This post is a bit random; the idea popped into my head while I was grading homework for one of my other classes. However, I think you might enjoy this discussion . . .
If a book has a film version, is it better to read the book first or to watch the movie first? Why? Support your reasoning with specific example(s).
I'll start us off with a brief comment (yours, I'm sure, will be longer and more detailed). Normally, I staunchly support reading the book first because films always cut out and change significant parts of the story. I'll save my examples of that fiasco for later . . . but every once in awhile, I prefer the movie. I saw Jurassic Park (the movie) long before I ever read the novel; though they share the same name and some of the same plot elements, the two versions are vastly different. I did not enjoy the novel at all because it drove me crazy the whole time I was reading it; I much preferred the movie's story and I did not approve of all the "changes" made to the novel (even though the novel was written first). That said, my example doesn't necessarily contradict by position that you should read the book before you watch the movie; after all, if I had read the book first, maybe the movie would have driven me crazy!
I realize that I'm posting this assignment before blog 4 is due, but I decided to post tonight in case anyone wants to get a head start on blog 5. All responses are due by 5:00 p.m. on Wednesday, May 20th.
Wednesday, May 13, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

11 comments:
I believe that reading the book first is more essential for the imagination, while if you watch the movie you cannot establish what you think the place, people, and events will look like, because you are there watching it happen on a screen.
Take the Harry Potter novels for example. When first reading these novels I had imagined everything in my mind perfectly; the way the school looked, the charcters' personalities, and the mysterious monsters lurking in the shadows. To a fourth grader, reading the book first not only pushed my imagination, but also let me appreicate books rather than preferring to watch the movies. I feel that growing up, especially today, where technology is pushed/available to us at such a young age, we forget the great and admirable benefits reading books can bestow upon us.
In general books are more descriptive and precise, if written well. They do not have cheesy lines that big shot writers spat out like rappers spit out ryhmes. Love stories, eg The Notebook or A Walk to Remember, is a teen based romance movie. Yet the books appeal to all ages. It is not fair that we limit movies to the age where the best profit could be made, whereas the book it is based on is read by all ages or genders. I believe that movies based on books, in general, ruin the books. Hence I read the book first, as not to spoil it when I watch the movie!
I totally agree that reading the book first is much better than watching the movie. For example, I, if you did not know, have read all the Twilight novels twice before the movie came out. I then watched the movie and, as Miss Alexander mentioned, many major events in the book were missing from the film, such as the Biology lab with the blood test. This scene, in my opinion, was a pretty crucial one to the plot and therefore should not have been removed. Also, Eric was ASIAN!!! Was his character in the novel even close to resembling an asian dude? I think not! Enough with my Twilight ramblings. While I did not read the Harry Potter novels, I find the movies interesting. When I attempted for the fourth time to pick up The Sorceror's Stone, I had trouble imagining the characters besides the actors from the movie. That is the next issue when watching the film version of a book. When going back to read that book, the movie characters become implanted into your brain, preventing the imagination aspect that is o-so-important in the reading of a book is nonexistent! For another example, I read The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants one summer. I did not know there was a sequel to this book until after the movie premiered. I tried to read it and I realized that thanks to my viewing of the movie, I forgot the true plot of the book that was forgotten in the movie and my version of the characters were not present. Unfortunately, I did not finish that book due to its lame-ness. Overall, you need to read!
I firmly believe that one should read the book before seeing the movie version of it. As already mentioned, movies tend to leave out crucial parts of the novels for either time management or public appeal. And, as Kate mentioned, reading is so much more beneficial than just sitting and watching a film version. You as the reader have to imagine each scene and create all of the characters in your own mind. Reading the book before seeing the movie is also a valuable resource to compare how the director of the movie took the book and turned it from text to image. It definitely helps to see the movie, but read the book before hand lets you absorb all of its information, rather than having some Hollywood director shove his views down your throat. However, as mentioned with Jurassic Park, the movie can be much much better than the novel. Even if the reviews of the book are horrific and the reviews of the movie are spectacular, you still have to distinguish between the two for yourself.
Just like Kate, I read the Harry Potter books before seeing any of the movies, and thought it was really good. When I saw the movie, I was pretty disappointed because a lot of details were changed, although everyone else who saw it but never bothered reading the book thought that the movie was great. I think when you read the book first it gives you a lot of free space to imagine the characters and places, while the movie version only gives you one way to think of the characters and the events that take place. However, I think that if I had seen the movie first, I wouldn't have enjoyed the book because I would have wanted it to be like the movie. So for most books/movies, I think it is better to read first rather than watch the movie, even though you may not enjoy the movie quite as much if you read the book first.
However, I think that for really long, hard books that have movie versions of them, it is better to watch the movie first. For the Lord of the Rings trilogy, I saw the movie first. It was so cool with all of the special effects and great storytelling that I fell in love with it. It gave me the inspiration to go read the books, which are long with short print, and can be very boring because the author goes into great detail describing landscapes that can go on for a couple of pages at a time with nothing happening in the plot. If I had not seen the movie first, I think I would have given up on these books because I wouldn’t have realized what was happening and I would have given up once it started getting boring. But watching the movie first made me know how cool of a story it was and so I finished and enjoyed the books also.
If you want the best overall experience, I think reading first is the way to go. However, if you need a version to get you interested enough to stick with it, I think watching the movie first could be like a guide and an inspiration to help finish the really long, hard books.
As a good rule of thumb the book is usually better, if not vastly better, than the movie. Books really are a personal experience and no matter how much description are contained in the book you always have your own image of what everything looks like, when that same book becomes a movie a whole group is presented with one image that most people might not agree with. This is the reason that, in my opinion, people always say the book is better than the movie, because it disagrees with their image of the “world”. This image of the world includes events too, for instance Meghan didn’t like that they left out a scene in Twilight because she felt it was crucial but the film makers obviously didn’t so because Meghan doesn’t agree with the film makers and their vision she likes the movie less. For me personally I read the Harry Potter books before I saw the first movie and well I like the movies and enjoy them, I still prefer the books because when they read them I read them in my vision of that universe, not the director’s vision. However there have been times where the opposite, although rarely, has happened where I preferred the movie to the book, such as The Lord of the Rings Trilogy. As a little nerd who grew up on Harry Potter and Star Wars, those movies were awesome so I figured I’d read the books and it was not the best decision. The movies are pretty long but the books are longer and for the most part really boring (really boring) and unlike Matt I did not stick with them. So while I think for the most part books are better than movies there are rare exceptions where the movie is better, but my advice is always go with the book first.
As everyone has already said, reading the book first is definitely better than seeing the movie. Many of the novels that I read that actually had a film version were right in Ms. Alexander's English class. Much Ado About Nothing is an example of a Shakespeare play that was difficult for me personally to understand. After watching the movie certain aspects of the play were clearer to me and I was able to understand the play as a whole better. Although that seems unusual, I enjoyed being able to identify certain characters instead of having to guess what exactly was going on during scenes. Even if there were parts that confused me, as the movie developed I was able to relate scenes to the play. Also, as Kate mentioned, seeing the movie first takes away from developing your imagination. I know that as I read certain novels and plays, I create a picture in my mind of the setting and characters that I believe they look like.
Movies do often omit certain scenes that are essential to a story’s plot. Another movie that was seen in Ms. Alexander’s class was An Ideal Husband. In this specific movie, many parts from the play were taken out and some were even put in a different order. Reading the play first, in this case, was better because the parts that were taken out added to the understanding of the overall plot. Sitting and watching a movie is easy and does not require your mind to expand and think “outside the box.” Imagination helps to develop thinking skills and reading inspires that to occur. Being able to imagine the way a novel is and then actually having a visual, provides for a better experience with the overall story.
I agree with everybody else. Reading the book first is better than seeing the movie first. This is not just because the movies usually leave out parts that the book had, it’s also because seeing the movie first can ruin your perception of the book. Great books come out all the time, and eventually they get made into movies. Sadly to say, many times these movies are trash. I can think of many examples of this happening off the top of my head; The Cat in the Hat, A Journey to the Center of the Earth, pretty much any Stephen King movie (not that all his books are so great though), and the list goes on. If you see a bad movie version of a book, such as these, before reading it you might just assume that the book was just as bad, and miss out on reading something great. Not to mention how much content there is in the books that gets omitted in the movie. Sometimes movies don’t even acknowledge characters that were in the book! How could you just leave a person of the story like that? Because these movies simply cannot live up to the level of the books, you should definitely read the book first.
Well, despite the fact that I would love to be different in my opinion with this blog, I have to agree with everyone else in saying that reading the book is definitely better than watching the movie first. Like Kate said reading the book first allows you to use you own imagination in what each aspect of the book is about from the characters, to events, to the settings. The main reason why it is better to read the book before watching the movie is because you get a better understanding of what the author wanted to portray in their work; the book is the author’s vision and creation while the movie is the vision of the director who had the chance to change the things we all complain about. At this moment I can’t recall watching a movie after I read the book unless it was in English class. I have read the first Harry Potter book in second grade so when the movie came out it was a good refresher. Going along with Courtney, The Crucible movie brought to life the things that were happening in the book. Reading the book first allowed us to understand the rhetoric and entire back-story of why the Puritan society was being satirized. The movie also did this, but on a harsh note and elaborated many of the scenes. We come to understand the author’s vision with the book and then we come to further understand the vision of both the author and the director with the movie. I would always try to read the book first unless if the books are extensively long like the Harry Potter series, then I’d watch the movie instead. Overall, reading allows you to understand what the author’s purpose was, so read books before the movies!
Let’s give Hollywood some love! Movies do not act as leashes strapped onto our imaginations. They do not hold us back from fully understanding a plot’s central theme or message. Movies actually enhance our views on a topic and bless us with a wider perspective.
Let’s set one thing straight. The point of a movie is to take its audience on a journey where they are entranced by the unexpected but still uplifted by an inspiring message. We cannot expect moviemakers to inhibit their own imaginations by completely reproducing a previous work. By indulging the audience and providing them with exactly what they are expecting—a boring repetition—a movie falls short of its goal of taking its audience on a new and exciting journey.
Let’s think about something else. We both watched and read An Ideal Husband this year. I think we can all agree that when we read the book we could think of nothing that we could change. Oscar Wilde presented the story “the way it was supposed to be”—it did not even cross our minds to think of different ways the story could have unfolded. It was then that our imaginations were truly constricted. Sure...when we read a book we may imagine that characters look different or scenes take place in different settings. But let’s be honest with ourselves. What difference does any of that peripheral information—when all is said and done—make to our understanding of the story’s message?
Now think about the time we watched the movie in class. Every day—once we stopped watching the movie at the end of class—we immediately rattled off our own suggestions at how we would have made the movie better. Most of the times we disagreed with the way the movie was presented. But at least our imaginations were stretched and we were compelled to think outside of the box.
Watching a movie allows us to form our own version of the story in our own minds. Our minds are already open to various ideas and concepts. Reading the book afterwards would only supplement these ideas and compel us to analyze the story from yet another different viewpoint. Reading the story first is harmful because it traps our minds—we do not want to go against the writer’s wishes and therefore do not feel entitled to view the plot from alternate angles. A movie is not the “real” version of the story—so we do not feel guilty when we allow our imaginations to dream up its own ideas and concepts.
To fully understand a story the way it was meant to be told, you have to read the book first. I was also hooked on Harry Potter when I was younger and loved to read the stories. When the movie did come out, I still liked it but was a little disappointed. When you have just words, you are free to imagine the characters however you want to see them. Movies make this almost impossible, especially with all the animation that is available to directors and produces. Movies also leave out elements just like most people have mentioned. The only thing about this factor is that if you never read the book, you would not have to worry about getting angry over missing details. If you never read the book and did not have the knowledge about the book’s intricate details, than you be free to just enjoy the movie. Like Matt, I never read the Lord of the Rings books but enjoyed the movies immensely. There were times when I found myself a little lost in the plot line because I did not read the book but I was ok with that. I think I would have enjoyed the movie less if I had read the book because there is so much to imagine in that story and I would have been disappointed to have all my images limited to what the producers and special effects people came up with. Overall, it is better to read first because the book is typically what is done first. You get the most value by reading first and you can feel like a movie critic when you do go to see the film. But for long and difficult books, like Matt said, it may be better to see the movie to help you to understand where the story is going.
I have to agree with almost everyone else and say that it is better to read the book before you watch the movie. By reading, you can imagine the story, as you want it to be rather than the directors ‘and producers’ view of it. The characters are whom you seem them as and not random actors that are chosen to portray them. There has been many times where great characters are ruined because lousy actors portrayed them.
Ever since I was younger, I’ve made it a rule to read the book first. There are times when I don’t, especially if I really have no desire to. But nine times out of ten, I read the book first, mainly because of my aunt. When the first Harry Potter movie came out, my aunt planned to take my cousins. Of course, I wanted to tag along but my aunt said she wouldn’t take me unless I read the book. My cousins read the book and if I wanted to go, I had to too. I read the book. I loved the book and the movie but the book was definitely better. If I had just gone to see the movie, I probably would’ve never read the book and by doing that, I would’ve missed out on a fantastic series.
Meghan brought up The Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants. I read the books before I watched the movies. I loved them both but I can definitely see why the movie ruined the second book for Meghan. The second movie is based on the fourth book but had story lines from the second and third. Things were taken from each book and were squished together to be a 1.5 hour movie. I would’ve been lost too if I had watched the second movie first and then tried to read the book. They just don’t match up.
Sometimes it is better to watch the movie first and it can helpful when reading difficult books but I've found that those times are few and far between. Reading the book first is just better.
Post a Comment