Respond to ONE of the following quotes by articulating, explaining, and supporting your position on quote (defend, refute, or qualify . . . ). You only need 1-2 pieces of potent and appropriate evidence to support your arguments. DO NOT repeat anyone else's arguments or evidence.
OPTION 1: "You ask me why I do not write something . . . I think one's feelings waste themselves in words, they ought all to be distilled into actions and into actions which bring results." - Florence Nightingale
OPTION 2: "I declare after all there is no enjoyment like reading! How much sooner one tires of anything but a good book! When I have a house of my own, I shall be miserable if I have not an excellent library." - Jane Austen (In Pride and Prejudice)
OPTION 3: "Imagination is more important than knowledge . . ." - Albert Einstein
OPTION 4: "To travel hopefully is a better thing than to arrive." - Robert Louis Stevenson
OPTION 5: An appropriate quote of your choice (about people/society)
All responses are due by 5:00 p.m. on Thursday, May 28th.
Thursday, May 21, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

12 comments:
"Not everything that counts can be counted, and not everything that can be counted counts." - Albert Einstein
This is a very interesting quote that I whole-heartedly agree with. Some things that are very materialistic don't count for anything, and things that aren't so materialistic are extremely important. This quote can be applied to anything in society, and you will always find something that applies to it.
As I said before some things that are materialistic don't really matter. This holds true for money. Of course everyone wants to have money. But what does it really get you? That new pair of shoes you really want, or maybe a new baseball bat, these things make you happy for a little, then it goes away. If instead you donate that money to a charity, you provide something that someone else never would have otherwise had the chance to get. You give someone else a chance to experience happiness, and knowing that you made such a huge sacrifice to help someone else makes you feel great. This feeling isn't so short lived. It stays with you for a while, and that matters. It matters because instead of buying a pair of shoes you might wear once, you made a complete stranger happier then that pair of shoes would have ever made you.
This quote also applies in sports. In lacrosse, the Tewaaraton trophy is the lacrosse version of the Heisman trophy. This trophy is given to the most outstanding lacrosse player in the nation. The reason that I brought this up is that one of the Finalists, Matt Abbot is not who you would expect to be there. Usually the winner of this trophy has a lot of countable stats, goals, assists, and so on, but not Abbot. He has only 18 points (goals and assists combined), yet he looks to be one of the leaders heading in to voting. This player brings things like leadership, and defense to the table that other finalists don't have. He is one of the most versatile players in the sport. These kinds of things, defense, leadership, and versatility cannot be counted, yet for this kid, they are all that matters. Even if he doesn't get the award, it still shows how things that may not show up on the stat sheet matter, that there are things more important then goals in lacrosse, or runs in baseball that sometimes the most important things, can't be counted at all.
(This is probably not what Stevenson meant but reading on his bio, this what I thought it meant.)
"To travel hopefully is a better thing to arrive."- Robert Louis Stevenson.
Most of us wish we were older, freer, more grown-up. We go on in life as teenagers always wanting the next age, step, or path that life offers us. Instead of waiting and living now as juniors in high school, we want and wish we were juniors in college. Why not appreciate what we have, go on growing up without responsibility, why not travel hopefully not knowing what lays in store for us?
I believe that Stevenson wanted people, especially the young to love life, love the moment they are living, and the people they are with. We always plan ahead, wanting to rush things, never taking our time and looking around for the enjoyment that life brings now. We want to arrive more than the want to travel, I think is what Stevenson may have been trying to convey. Yet through the travel we become better people. We recognize the things or people we take for granted, we see the resposibilties we choose to ignore, and then we reflect on those words or actions we know were not the wiset.
The summer going into sophmore year, I went to China for two weeks then Japan for another week. While I was there I saw a whole different culture, a new perspective on happiness, and a entirely changed view on life. In the U.S. there aren't people following you around begging for money outside your house, work, or school. There aren't people taking pictures of you because they believe the way you look is beautiful or amazing to them. China holds the most breathe taking places in the world, yet the people there are some of the most ignored and poorest in the world. Now thinking about it I realize that traveling there, being the happy and innocent teenager I was, was the best thing that could make me see tht we should always live in the moment because you never know when your last moment will come.
When we arrive to wherever we are meant to go in life, it is most likely not going to be half of the fun is was getting there. Arriving home, everyday from school, sometimes is boring. Although I'm glad not to be doing anymore work, I can still talk to my friends, laugh at the stupid things that someone said, or watch the fight at the lunch table. Either way you slice it, arriving to your destanation, whether it's arriving back to a life that to some may seem extravagant based on the fact you have food or two healthy legs you can run around with or coming home from the worst day of school you've ever had, is not exciting, it is not new or different, it's just the same.
"I declare after all there is no enjoyment like reading! How much sooner one tires of anything but a good book! When i have a house of my own, I shall be miserable if I have not an excellent library." - Jane Austen
I love this quote. Books are the most intriguing form of entertainment there is. While movies and television shows portray some dude's vision or thoughts, you are able to take the ideas of someone else and make them unique and imaginative. A book is more entrancing than any show or movie, as well, giving you no better sense of satisfaction than when the novel is finally completed. It is a great journey that you can go on as you dive into one person's story, and the best part is that you can read it again! No one ever tells you "Put down that book" since no book is said to rot your brain like the television. Also, it provides the necessary reading and grammar skills in a fun and creative way. Reading allows learning to be enjoyable and interesting. Curling up with a good book allows your mind to wander and evolve as if you were one of the characters within it. For me, it is impossible to put down a good novel once I start; however, I am pretty quick to fall asleep to a "good" movie. Nothing entertains me more than a good book.
"You ask me why I do not write something . . . I think one's feelings waste themselves in words, they ought all to be distilled into actions and into actions which bring results." - Florence Nightingale
This quote is absolutely right. I may be interpreting this quote wrong, but to me it seems like it is saying talk is cheap, and I could not agree with that statement any more than I already do. Many people say they can do something, but in reality, they cannot. Many athletes have big mouths, saying they can do this or that, talking trash about someone. But when it comes time for them to put their skills to the test, they cannot perform. They cannot back up their words. Also, if you can do the actions, there is no reason to talk about it. If you know that you can beat somebody in a game of basketball, there is no point in trash talking your opponent. You should not waste your energy doing something negative instead of doing something positive, beating your opponent. Basically, there is no reason to talk or write about doing something. If you feel strongly about something, you should take action, and not just talk about doing it. That’s how I feel, and I think it is a good way to live life.
"You ask me why I do not write something . . . I think one's feelings waste themselves in words, they ought all to be distilled into actions and into actions which bring results." - Florence Nightingale
I whole-heartedly agree with this statement. Simply stating that you are going to do something does not get the job done. You must actually do something, and not just be "all talk."
Too many people in today's society (even today's Kennedy-Kenrick!) are two-faced people who do not live up to their word. People say they are going to do things, yet never act upon those words. This, in fact, is a perfect example of Nightingale's reason for night 'writing'. People waste too much time talking (or writing) about their feelings on certain topics, though they ought to be more concerned with actually doing it! Even if it is a negative occurance (such as the two-faced people example i gave previously), you are still acting out on your word and being honest with what you say. Actions provide results; good actions provide good results.
A second example is of the state and federal government officials who state their future actions in speeches, and promise the people of our state/country that they will make it a better place. Too many of these officials do not act out on what they promise in their speeches. People should stop focusing on writing good speeches and trying to make themselves sound impressive in public, and should just do something! Act out to make a better tomorrow instead of wasting tomorrow telling people about it.
Our 35th president stated in his Inaugural Address, "Ask not what your country can do for you, but what you can do for your country." This famous line delivered by JFK is a very prominent piece of history. It echoes how we as individuals should live together in our societies and in our world. Ever since I first heard this quote, it stuck with me. I totally agree with it and with President Kennedy because it is much more important to help your nation than to have it help you. This quote offers multiple meanings. On a large scale it means exactly what the text implies. It is not about what the government can give us, or the benefits and rewards but rather about the service we can do to help others. The quote can also be viewed on a smaller scale where the text is interpreted in a more general context. It is not about what others do for you, but what you do for others. This context is designed to show the listener that service is very important. It is through helping others that we can truly help ourselves. Kennedy's presidency was all about unselfishness and determination. He strived to make the world better by helping people realize their obligation to their nation. I beleive Kennedy intended both large and small meanings with his quote and his entire speech. I agree with Kennedy's quote because of what our world is experiencing today.
Earlier this year, Barack Obama was elected as president. Many said he shared the same charisma and intelligence as JFK. Obama came into office with our country in shambles, desperately trying to rebuild. We are currently and were then in an economic crisis. Many people lost their jobs and companies went out of business. As days go by, the stocks continue to drop and the job situation is worsening. Alot of people expect the government to just fix everything overnight. They request bailouts, universal health care, and job creation among other things. This is where Kennedy's speech comes into play. It really isn't about the bailouts, or the healthcare or the job creation. Sure, these are important roles of the government to help protect its people, but they are not the most important things. No matter what the government does it will never be enough and people will always be dissatisfied. What is important is how we as citizens can help our country provide for us. People volunteer for war in order to help protect us and the country. Kennedy's peace corps still exists today and continues to help the less fortunate. Many help out at homeless shelters, soup kitchens and visit the sick and imprisoned. These are people who do in fact understand Kennedy's ideals in the importance of service. However, just by doing your job you are also helping your country. Without doctors, chemists, and pharmacists we would have no need for universal healthcare because medicine would not exist. Without entrepenaurs and bussinessmen we would have no need for bailouts because there would be nothing to bailout. Without teachers we would not have students and our culture would lose the potential and bright future we have in store. Every single worker is important in the world and just by doing their job they are helping their country.
I challenge everyone to realize the importance of service and ask yourselves if you truly do what you can for the betterment of the world. We cannot expect our country and the government to fix all of our problems without our help. We helped create the mess and we need to help clean it up.
"Imagination is more important than knowledge . . ." - Albert Einstein
This is something that is very easy for a very smart man to say. He was able to accomplish everything he did because of his knowledge. He was able to teach himself most of the information he acquired and as we all know developed the theory of relativity. This came about because of the mix of imagination and knowledge Einstein had. He was able to use the knowledge he already possessed along with his imagination to come up with this theory. But without the knowledge, there would be nothing to imagine. Someone could not just come up with something like that without knowing what they are talking about. I believe that the people in this class are all very smart people. We are also all capable of using our imagination. But the idea that any of us could develop something like the theory of relativity or the atomic bomb is absurd. Einstein possessed unmatched knowledge to go along with his extremely active imagination. But all people are capable of imagining something. It is people that have the knowledge to conceive and develop their imaginations into real and operational things that are truly special. Without special knowledge, imagination is just your mind’s eye.
OPTION 3: "Imagination is more important than knowledge . . ." - Albert Einstein
Before knowledge can provide a means on how to accomplish something, it must first be thought of and imagined by someone. This is what Einstein means in his quote, and I think he is very correct (after all, he is arguably the smartest man to ever live). All of the great things of the world had to be imagined through creativity and by inspiration before knowledge could help to bring it about. For example, works of fiction do not really need knowledge to write; imagination must be first established in order for a fictitious idea to be written into a book. This can be shown in the Harry Potter series. The author did not have any actual concrete knowledge of witches or wizards, but used her imagination to create characters and events that have endeared to millions. Likewise, in the real world, Einstein himself imagined something that was unheard of beforehand, the splitting of an atom to create an atomic bomb. He had to think of an outlandish idea like this bomb before knowledge on how to build it could be put into practice. This bomb helped save thousands of soldiers’ lives in the United States from having to attack Japan on foot. Knowledge was still very important because it helped Einstein to develop plans for the bomb, but if he had not imagined it first, any amount of knowledge Einstein had would not have allowed the bomb to be built. He realized this, and with all the knowledge that he possessed, still considered imagination to be the more important of the two.
Most of us are familiar with the old adage that warns us “don’t count your chickens before they hatch.” So Oscar Wilde’s take on unborn chickens might take us by surprise at first: “People who count their chickens before they are hatched, act very wisely, because chickens run about so absurdly that it is impossible to count them accurately.” But just think about it. “Counting your chickens”—in Wilde’s terms—is the equivalent of planning effectively for a situation. Wilde is telling us that planning for a challenge is necessary because, when said situation unfolds, it is extremely difficult to plan and act at the same time. And isn’t he right?
Planning is the key to success in any situation. Every time we write an essay for class, we have to brainstorm our ideas and write multiple drafts. Why? We lay a foundation for our work when we initially collect our ideas and jot them down. We then build upon this foundation with further drafts, until we finally have arrived at a stellar piece of writing. A building’s foundation alone does not complete the entire structure, just as our rough drafts never adequately convey our ideas. It takes a continued effort and a strong will to improve in order to get the best out of the situation. But the work has to start somewhere, and the planning stage is the ideal—if not only—spot. Planning in our essay writing ensures that we know what we want to address and take the right steps in addressing it. Planning for life ensures that we are well-equipped to tackle certain challenges and take on certain endeavors.
Most of us involved in this discussion have participated in organized sports at some point in our lives. I myself used to play basketball—back in the day. I know that when I was in practice, my team, led by my coach, would prematurely “count our chickens” when we formed a game plan for an upcoming game. We could not be sure what the other team would due when we were on the court, but we could anticipate and prepare ourselves for every possible situation. If we didn’t plan ahead, we would be caught off guard in the middle of the game. We would not be aware of the other team’s weaknesses, so we could not fully employ our own strengths. We—and every other competitive sports team that ever took to a field or court—“counted chickens before they hatched.” But in doing so, we made sure that we prepared ourselves for the challenges that we were sure to face.
So go ahead and count your chickens before they hatch. Because who knows if you’ll be able to control them once they do.
"To travel hopefully is a better thing than to arrive." - Robert Louis Stevenson
I completely agree with this quote by Stevenson. In life there are going to be many journeys that people must go through, and eventually reach a destination. These journeys require certain paths to be taken. Along these paths new lessons may be learned, which can turn into life lessons. Once the journey is over, hopefully you can look back and be able to enjoy the paths that you took. This is what Stevenson means by his quote. He is not necessarily talking about an actual trip to a place, but rather a trip through life and certain experiences. If people take this quote to heart, more appreciation would be given to certain aspects that humans take for granted.
This lesson about life’s travels can be seen in everyday life, whether it’s the journey through school, relationships, or family life. At the end of a school journey, a person has obtained most of the knowledge they can for whatever career they wish to have later in life. When it is time to go out into the real world, the end of all the school travels, you should feel proud and ready to start on another travel. Life is a constant travel that at a specific time comes to an end. When life is over, hopefully a person can look back on their “travel” and be satisfied with where they have arrived.
"A guy goes nuts if he ain't got nobody, don't make no difference who he is as long as he is with ya. I tell ya, a guy gets too lonely and he gets sick." - From of Mice and Men.
Human interaction is a necessity of life so if "a guy ain't got nobody" they would get "sick". The quote is obviously not talking about psychical sickness it refers to the mental state, it is referring to insanity or going "nuts". If someone is alone, truly alone, isolated from the rest of the world they would go insane. People need to interact with one another to survive sanely.
One of the best examples of the effect that a lack of human interaction can have on a person is in cases of interrogation/torture. Isolation is used when people are being tortured for information and be interrogating. People who are kept in extreme isolation so they become so starved for human contact that they are willing to talk just they can have any basic human interaction. These people are forced by their nature to interact because they will go insane otherwise. The people being interrogated or tortured are not bothered with whom these people are but they are somebody.
This may example may come from a fictional movie but it is still valid. In the movie Castaway, Tom Hanks’ character is stranded all alone on an island. There is absolutely no one around and as a result he goes insane and even names a volleyball and treats it as a sentient human being. Besides food, water and shelter, human interaction is one of the most important aspects to a fulfilled human life. Tom Hanks’ character needs some kind of interaction even if it was from an inanimate object. He was already kind of “nuts” at that point but Wilson (the volleyball) prevented him from slipping down into a deeper and more dangerous insanity.
option 5: Years ago I recognized my kinship with all living things, and I made up my mind that I was not one bit better than the meanest on the earth. I said then and I say now, that while there is a lower class, I am in it; while there is a criminal element, I am of it; while there is a soul in prison, I am not free.
-- Eugene V. Debs
While Debs is an extreme socialist, I find this quote fascinating. I do not agree completely with it, but the point that it brings up: that we are not free while there are criminals in prison, is very interesting. I think he is trying to say that we are not free because of crime, not because the committees are imprisoned. We are all trapped in some stage of fear occasionally when walking home late at night, or going to your car after work in the dark. You never know what's around the next corner; Debs is saying that we are not free in his communistic sense, but I find the quote more about an abstract kind of enclosure and fear.
To say that you aren't better than the worst on Earth seems very humble. If everyone followed that ideology, then I feel the world would become a much happier environment in which to live. If perhaps someone decided to act like they weren't better than their neighbor, their neighbor would respect them more. There wouldn't be fights about who should cut the grass in between the two houses, or how far the hedges should be cut into either side.
Aside from the flowery language of the quote itself, it just seems like a good piece of advice for someone who feels very highly of themselves. I defend this quote, because the world and everyone in it, could use a huge slice of humble pie, which this quote happily explains how to bake.
Post a Comment