Compare a scene or element from The Crucible (1996, movie) with a related scene from the play*. Evaluate the rhetorical effectiveness of these two scenes or elements; to evaluate the effectiveness, you must consider the purpose of each version. Essentially, you need to determine which version is more persuasive and discuss WHY that scene is more persuasive. Make sure you indicate which rhetorical appeal(s) is(are) incorporated into the scene.
*Generally speaking, you will be comparing the SAME scene/element in both the movie and the play, but this scene/ element must contain significance differences between the two versions. ONLY choose different scenes/elements if the play does not have a corresponding scene/element for the movie scene/element (in other words, if you have chosen a scene added for the movie).
** "Significant" does not necessarily mean that the movie scene/element must have been greatly revised from the original; sometimes a seemingly minor change can totally alter your reaction to a work.
Two final reminders: Do not discuss in isolation from each other - reply to your classmates' evaluations (disagree or add in new insight to support the other person). Do not discuss your scenes/elements in a vacuum - they are not placed into the play/movie at random, so consider their surroundings.
All responses are due by 8:00 a.m. on Friday, November 6th.
Thursday, October 29, 2009
Saturday, October 24, 2009
The Crucible and Modern Society
Respond to ONE of the following questions. DO NOT repeat your classmates' ideas, but DO respond to your classmates' ideas. Support all ideas with specific arguments and evidence.
1) Choose 1 example of mass fear or hysteria from modern society or from history (you may NOT choose the witch trials or the Red Scare!). Discuss the reason for this widespread fear, the extent of the fear, and the results/ significance of this fear. As part of your discussion, evaluate whether or not (and why) this fear was justified. No more than 3 people may discuss the same incident, and those three people must incorporate different arguments, perspectives, and evidence!
2) Evaluate how and how well one of the characters from The Crucible would fare in modern society. No more than 2 people may discuss the same character, and those two people must incorporate different arguments, perspectives, and evidence!
*All responses are due by 4:00 p.m. on Friday, October 30th.
1) Choose 1 example of mass fear or hysteria from modern society or from history (you may NOT choose the witch trials or the Red Scare!). Discuss the reason for this widespread fear, the extent of the fear, and the results/ significance of this fear. As part of your discussion, evaluate whether or not (and why) this fear was justified. No more than 3 people may discuss the same incident, and those three people must incorporate different arguments, perspectives, and evidence!
2) Evaluate how and how well one of the characters from The Crucible would fare in modern society. No more than 2 people may discuss the same character, and those two people must incorporate different arguments, perspectives, and evidence!
*All responses are due by 4:00 p.m. on Friday, October 30th.
Friday, October 16, 2009
Considering Characters from The Crucible
Respond to ONE of the following questions:
1. Towards which character do you feel most sympathetic? Why? Defend your choice with persuasive reasons and evidence.
2. Towards which character do you feel least sympathetic? Why? Defend your choice with persuasive reasons and evidence.
You MUST interact with your classmates' ideas. For example, if you feel sympathetic towards a different character than the person who posted before you, explain why you disagree with that person's choice (as part of your reasoning).
All responses are due by 4:00 p.m. on Friday, October 23rd.
1. Towards which character do you feel most sympathetic? Why? Defend your choice with persuasive reasons and evidence.
2. Towards which character do you feel least sympathetic? Why? Defend your choice with persuasive reasons and evidence.
You MUST interact with your classmates' ideas. For example, if you feel sympathetic towards a different character than the person who posted before you, explain why you disagree with that person's choice (as part of your reasoning).
All responses are due by 4:00 p.m. on Friday, October 23rd.
Thursday, October 8, 2009
The Crucible: Take One
Respond to ONE of the following statements. Discuss whether you agree or disagree with the statement . . . you will, of course, explain your reasoning. Support your position with a specific example from modern society (life, literature, TV, movies, science, etc.):
- Most people are like sheep, allowing themselves to be herded by one or two persistent voices. As sheep, we do not think for ourselves; instead, we trust another to make our decisions for us.
- The difference between right and wrong is always clear. Those who follow the wrong path always do so with full knowledge of their actions.
- People who are different from the masses should not be trusted. Generally, non-conformists cause trouble; therefore, they do not deserve our acceptance.
- If you truly believe in something, you should fight to uphold that belief, even if your position threatens your freedom or your life.
Tuesday, September 29, 2009
Family legends
In The Woman Warrior, Kingston intertwines myths and family legends with her own memories. Choose 1 family legend or story from YOUR family, and relate it. This story may center around you or around a parent, grandparent, or ancestor; however, as part of your description, you must discuss what this story reveals about YOU.
Have some fun with this assignment, but don't forget to develop your ideas or to proofread your work. All responses are due by 4:00 p.m. on Monday, October 5th.
Have some fun with this assignment, but don't forget to develop your ideas or to proofread your work. All responses are due by 4:00 p.m. on Monday, October 5th.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
