Wednesday, May 13, 2009

Book or Movie?

This post is a bit random; the idea popped into my head while I was grading homework for one of my other classes. However, I think you might enjoy this discussion . . .

If a book has a film version, is it better to read the book first or to watch the movie first? Why? Support your reasoning with specific example(s).

I'll start us off with a brief comment (yours, I'm sure, will be longer and more detailed). Normally, I staunchly support reading the book first because films always cut out and change significant parts of the story. I'll save my examples of that fiasco for later . . . but every once in awhile, I prefer the movie. I saw Jurassic Park (the movie) long before I ever read the novel; though they share the same name and some of the same plot elements, the two versions are vastly different. I did not enjoy the novel at all because it drove me crazy the whole time I was reading it; I much preferred the movie's story and I did not approve of all the "changes" made to the novel (even though the novel was written first). That said, my example doesn't necessarily contradict by position that you should read the book before you watch the movie; after all, if I had read the book first, maybe the movie would have driven me crazy!

I realize that I'm posting this assignment before blog 4 is due, but I decided to post tonight in case anyone wants to get a head start on blog 5. All responses are due by 5:00 p.m. on Wednesday, May 20th.

Saturday, May 9, 2009

Life After the AP Exam

Life - and English class - must continue after you take the AP English Language exam on May 13th! Though our expectations may relax a bit after the exam, we still need to work productively until the end of the school year. Therefore, I want to hear your input about possible paths to follow . . . of course, I will make the final decision about the work, but I will consider your suggestions! A few ideas to get you started (you may build off of them or introduce a totally different idea):

We could read a play; I don't have a particular play in mind right now. I always think Shakespeare makes an excellent choice - perhaps a comedy like Twelfth Night - but there are many other plays out there, too.

We could read and discuss a novel of the class's choosing.

We could explore and create unusual words. Last year, my senior AP group embarked on a dictionary project in which they (in groups) found unusual and underused words in the dictionary AND created their own words (these "new" words filled gaps in our language, where we should have had words to describe certain objects, feelings, etc.). Each group had part of the alphabet to peruse. Let me know if you want more information about this project.

Post any/all of your ideas by Thursday, May 14th at 8:00 a.m.

Wednesday, April 29, 2009

Lies, lies, and more lies!

Respond to ONE of the following prompts. As always, respond to each other's thoughts but do not repeat one another:

1) Discuss a time when you (or someone else) lied. Explain what kind of lie was used; you may use the categories from the essay or from our class's list. Evaluate whether or not you (or the other person) should have lied in this situation.

2) Are some types of lies more acceptable than others? Is lying ever acceptable? Form a position on lying, then support it with persuasive arguments and specific examples.

All responses are due by 5:00 p.m. on Monday, May 4th.

Friday, April 17, 2009

Fitzgerald as a Catholic writer

In her 1999 article, "Gatsby's Epitaph: F. Scott Fitzgerald," Jody Bottum argues:

"The best Catholic fiction is always written by the worst Catholics. Not the saints in all their virtue - and especially not the heretics, who are willing to undo the whole of Christianity if only their vices can be redefined as secret virtues - but the sinners in all their sin are the ones who are able to create a genuine story. The best Catholic novels seem to be written by those who know, no matter how far they've fallen in faith and morals, that above them or outside them or beyond them lies a truth they did not make and cannot change"

She goes on to argue about Fitzgerald and his faith:

"But he couldn't escape it, and it pursued him like the Hound of Heaven. There's a moment in Evelyn Waugh's Brideshead Revisited when the fallen Julia tries to explain to her uncomprehending lover, the novel's narrator, Charles Ryder, why she has to leave him. And what comes out at last is an explanation that it doesn't really matter whether or not she believes that all the old, out-dated, superstitious Catholic mumbo-jumbo is true; she knows it - knows that it's true - and there's not chance of ever escaping from that. 'Sometimes,' Fitzgerald wrote to his daughter near the end of his life, 'I wish I had gone along with that gang [the pure entertainers, like the songwriter Cole Porter], but I guess I am too much a moralist at the heart and really want to preach at people in some acceptable form rather than to entertain them.' The real, inescapable Catholicism in Fitzgerald is the truth that he knows even though he doesn't believe it. And it looms over all of his fiction."

To read the rest of the article, click here. For your response, evaluate whether or not (and why) The Great Gatsby should be considered a Catholic novel. As always, use persuasive and appropriate language, incorporate specific evidence and arguments, respond to your classmates, but do not repeat other people's ideas.

All responses are due by 8:00 a.m. on Friday, April 24th.

Thursday, April 2, 2009

The Great Gatsby?

This week, your assignment is simple. Take a position on the following question: Is Gatsby a hero?

Support your position with clear, well-supported arguments (think quality of ideas/ evidence over quantity) and with persuasive rhetoric. Develop your position in relation to those of your classmates (at least of the classmates who post before you).

All responses are due by Thursday, April 9th at 5:00 p.m.