Monday, November 10, 2008
The Crucible Blame Game
Throughout The Crucible, the characters often make choices to bend, distort, ignore, and even breach the truth. These decisions, though sometimes seemingly minor, create the atmosphere and conditions that allow the witch trials to run amok. Choose ONE character whose actions/words (or inactions) help the trials to flourish. Discuss how and why this character influences the events; include the extent of the blame that falls on your character's shoulders. DO NOT limit yourselves to the obvious characters - the less obvious characters generally will yield more interesting discussion ideas.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

5 comments:
Mary Warren has one of the most influential roles in the trials but is not one of the more prevalent characters. While Proctor and Abigail are the two characters influence the trials and the events of the play the most, Mary Warren is both very important to both of them. Mary is very easily manipulated and cowardly, which is why she becomes so “useful” to Proctor and Abigail. Mary can be very easily pressured and Proctor and Abigail know exactly how to exploit this characteristic in them so that she quickly bends to their will. Mary is a tool that Proctor and Abigail both use so it does not matter that Mary knows what is right she is just not strong enough to commit herself to that right cause. It is because of this inaction that Mary is the sole reason for the trials’ continuation.
The last time that Mary appears in the play is once the power struggle that Proctor and Abigail play with Mary as their pawn reaches its climax and conclusion. Once Proctor threatens Mary to tell the truth in front of the court she has the opportunity to end the trials. Mary in that moment could have exposed Abigail and the rest but her weakness seeps through and causes her to chicken out once again. Mary quickly becomes confused and scared once Abigail and the judges start to threaten her and it becomes clear how weak she truly is, Mary loses it and begs forgiveness. Therefore the blame for the outcome of the trials can be placed almost solely on Mary but it is not truly her fault. She is not willingly giving up and not telling the truth it is because of her own character flaws, she can’t help it because it is who she is.
Elizabeth is a somewhat minor character in "The Crucible", yet her one statement helps the judges prosecute her husband. John Proctor attempts to save his wife from being denounced a witch by admitting that he and Abigail had had somewhat of a secret affair and that is why Abigail is trying to pin the puppet voodoo crime on Elizabeth. So the court tries to clarify this by having Elizabeth testify; however, she wishes to not ruin her husband's reputation by lying to the judges and saying that Proctor was always faithful. This is ironic because she thinks she is saving her husband from humiliation when little does she know that he will now be condemned a witch himself! Because of her statement and Mary Warren switching to Abigail's side, the court eventually comes to the decision that John Proctor is in alliance with the devil and tempts others. I don't think Elizabeth ever finds out that if she had told the truth her husband might not have been in any such trouble. Yet I think if she had known she was responsible for her husband's death then she would have felt very remorseful and regretful because she would be a person to blame. But John does not seem mad at her at all. He still seems to love her very much, and at the end John and Elizabeth have a very deep, loving discussion, which will be their last.
Tituba, while being somewhat of a minor character, played a big role in bringing the witch trials about. The whole debacle started when the people of Salem witnessed Tituba, Abigail, and the other girls dancing around naked one night. She was also trying to conjure up spirits for the girls. The next morning, talk of witchcraft arose when Reverend Parris’ daughter, Betty, seemed to be in a coma and could not wake up. Parris then sent for Reverend Hale, and the witch trials really took off. Hale was able to get the girls to “admit” that they had seen the devil and other people with him. Soon, many more citizens were being accused of witchcraft, and almost all of them being found guilty.
While you cannot blame Tituba for all of the deaths in the witch trials, she did inadvertently start them. She should not be viewed as negatively as some of the other characters, such as Abigail, because she did not do this out of anger or revenge, just out of fright. Tituba was being pressed by Hale and she said that other people were with the devil also so she would not be the only person in trouble. As I said before, you can blame Tituba for starting the witch trials, but she can hardly be blamed for them evolving into the mess it became
Even though a minor character would allow more discussion, I believe that Abigail was the most influential character during the trials and overall in the book. Abigail was first seen in the story in the very beginning, and even then she caused trouble by having a love affair with Proctor and a connection to Betty. It started with Abigail because she threatened the girls not to tell what they were doing in the forests, and then each one of them started to accuse people to witchery. This sparked a thrill that Abigail would never seem to control. This thrill continued as the witch trials flourished and took over as the center of everyone’s attention. Abigail led many of the trails seeing as though she was the one who called witchcraft on many women, including Elizabeth Proctor. Abigail was present when Mary Warren made Elizabeth’s puppet and the one who suffered from a needle to the stomach later. Abigail also uses her deception to cover up the truth like when Mary Warren and Proctor come to tell the truth about Abigail to the judges; Abigail claims to see a bird that is going to hurt her and all the girls follow her lead because they know if Abigail gets in trouble then they will too. Abigail is the leader of the other girls and uses them to get her ways during the trials. Abigail has most o the weight on her shoulders to the trials because she is the one who condemned women and men to the court and convinced/deceived the court with false evidence.
Out of all the characters in The Crucible, the person that was most responsible for the prolongation of the witch trials is easily Thomas Putnam. Putnam helped the trials continue, if not worsen, with all of the accusations that he and his wife made. They accused many people of being witches simply because of their own greed. He would accuse the wealthier people in town, so that when they were arrested, he could take their land from them. Luckily for him, no one questioned his accusations due the state of fear and madness that had spread through the town, so instead of being examined properly, they are just acted upon.
Although most of Putnam‘s accusations are made because of his greed, one of them is made for a whole different reason; revenge. This would be the accusation of Goody Osburn. Osburn had been the Putnam’s midwife for the birth of their seven children, all of which had died. They were very sorrowful because of their babies’ deaths, and out of shear grief, they put the blame on Osburn. The Putnam’s believed that she had placed a curse on them and their babies and that was what caused of deaths. Because of their anger they had Osburn falsely arrested and never even thought twice about it. He is not afraid to put an innocent person in jail, and that’s basically what the entire witch trials are Thus, you can clearly see that the actions and motives of Thomas Putnam make him the key reason for the survival of the witch trials
Post a Comment