Monday, January 12, 2009

Thinking about the Declaration

Respond to ONE of the following questions. No more than 4 people should respond to the same question. As always, DO NOT repeat your classmates' ideas, but DO build upon them:

1. What would happen if our entire government was dissolved tomorrow? What would life be like? Why?

2. Though Jefferson borrowed ideas from John Locke, he adapted them to suit his purposes. Locke championed the essential freedoms of "life, liberty, and property" but Jefferson altered this phrase to "life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness." What is the significance of this meaning? Which version do you prefer? Why?

3. Discuss 1 inconsistency that you see within the Declaration OR between the Declaration and actual life during the Revolutionary period. Evaluate the purpose behind and the significance of this discrepancy - does it strengthen or weaken the Declaration?

4. Choose 1 grievance against King George that seems to have a modern counterpart (a shortcoming in OUR society). Does this similarity mean that we failed to accomplish the founding fathers' goals, or is there another explanation? Explain.

5. If you were a colonist in 1776, would the Declaration have persuaded you? Explain, taking your position in society into consideration (you can choose whatever occupation/position you want, but be specific).

All responses are due by 11:00 a.m. on Monday, 1/19.

Tuesday, January 6, 2009

Ella 2: The Satirical Student

Mark Dunn satirizes American society in Ella Minnow Pea; while he does satirize the government, his satirical commentary on ordinary people is, perhaps, even more potent. Now that we have discussed various elements of Dunn's satirical purpose, you have the opportunity to choose your own satirical target (not necessarily one with a direct connection to the novel).

Some restrictions: You must focus on some aspect of society in the United States. Do NOT satirize the government (I'm a bit bored with this topic at the moment). Your satirical target could encompass ALL of society OR some small segment of society; it could focus on people, on institutional structures, on cultural establishments/rituals, etc.

The actual guidelines: Discuss the target you chose, explaining why you chose it and how you would satirize it. Option for Later posters: Instead of posting your own object of satire, you may (but are not required to) choose someone else's post and argue AGAINST satirizing that element of society.

Friday, December 19, 2008

Book Recommendation

'Tis the season to . . . read books!!! In the spirit of vacation time and reading, your assignment is to recommend a book to your classmates. Of course, you should not give away the ending or other essential information that would ruin one's reading pleasure, but you should present the book in such a way that it sounds enticing and irresistible to your classmates. This response might require 1 long paragraph instead of 2 paragraphs, but it still will be detailed (ideas and evidence).

No more than 3 people may recommend the same book: If you recommend the same book as someone(s) else, you MAY NOT incorporate ANY of the ideas included in the previous recommendations. For this assignment, I would prefer everyone to choose a different topic/book.

All responses are due by Monday, January 5th (8:00 a.m).

Monday, December 15, 2008

Ella Minnow Pea

Discuss ONE aspect of modern society that Mark Dunn satirizes in Ella Minnow Pea. Articulate what facet of society he is satirizing, why he is satirizing it, and how well he is satirizing it. Focus on 2 specific incidents from the novel as the vehicles of your analysis.

If you choose to piggy-back off of a classmate's topic, make sure you discuss new scenes and evaluate them in relation to those chosen by your classmate.

A reminder - all posts are due by 4:00 p.m. next Monday (12/22).

Wednesday, December 3, 2008

Rhetoric in the Christmas Season

The air is getting colder (inside and out!), more stations are playing Christmas music (3 at my last count), the stores are enticing customers with print and TV ads . . . yes, the Christmas season is upon us. Well, technically, the Advent season is upon us, but the commercial world always jumps directly to Christmas!

As I sit here composing your assignment, the Chipmunks are singing their Christmas song in the background (yes, Alvin still want that hula-hoop). But I digress - rhetoric abounds in the weeks (and sometimes months) leading up to Christmas. The commercial world relies on rhetoric to lighten our wallets, while the religious world (along with other well-intentioned people) relies on rhetoric to convince people to help their less fortunate neighbors. For better AND for worse, we are swayed by the rhetoric behind these agendas.

Your assignment: Choose 1 piece of this Christmas puzzle (commercial, religious, charitable, etc. - but narrowed down to one specific element), such as a particular store's advertising efforts, a particular Christmas carol, a particular charity drive, a particular Church practice (you get the idea) and discuss how that 1 thing relies on rhetorical appeal(s) - identify the appeal(s) - to persuade us to agree with its purpose/position. Of course, you must identify the purpose/position before you discuss the appeals (and evaluate their effectiveness). Somewhere in your discussion, you should reveal whether you believe this particular rhetorical persuasion is good or bad.

** A friendly reminder (that I'm sure you don't need): All your ideas must adhere to the values of our Catholic high school; otherwise, you'll earn a zero for the assignment . . .