by a car and Gatsby being shot by Myrtle’s husband. Nick discovered that Daisy and Tom were just concerned with themselves.
This book reminded me of those old black and white movies, where the girl and the guy cannot be together or the girl is in a better class than the boy. This is just like with Daisy and Gatsby. She is in a better social class than he is but they are still together for a little while. I really like those movies and I think I would be able to enjoy this book if it was made like that.

Unknown said...

When I first started reading this book, I had to read the first page about five times because I did not get it, and if that happens to me I usually know that I will not like the rest of the book. I was right, when I read books I need them to be interesting and not slow in the beginning. Like Tom, The first 3 chapters were so boring and just made no sense to me. Maybe I wasn’t putting enough effort into reading the book, but I was just so confused. When Daisy and Tom were first introduced Fitzgerald wrote that Tom was cheating on Daisy and when I read this it seemed that Daisy knew that Tom was cheating on her. When I read this I didn’t know the theme of the book yet, but still I was just so confused. Then as I read on I began to like the character Gatsby, but then of course Fitzgerald goes and kills him off. This greatly disappointed me, because I don’t like when interesting characters and characters I like died. When Gatsby was killed my interested in the book when even lower.

As Tom and Mike said this book did remind me of today’s society, and how some of the rich are fairly greedy and they take too much for their own good. In “The Great Gatsby” Fitzgerald shows how money can affect you, and maybe some of the people today should read this book to teach them a lesson. I would not recommend this book to anyone because I personally thought this book and boring and confusing, but if the people were exceedingly greed maybe this book would teach them a lesson.

Unknown said...

Overall, I liked The Great Gatsby, it was a very different book that included a lot of commonly used topics all pulled together into one story line. It was very interesting to me, even more then the story itself, but just looking at how Fitzgerald wrote the story and how he took on the character of Nick. Nick had a slight sense of humor which I believe kept the book moving smoothly. I feel as though most books, movies, television shows, etc. include similar ideas and story lines and I always feel they are so predictable. Half way through a movie I can almost always guess the ending or what’s coming next. That isn’t enjoyable because although they all have different characters, different settings, and a slightly different story- they are all basically the same. While reading this novel, I could never guess what was coming next and you never knew which turn the story would take. For example, while reading about the rekindled love of Gatsby and Daisy and the first time they reunited, I would have never been able to guess if they were going to wind up back together or not. I think this is a very good aspect to have in a story because it kept me reading, the main reason I could not put the book down. I also enjoyed Fitzgerald’s way of describing a place or scene. I felt as if I had a clear picture of Gatsby’s house and the dock and Gatsby’s elegant parties. When reading a story, your imagination is going to wander and you will paint a picture in your head regardless of what you are reading. However, I believe you will get a clearer picture and a better understanding of the story if you aren’t going about doing so completely blindly. In The Great Gatsby, I felt like Fitzgerald gave the perfect description and idea of the places and the people. It was just enough to help me paint an accurate picture in my head, and see what Fitzgerald saw when writing it, and what he intended for us to see. I would say that The Great Gatsby is a great story for all different types of people, it will attract all different crowds and get them hooked, which is what you should aim for when writing. And, I would recommend it to anyone

Anonymous said...

I liked The Great Gatsby and I thought it was the best book that we have read all year. Like Tori, I liked the way that Nick narrated the story, giving us Fitzgerald's point of view on our society. He used humor along with sarcasm, which made the book more enjoyable to read. The narrators in the other books were boring, and in turn made the book boring, so this was one thing I really liked about the book.

The only question I have is why didn't anybody do to Gatsby's funeral? With all of the" friends" that he had, and even the girl who loved him, nobody showed up. Nick only knew him for a few months, but he still showed up to pay his respect. This gave a sad ending to an otherwise good story