Wednesday, May 19, 2010

The Literary Potential of Popular Mr. Potter

For this week's blog, I pose a question for you: Should we classify the Harry Potter series by J.K. Rowling as literature (a.k.a. literary fiction)? Why or why not?

If you believe in the literary merit of the novels, defend your position with persuasive arguments and evidence from one or more of the novels. You also might find it useful to include evidence from outside of the the novels (in terms of public reception), but then again you might not want this additional evidence.

If you think this claim of literary merit is pure hogwash, provide persuasive arguments and evidence to support your claims. I would expect at least SOME of your evidence to come from the series, but perhaps less than that of your pro-Potter peers. Also, you might want to venture down the path of categorizing the novel: if it is NOT literary fiction, then what IS it?

Have some fun with this post, respond to your classmates, but DON'T repeat them. There's more than enough evidence, and there are more than enough arguments, for each person to come up with a stellar and unique response.

All responses are due by 5:00 p.m. on Wednesday, May 26th.

13 comments:

Meghan O. said...

Literary fiction is literature known for having beautifully developed imagery, and also very detailed characters and an inspiring plot throughout. Therefore, I believe that the Harry Potter series should be classified as this type of literature, since it contains all of these elements and many more. In the Harry Potter series, the author J.K. Rowling takes us into another world full of witches and wizards, and many more magical creatures. In order to accomplish this, she uses imagery to enhance her readers and bring them into this magical world. She describes everything she is writing about, from the characters to the locations in the novel. For example, in Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone, when we are first introduced to the character of Severus Snape, she tells us that he is a teacher with a hooked nose, sallow skin, and greasy black hair. This is just one of the many examples of imagery found in this series.
Another characteristic found in the Harry Potter series that classifies it as literary fiction is the inspiring and developing plot. There are seven books total in this particular series, yet as it progresses, the plot never sways from its purpose and it continuously builds upon the plot set in the previous books. For example, in Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone, Harry receives an invisibility cloak on Christmas during his first year at Hogwarts, and in the final book of the series, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, we learn the true significance of the gift he received seven years ago. There are several other examples that show how the plot continues to develop over the series, which show that the Harry Potter series contains a truly inspiring plot, which allows us to classify it as literary fiction.

Unknown said...

Okay so for starters, I have never read the Harry Potter series and i don't plan on it. So I don't have much knowledge of the books nor can I give a lot of concrete examples. But what I do know is that the public can generally identify crap when they see it, or in this case read it. Literature consists of strong plot, well developed characters and detailed imagery, like Meghan says. Therefore literature isn't crap. My point is that the series has been part of our culture since the 1990's. If it was a terrible book the public would have identified it as such.
I'm not saying that if everyone seems to like a certain book then it should be considered literature. What I'm saying is that there wouldn't be as much public love for the Harry Potter series if it sucked, nor would it have such a diverse fan-base or be read by people of all ages. The reason so many people like the series is probably because of its characters and storyline. And if those two things are as superb as everyone says, then it would make logical sense to call the book literature.

Bianca D said...

As Meghan said, literary fiction is full of heavy language, an abundance of imagery, characters fully detailed and the story line thought provoking. With this definition I would definitely say the Harry Potter series is literature because it is full of those qualities. In the first book, Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone, J.K. Rowling tells us exactly who Harry Potter is. He is a miserable, lonely boy with brown hair forced to live with he rude and uncaring aunt, uncle and cousin. Also, as the book continues Harry meets Ron, and J.K. Rowling describes Ron with red hair and Hermione with brown curly long hair. For every new character J.K. Rowling gives them great detail so the reader can visualize what is happening. She also describes Hogwarts, the dorms, the Great Hall, and all the other places Harry and his friends visit.
The plot behind Harry Potter keeps the audience thinking and wondering. In the first book, Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone, we find that Voldemort is still alive some how. This question isn’t answered until the sixth and seventh book when we finally find out that Voldemort placed seven horcruxes in order to stay alive. This explains the second book, Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets, when Harry destroys the diary and Tom Riddle was killed and Voldemort was weakened. The story line is continuous throughout all seven books and missing one will leave many questions unanswered. The seventh book answers all questions thought of in previous books.

Federica C said...

Literary fiction is described as a book that draws you in with language, imagery, character insight and a developing plot. J.K. Rowling demonstrates all of this beautifully in her series with her impressive writing skills. If this definition doesn’t describe Harry Potter perfectly then I don’t know what does.
J.K. Rowling’s series is a literary fiction that you only see once in a lifetime. From the first book to the last; Rowling has created a plot so unimaginable that you’re dying to know what happens next. Each book leaves you with more unanswered questions until the end when you find out everything and it all fits into place. She captures your attention so well because you’re curious to know more about the wizarding world and reading is the only way to satisfy this desire.
Another aspect that makes this series a literary fiction is her imagery. She describes the Great Hall as a never-ending room with four long tables laid with golden plates and goblets. Above their heads is a velvety, black ceiling dotted with stars that are bewitched to look like the sky outside. This is just one of the many descriptions Rowling gives us. It lets your mind create a picture to mimic this description and every time you read about it you are reminded of your creation.
Not only is her imagery creative, but also her characters are the root of this piece of literature. Throughout the book, Rowling manipulates you into becoming emotionally attached to the characters and when one of them dies, one that you were particularly fond of, you are devastated. For example, many people like Dumbledore because he was always considerate and had an extremely forgiving heart. When he was killed off in book six, fans were crushed because it was a shame to see such a wonderful character go.
It’s amazing to find a book that has all of these characteristics and not lose sight if its objective. J.K. Rowling does exactly that and that’s what makes this book literature.

DavidN said...

I personally enjoy the Harry Potter series; I have read books 4-7 and I have cherished the moments of sitting in a seat, in the midst of the sizzling, summer days, reading the novels. However, I scorn myself for admitting this, but I believe Harry Potter is not literary fiction. After about an hour of surfing the Internet, I came across the conclusion that literary fiction is not only a book with a developed plot, lots of imagery, and detailed characters, as Meghan said, but a book dependent on rhetorical appeals, persuasive devices, and other rhetorical strategies to stress a certain message. A great example of literary fiction is the classic book The Great Gatsby, which we, as a class, have read a few months ago. The Great Gatsby, a book loaded with rhetorical appeals and strategies, symbolism and persuasion, can be considered a masterpiece compared to the magical Harry Potter series. After all, The Great Gatsby contained underlying themes, including the corruptness of the upper class, while Harry Potter only has a direct, purely fictional plot of Harry Potter going to wizardry school and trying to defeat Voldemort. The purpose of Harry Potter is to entertain the readers, not to include rhetorical elements, as in The Great Gatsby, in order to unveil a hidden message. Also, Harry Potter is not on any type of reading list for AP English Language students, because the series does not have persuasive rhetoric, like in The Great Gatsby.

Now that it is understood that Harry Potter is not quite a literary fictional book, because it is merely used for teenager entertainment, not rhetorical appeals and messages, what could we classify this tremendously popular book series as? Well, considering that the Harry Potter series is directed mostly to teenagers and it is sold and read worldwide, we can safely say that Harry Potter is just simply genre fiction, or, more specifically, fantasy fiction. In contrast to literary fiction, which is, not necessarily exclusive to, but normally, a classical book that is mostly read by certain intellectual individuals, like the Great Gatsby, genre fiction applies to a mass audience. In other words, genre fiction is not as much as an educated read as is literary fiction, which usually requires the reader to work and read slowly and carefully to discover the underlying themes and messages; instead, the Harry Potter series is a book read around the world. And, also, I know people who have read the entire Harry Potter series, containing thousands and thousands of pages, insanely quickly in one or two days. These speed readers, as so I have heard, are just simply attracted to the incredible story line. I have read the four last and largest books of the series; and so, I can confirm that these books are still easy reads, compared to the literary fictional books we read in class. Finally, a website claimed that when you read the last page of a book, and you are somewhat confused (or, you need to re-read it to fully understand the context), then the book is considered to be a literary fiction. That is because a literary fiction book is more than just a simple ending (for example, the Harry Potter 7 concluded by simply mentioning that Harry and Ginny got married); rather, a literary fiction book would end with a more complex passage, not just merely stating the conclusion (for example, The Great Gatsby ended by mentioning something with the past, which is quite difficult to understand and requires more thinking).

To reinforce: I hate to discredit this marvelous and entertaining, fantastical series of wizards, sorcery, and magical creatures, but Harry Potter does not quite fit into the category of literary fiction, because it simply does not contain rhetoric.

Anonymous said...

As Federica said, literary fiction is a book that uses strong imagery and detail to draw you in. If J.K. Rowling did not use this then how could her books have become so popular around the world? She kept her audience interested and enraptured throughout seven books. If the series were not well written and wonderfully detailed then people would have stopped reading after the first or second book. J.K. Rowling weaves such wonderful stories that people want to be in these stories. They want to be Harry Potter and she wrote about these characters in such a detailed way that when one of them died, like Albus Dumbledore, that it was as if you were losing your favorite teacher and friend. To be able to do this you must be a fantastic writer.
Literature is supposed to be memorable in my mind. J.K. Rowling has made people crave her books and make them anticipate the next book so much that people are willing to wait at midnight on the day of the release to have the book. People ordered her books weeks, maybe even months, in advance. If her books were not great works of literature people would not have cared when they got their copy.

Anonymous said...

Literature does NOT have to be good. It does NOT have to have imagery. It does NOT have to be inspiring or interesting. Literature is writing on a particular subject according to the dictionary. Harry Potter is indeed writing about witchcraft. Therefore it is literature. A novel is defined as a fictitious prose narrative of considerable length and complexity, portraying characters and usually presenting a sequential organization of action and scenes. All the books have considerable length. The Great Gatsby is a novel, but is not much longer than 150 pages. The series is most definitely complex with various plots and unexpected twists. Obviously there are a great array of characters such as Harry, Hermine, Ron, Snape, Dobby, ect. Being a 7 book series in chronological order, there is a sequential organization of events and scenes. Therefore, Harry Potter is a novel, or series or novels.

I have never read the books, nor do I intend to. This brings me to my next point. I do not want to read literature. Anything I don't want to read is literature. Therefore, Harry Potter is literature. Harry Potter has captivated audiences around the world, and continues to bring in new fans with the popular films. Even though I don't ant to read it, I cannot deny it has affected the world more than many "great" literary works (Like The Great Gatsby).

Billy G said...

As Meghan said, "literary fiction is literature known for having beautifully developed imagery, and also very detailed characters and an inspiring plot throughout." I can not think of a better definition. When we think of literary fiction, classics, such as the works of Shakespeare, Hemingway and Oscar Wilde. But does the Harry Potter series fit this definition? I would say, "Yes, it does," because Rowling had great descriptions of places and events, she has created and developed characters that we, as young readers, can relate to and we "know them" well enough that we know how they will act. The plot of the story can be described as inspiring. A boy that has never known love finds friends that love him and he loves back. He is also willing to give everything for them. And even though he faces insurmountable odds, a minimally trained wizard taking on the most powerful dark wizard ever known, everything turns out well in the end. This story tells us the value of friends (Ron and Hermione are always there to help him fight Voldemort), and that love will conquer over all evils.

And to Dave, who said there is no rhetoric, Rowling gains credibility through her use of vivid imagery. The whole series is an allusion to Hitler and the Nazi Regime (Voldemort being Hitler, Muggles and Mudbloods the Jews, Death Eaters the SS or all Nazis), making the whole storie more profound. She has also added emotional and dramatic events to keep us reading. This rhetoric adds up to the fact that Harry Potter is Literary Fiction.

Mike K said...

I believe the Harry Potter novels should be considered literature. First of all, it is a written book, so by definition it is literature. Second, it has affected thousands of people worldwide. The novels were so popular that fans would be anxiously waiting for the next couple of hundreds of pages to come out. People loved the novels so much, that they have been turned into movies which people will stay up all night to see the midnight opening of.

I agree with Natalie that the general public's idea about a novel shows something, and people love this series. Like Natalie, I didn't read these book either, but by the reaction of those that love them, they must have some merit in them. There are a lot of die-hard Harry Potter fans all over the world. I believe that this worldwide love for a novel suggests that there is something to this story, so I am convinced that this series is literature.

Dan G. said...

Merriam-Webster defines literature as “writings in prose or verse; especially : writings having excellence of form or expression and expressing ideas of permanent or universal interest.” Although I have never read the Harry Potter novels, nor do I plan to, I believe they must fit this definition because of the public response. The Harry Potter novels have swept the world, captivating audiences who anxiously await the reveal of the next novel in the series. Therefore, one can conclude that the novel must use effective language in capturing the reader’s attention. If the novel’s rhetoric was dull and bleak, it would not have been able to hold the attention of its audience. The same is true for how the novel appeals to the interest of the readers. Rowling used fantasy that has been of interest to a mass audience all over the world. Therefore, it is clear that the Harry Potter series meets the criteria for literature and should be defined as such.

Unknown said...

Literature and literary fiction is full of exciting and astounding depiction. The key word is fiction, which is why Harry Potter should be classified as literary fiction because most of the things that happen in these books and movies are not real (sorry Meghan, Tori, Fred and whom ever else takes offense to this). The magic throughout the entire series could not happen in real life. It would, however, be interesting if all of it could happen. With flying cars, traffic would be a breeze to bypass. Anyway, from a more professional standpoint, the Harry Potter series is a worldwide phenomenon. Millions, perhaps billions, of people have read this series or at the very least one book; I am not one of those people. I have seen some of the movies, however, and the fiction that is portrayed is interesting to the viewer. J.K. Rowling’s job is to make people interested in what she is writing, which is the job of any great writer, which she is. People as an audience are meant to be wowed by entertainment, whether from books or movies. The fiction is what does that very job. I am not trying to say fiction is a bad thing or that it tarnishes any good series, instead, I am saying the opposite. The Harry Potter series has been an absolute success, and I wish J.K. Rowling the best of luck in the future. Although I have not read the books, the movies that I have seen were very good. And perhaps I am wrong about everything; maybe there is not fiction in this at all, but that is someone else’s job to find out if there perhaps is a true place called Hogwarts.

Unknown said...

I agree with Meghan that Harry Potter is a literary fiction. The Harry Potter series is very long and gives in depth descriptions. The character Harry is so related and that is why this series has become a huge success. In the first book, Harry is the oddball out in his home life and even when he goes to Hogwarts he is known for being "the one who lived". This is why the reader can relate to him because at some point in their lives they have felt left out or out of place. Literary fiction has, like Meghan said, detailed characters and inspiring plots. Harry, along with others, is very detailed and has many facets to his personality. The plot is about him overcoming his differences and finding a place in life he can call home, which is very inspiring. Along with that, the Harry Potter series is very long which adds to why it is a literary fiction.

Unknown said...

If you mention the Harry Potter series to anyone in the world, I bet you that they would know exactly what you are talking about. As Dan said before Literature is writings in prose or verse; especially: writings having excellence of form or expression and expressing ideas of permanent or universal interest. So should the Harry Potter series be considered Literature? I believe that it should be considered Literature. As many said before, J.K. Rowling uses rhetorical devices. She uses imagery to make you feel like you are part of the story. I have read books one through six and I’m currently on the seventh, and every time I read the books I never want to put the book down and I feel like I know the characters. The purpose of using rhetorical devices is to make your audience to keep interested in what you are writing and for them to feel like you are in the story. That is exactly what J.K. Rowling did.

In response to Dave, you can not compare the Harry Potter series to The Great Gatsby. They are two different types of Literature; obliviously is literary fiction and they are based on witches and wizards. The Great Gatsby was written in a different time period and it could easily be classified as realistic fiction. Also there are many hidden messages to Harry Potter. Some of them are: without love nothing can survive, good always prevails over evil, and true friends will always have you backs. Maybe if you read all of the books not just four through seven and reread the others you would see these messages. Another thing is since when imagery not rhetoric? Last time I check using imagery to get to the emotions of your readers is pathos, which is rhetoric.

When I read these books I feel like I am part of them and they give me important messages to live my live. Therefore Harry Potter is literary fiction.