The laws of reality have been suspended (temporarily), giving Ralph Waldo Emerson the opportunity to converse with authors he never actually met. Choose ONE author that we have studied this year (summer reading authors through Fitzgerald - NOT Emerson!), and envision that author's conversation with Emerson. They will, of course, discuss the concept of self-reliance.
Before writing, decide whether the 2 authors will agree or disagree about self-reliance and social responsibility. Focus on 1-2 key areas for your dialogue so that you can develop a well-developed and insightful exchange.
You may set up your posting AS a dialogue (think play format) OR you may act at the narrator who relates what the writers said to each other when they met.
A word of warning - this assignment just might be the precursor of a major writing assignment, so I don't recommend skipping it!
All responses are due by 5:00 p.m. on Wednesday, February 24th. The usual restrictions apply (don't repeat each other); you may choose the same author as one (or a few) of your classmates, but you must devise original ideas for your post - you might even want to continue a conversation that someone else ended!
Wednesday, February 17, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

6 comments:
-mid way through a dialogue between Ralph Waldo Emerson and Arthur Miller
Miller- I completely agree, I don’t like majority thinking either.
Emerson- yea, didn’t you mention it in your play?
Mention it, my whole play focused on the trouble of group thinking. If the characters didn’t all cry witch they would have been hanged.
I’m sorry I never read it.
I read your essay, but anyway, my play took place during the Salem witch trials. After more and more of the townspeople were being accused of witchcraft, it became the “cool” thing to accuse others instead of denying the accusations.
I still don’t see the connection.
Really? The people followed the crowd.
Yea but only in the face of death, that’s more survival than it is group thinking.
Good point, but if no one cried witch to begin with then the hangings never happened, so the group thinking resulted in the executions.
Ok, is that the only connection to my widely recognized essay?
Wow, you really like to talk about yourself a lot.
Hey, I live in isolation, I talk to a few people a year, I’m going to brag a little.
Well, back to my story, your paragraph about being misunderstood.
What about it?
Whenever someone went against the crowd and denied being a witch, they were labeled as witches anyway. It was ironic, when someone was lying, everyone believed them but when they were telling the truth, no one believed them.
I get it, when someone challenged the popular belief no one could understand what they were saying.
Exactly.
Pretty clever.
Would you say that my play transcended other plays of that time?
Was that a transcendentalist joke?
Yea.
Stick to dramas.
Hey, I can be funny when I want to.
Why are playwrights such prima donnas?
Emerson is having a conversation with Arthur Miller, and they are presently debating the issue if isolation is the best way to live life.
-Miller: So what’s your position on this whole ‘live your lives in isolation’ debate?
-Emerson: Well, I still stay true to what I originally wrote in my essay. I believe that we should simply ignore whatever society is telling us, because it is usually wrong and differs from what we personally believe.
-Yes, I can see your point there, but. .
- At the same time, however, I don’t believe that we need to isolate ourselves in order to stay true to ourselves and our beliefs.
-Hmm. .Well, you definitely brought up some good points.
-Uh, yeah, thanks, I am a great philosopher! But what about you? Where do you stand?
-Well, that’s the thing. .I guess I’m not sure.
-You mean to tell me that you believe we should just be outcasts to society? To the whole world?!
-No, no! Definitely not! It just that. .Well look at the characters in my play. Pretty much all of the main characters suffered under society’s rule! What do you expect me to say??
-Anything! Anything but that! If you live in complete isolation, how will you ever show anyone your own, unique genius?!
-Let me explain. Throughout the play, we see characters suffer death and other punishments, even when no crime was committed. Now I completely disagree with the complete isolation idea, but I don’t know, sometimes I wonder if we are all better off just detaching ourselves from society, not completely, but on some level.
-I can see where you are coming from, Miller, I really can. But I believe what happened in Salem all those years ago was a result of mass hysteria and fear, not from the lack of isolation. But if I am correct, not everyone conformed. The character of John Proctor and other victims would not go along with the rest of the town, right?
-Yes, that is correct. They followed their own minds and would not be swayed by society, no matter what the cost. They would not conform.
-You see, that is what I believe to be the most important part! Society wants you to conform, to lose whatever beliefs you have, to make you exactly like everyone else. It takes true courage to go against society, especially when you are the only one doing so. And that my friend, is when we see the importance of integrity come into play.
-Well, Mr. Emerson, it sounds like we have finally completely agreed on something!
Elizabeth Cady Stanton and Ralph Waldo Emerson discuss the aspects of self reliance on one bright, sunny morning at Café dé Franco in Paris, France on April 17th, 2010.
Stanton: Someone told me about your ideas on self reliance. Is it true that you believe that one person should never follow what another person thinks?
Emerson: Well, consider it this way… I believe that every person should just follow their own genius—what a person truly believes in—rather than listening to what others say.
Stanton: I see what you mean by this. However, as I wrote my Declaration of Sentiments, I basically took the entire Declaration of Independence and changed some wording around. Do you think this is non-self reliant?
Emerson: Could I see this—err—Declaration of Sentiments that you possess?
[Stanton hands Emerson the document to Emerson, who quickly reads it. Ten minutes later, Emerson puts the document on the table and blankly stares at
Stanton.]
Stanton: What do you think? I took the idea of desiring freedom from Britain from the Declaration of Independence.
Emerson: Well, a self reliant person would definitely not follow the Declaration of Independence and copy from it. A self reliant person would, instead, develop his/her own idea, as you have done very well, and create a new, unique declaration. That certainly doesn’t mean that you should not have read the Declaration of Independence. A self reliant person would read it, but not dwell on it, and then build off of it. By doing this, the person will become great.
Stanton: Oh.
Emerson: Basically, you were imitating. And imitation is suicide. And, since you copied the Declaration of Independence, you were not nearly as widely known. After all, the Declaration of Independence has more searches on Google. Therefore, you are not as great as the original creator of freedom from Britain.
Stanton: Well, then, how come my declaration for women’s rights was still supported by many people and then published, just like the Declaration of Independence was honored and also published?
Emerson: Your supporters were simply not self reliant.
Stanton: How so?
Emerson: They followed you. That is imitation.
Stanton: Hmm… If you expect people to become great by creating their own ideas, and then you say that nobody should follow those ideas (because that would be imitation), how would that person be able to become great? Aren’t you contradicting yourself?
Emerson: A person who discovers a way to travel to another galaxy, for example, can become great. He doesn’t have to have supporters. He can be great in his own mind, because he discovered something great.
Stanton: Well, I’m sorry, Ralph, but your logic is messed up. I do not agree with your transcendentalism. A person needs support to pass a law, for example, like I have done. Otherwise, the society would have remained corrupt as it was before women got their rights. Supporters/followers change the way a government thinks. If more than one person is fighting for something, they will be more intimidating and persuasive than one person would be to the government.
Emerson: So be it. I do not follow others. I stay to what I truly believe. I will now go home and crawl into my dark alley and meditate on transcendentalism.
Stanton: Text me if you think otherwise!
An Evening with Sir Thomas and His Genius
The room slowly starts to fill up with students waiting to hear Robert Bolt and Emerson start their interview. I don’t know about everyone else but I was fidgeting in my seat. I had been waiting for this interview ever since I read about it in The Sunday Times.
Eventually everyone was settled and the interview finally began…
Emerson: First of all, I’d just like to say what a great book A Man For All Seasons was. (Everyone clapped politely as they listened to Emerson) I really felt that that book and my essay paralleled each other. What do you think?
Bolt: Yea absolutely. I mean firstly Sir Thomas More was a man of conscience and you say in your essay that what you believe is good for you is good for all men and this portrays More perfectly. He uses his genius in a way. Wouldn’t you agree?
Emerson: Yes he does, in a way by standing apart from the crowd. I totally agree with you there. But correct me if I’m wrong; Thomas More didn’t come right out and say that he disapproved of the King’s divorce, only when he was asked, did he say he disapproved if it?
Bolt: (A little hesitantly) Yes… yes this is true. However, when he did announce his disapproval, he did it with pride and he did it not only because he was asked, but he truly felt what the King was doing was wrong-
Emerson: So would you say he was misunderstood then?
Bolt: Yes, sort of in a way. He was hated more than he was misunderstood. But then again you could say hatred comes from being misunderstood couldn’t you? Think about it, a lot of people hated More because he was disagreeing with someone of so much power, whereas everyone else sided with the King solely because he was the King. People didn’t understand why someone could disagree with the King. It was almost taboo to do so.
Emerson: Yes I totally agree with you there. More was a very good example of how not to follow the crowd. I mean these days it’s so easy to follow society you just shake and nod your head when the crowd says so. You know?
Bolt: Yea absolutely. It’s a shame you know, to see very few people using their genius and not following the crowd. And More, who was definitely not the common person, to use your words, simply voiced his opinion. Tragically, he was sentenced to death and what was even more tragic; many people were relieved that he was killed. Unfortunately in today’s society a lot of people are like that. In many countries they will imprison you for speaking against your government and I just don’t see how that is justified.
Emerson: You are completely right. I suppose that’s why many people are afraid to use their genius. But you know society has instilled this fear in us causing us to either follow or not. A sort of: your either for me or against me type of way.
Bolt: Mmm yes, yes that’s very true.
Emerson: Well thank you very much for this interview Robert. It’s been a pleasure. (“Your most welcome”, said Bolt)
We will now be taking questions from the audience… Yes you sir in the green…?
A conversation between Thomas Jefferson and Emerson about their different views.
Jefferson: Now, Ralph, I think it is upsetting to see the ideas you are putting into people’s heads. How can you tell everyone to do only what is best for them and not worry about anyone else?
Emerson: Well, I believe every person has a path, and every person has a genius. Whether or not their genius falls into the common genius of society does not matter. As long as a person follows their own path and doesn’t worry about anyone else, they are doing the right thing.
Jefferson: How can you say that? You know we have some crazy people today, and you telling them that just because they believe it is right to hurt other people as long as they are staying true to themselves, that it is okay?
Emerson: Yes, we aren’t here to please the world. We shouldn’t care or worry about what other people think, say or do. We should simply be ourselves.
Jefferson: I think your ideas are completely idiotic and you are preaching this to people sending them the wrong message. You are going to start a path of distruction.
Emerson, Honestly, I appreciate you telling me how you feel. Though you disagree, you should tell me. You are following your values and I honor that. However, just as you disagree with what I am telling people, I disagree with what you are telling people also.
Jefferson: Oh really? And what is that?
Emerson: You are one of the brilliant men responsible for the writing of “The Declaration of Independence,” correct?
Jefferson: Yes, I am.
Emerson: Okay, and I totally disagree with the we, we, we. There is no we, people are to do their own thing, go on their own path. “We” should not be told we all have to act a certain way, or do a certain thing to achieve your view of happiness. Because I for one, know that I would not be happy doing these things and I would not be being true to myself.
Jefferson: Well, I can see we have very different views on how people should or should not live their lives.
Emerson: Yes definitely, and I respect that you gave your honest opinio. But, I must go. Nice talking to you.
A conversation between Emerson and Thomas Jefferson
Jefferson: Hey Ralph, how ya been?
Emerson: Eh, so-so. Being in the U.S. always aggravates me, all of these people just going through the motions to meet the status quo.
Jefferson: I’m sorry we don’t all like to live in isolation….
Emerson: It’s not about living in isolation, it’s about following your own genius.
Jefferson: People in the U.S. follow their own genius every day…Look at all of the innovative businesses we have!
Emerson: Let’s be honest, the only reason people invent things is to make a lot of money and to buy a big house in the suburbs and drive expensive cars.
Jefferson: America is the land of opportunity, Ralph. People here are free to follow their dreams…whatever they may be. Maybe you’d know that if you came out of your isolation and talked to someone every once in a while.
Emerson: Hey, don’t try to turn this on me. You started this whole “We’re gonna revolt against the crown thing”. Do you think all of those people that fought were following their own genius?
Jefferson: No, Ralph. They were doing what was best for their country…they were working for freedom and liberty for ALL people. Have you ever tried helping anyone else?
Emerson: No. Why should I help someone when I have no connection to them? It’s not my problem.
Jefferson: Believe it or not, it’s not all about you. Doesn’t your conscience ever bother you?
Emerson: No…I don’t see why I should have to help anyone else. I am self-reliant and they should be to.
Jefferson: You know, Ralph, you’re even more of a jerk than I though you were.
Emerson: I don’t care what you think of me. When I’m alone at home, I am the only person that matters.
Jefferson: I guess it’s a good thing people like you live in isolation…I gotta go. I’m meeting with some friends tonight. You should really try and make some.
Emerson: Yeah, I gotta go too. Except I have more important things to do than be with other people…I have essays to write.
Post a Comment