Wednesday, April 29, 2009

Lies, lies, and more lies!

Respond to ONE of the following prompts. As always, respond to each other's thoughts but do not repeat one another:

1) Discuss a time when you (or someone else) lied. Explain what kind of lie was used; you may use the categories from the essay or from our class's list. Evaluate whether or not you (or the other person) should have lied in this situation.

2) Are some types of lies more acceptable than others? Is lying ever acceptable? Form a position on lying, then support it with persuasive arguments and specific examples.

All responses are due by 5:00 p.m. on Monday, May 4th.

Friday, April 17, 2009

Fitzgerald as a Catholic writer

In her 1999 article, "Gatsby's Epitaph: F. Scott Fitzgerald," Jody Bottum argues:

"The best Catholic fiction is always written by the worst Catholics. Not the saints in all their virtue - and especially not the heretics, who are willing to undo the whole of Christianity if only their vices can be redefined as secret virtues - but the sinners in all their sin are the ones who are able to create a genuine story. The best Catholic novels seem to be written by those who know, no matter how far they've fallen in faith and morals, that above them or outside them or beyond them lies a truth they did not make and cannot change"

She goes on to argue about Fitzgerald and his faith:

"But he couldn't escape it, and it pursued him like the Hound of Heaven. There's a moment in Evelyn Waugh's Brideshead Revisited when the fallen Julia tries to explain to her uncomprehending lover, the novel's narrator, Charles Ryder, why she has to leave him. And what comes out at last is an explanation that it doesn't really matter whether or not she believes that all the old, out-dated, superstitious Catholic mumbo-jumbo is true; she knows it - knows that it's true - and there's not chance of ever escaping from that. 'Sometimes,' Fitzgerald wrote to his daughter near the end of his life, 'I wish I had gone along with that gang [the pure entertainers, like the songwriter Cole Porter], but I guess I am too much a moralist at the heart and really want to preach at people in some acceptable form rather than to entertain them.' The real, inescapable Catholicism in Fitzgerald is the truth that he knows even though he doesn't believe it. And it looms over all of his fiction."

To read the rest of the article, click here. For your response, evaluate whether or not (and why) The Great Gatsby should be considered a Catholic novel. As always, use persuasive and appropriate language, incorporate specific evidence and arguments, respond to your classmates, but do not repeat other people's ideas.

All responses are due by 8:00 a.m. on Friday, April 24th.

Thursday, April 2, 2009

The Great Gatsby?

This week, your assignment is simple. Take a position on the following question: Is Gatsby a hero?

Support your position with clear, well-supported arguments (think quality of ideas/ evidence over quantity) and with persuasive rhetoric. Develop your position in relation to those of your classmates (at least of the classmates who post before you).

All responses are due by Thursday, April 9th at 5:00 p.m.

Friday, March 20, 2009

Swift's Modest Proposal

Evidently, Jonathan Swift's "A Modest Proposal" has touched a nerve or two amongst you. Present an argument to your classmates that explains why Swift's proposition (all or part of it) either DOES or DOES NOT offer a rational solution to a terrible problem. Consider both Swift's society and our society when making your case.

DO NOT repeat one another. Do, however, enter a dialogue together by building off of each others' ideas and, when appropriate, pointing out the "weaknesses" in each others' positions. Have some fun with this assignment!

All responses are due by 8:00 a.m. on Friday, March 27th.

Monday, March 16, 2009

Wilde and Modern Society

In An Ideal Husband, Oscar Wilde satirizes a host of human failings: government responsibility, spousal expectations, and lies, to name some general categories. Choose ONE, specific aspect of society satirized by Wilde, then analyze what role that problem plays in our society. Have we overcome the weakness? Have we worsened our condition? Have new layers of this aspect surfaced - for better or for worse - since Wilde wrote his play over 100 years ago? Incorporate specific evidence from our society to support your position.

While you MAY discuss the same element as some of your classmates, you may NOT recycle arguments or evidence used by them. In other words, introduce your own unique thoughts and evidence to illustrate your position.

All responses are due by 8:00 a.m. on Monday, March 23rd.