Throughout the year, we have discussed the role of rhetoric in many works, both fiction and non-fiction. Rhetoric, however, also pervades the world around us. For this week's blog, choose one real-life example of rhetoric, discuss how and why the rhetoric is being used, then evaluate the effectiveness of the rhetoric in this situation.
As always, you may converse with your classmates' responses (indeed, you are encouraged to post in relation to their responses), but you should not repeat their ideas.
All responses are due by 5:00 p.m. on Thursday, April 22nd.
Friday, April 16, 2010
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

7 comments:
You sit down on an October evening to watch TV, and when the commercials come on you are bombarded by ad after ad promoting this election’s politicians. The whole election process is one long chain of rhetoric, especially the short television ads. These ads must appeal to the short attention span of the regular couch potatoes, while informing said couch potatoes about the candidate’s platform. The rhetoric comes in all forms, from campaign promises (which usually are lies) to the use of demographics. The politicians have to appeal to every voter, and the best way to do so is through effective language. For example, President Obama only had two years of experience in Congress, however; he mastered rhetoric. Obama knew how to play on the emotions of the working class, middle class, and the upper class in his campaign speeches and political ads, and I think we all know the result.
Another piece of political rhetoric is in the graphs and charts. These charts can sway voters based on popular opinion. If an undecided middle class voter sees a graph that shows the majority of middle class people are voting a certain way, they may be more inclined to follow that chart because if most people like them a voting a particular way they may think it that’s the best candidate for them. The graphs can also work the opposite way, back to President Obama, I saw a chart that showed 90% of campaign money from unions went to Obama. If someone doesn’t like unions, they might not vote for Obama because he supports the unions. The campaign process is all about rhetoric, and the winner is sometimes determined by how much better one candidate’s rhetoric is over another’s.
After 8 years of having George Bush as our president, America was once again ready to vote for a new leader in 2008. In the Democratic Primaries, the shoe in to win and move on to the General Elections was Hilary Clinton. Bill Richardson also was in the running, both having experience in domestic and foreign policy. However, a 2 year Senator from Illinois named Barack Obama, had something in his use that would prove to land him in the Oval Office: rhetoric.
How does a man who was not well known when the primaries started, and who had very little experience in even domestic issues let alone foreign policy beat out Hilary Clinton and then John McCain the war hero? All he did was use rhetoric in his speeches and debates. America for the most part was not happy with the last President, therefore, Obama coined the words "Change" and "Yes we can!" in order to inspire the nation that the next four years with him will be different. He gave ideas on new policies that sounded fair for "the little guy." He made a note to tell people that because he was not linked to a former president like
Hilary Clinton was, or because he was not corrupted by years in Congress like John McCain, he would be different from all the other politicians. He would be bipartisan and listen to the American people. This play on emotions, use of logic, and building of credibility slowly but surely gained him votes.
This rhetoric caused a chain of events that will long be remembered in American and even world history. Obama was the first black President, and he has implemented Socialized Medicine for the first time in American history. If it were not for his use of rhetoric, we would not have had a black president. We may have the first female president, or no socialized medicine. The world would be a very different place if it weren’t for one man, and his persuasive words.
In a time of mass segragation , one man stood among the rest for the benefit of the society as we know it. Though it has not changed that way that he hoped, or as much as he hoped he still made a diference in the lives of so many people. The man I am talking about and the accomplishment that he made is Martin Luther King Jr. closing the gap of segragation. He gave many speeches, and had many followers, even white followers as well, to help support his fight against racism in the world. His appeals were not only to the african-american public, but to the entire American public; that includes all races. He did not blame one specific race, point any fingers at any one else, he instead explained the problem to the public and rallied them together in effort to make a postive change in society.
King Jr's words in his speeches were not the only important part. Yes, the words told the plan to end segragation in the world, but it was Dr. King's attitude and the way he approaced his mass crowds awaiting to hear his speeches. His public speaking ability was key in being able to attract the crowd, and help them rally behind him. The persuasiveness of the words from his speech combined with the appeals to the people themselves, such as all of the negative effects that racism has had on everyone in the world as a whole, makes people realize what the problem truly is and that it should be stopped. Pertaining to the emotions of all people make them realize that we are all together as one, and that the only way there is a solution is for us to equally contribute to it. Sadly, Martin Luther King Jr. could not see his dream fully realized, but society is making consistant efforts towards finally putting an end to segragation.
Whether it’s from television to billboards to magazines to even vehicle-transmitted advertisements, rhetorical persuasion is all around us. There are certainly other types of advertisements than Mike and Tom’s political commercials. It just seems as though people around the world constantly attempt to bombard their products, services, and such at us everywhere we go, even in our own home: on our computers. Internet advertisements, in my mind, are one of the least effective advertisements, in general, because, during the recent years, people have found that many of these advertisements are scams. Therefore, the more experienced computer users tend to ignore the advertisements. After all, it’s tough to tell which advertisement contains a dangerous virus that will take over and destroy your computer and which advertisement is completely harmless; so, it’s usually safe to ignore all of the advertisements online. However, it mostly depends on the type of advertisement online and the personality of the user.
Let’s take a specific type of advertisement, for example: The cartoon smiley face advertisement. This advertisement is not only a bright, colorful picture to stand out and capture out attention, but it is also an audio advertisement. Automatically, once you get onto the page with the smiley face advertisement, you hear, “Say something!” in a loud voice. Less than one second later, in a rather obnoxious voice, you hear, “What?!” This advertisement solely relies on attracting attention, because these obnoxious sounds are so unexpected that the user tends to shift all attention to the advertisement, wondering where those random sounds came from. Some people, like I, find these advertisements unconditionally annoying, whereas I vow to neither go near the website they are advertising nor pay any attention to this advertisement again. It forces me to keep my volume off to avoid this further annoyance on a peaceful, internet browsing afternoon. Obviously, the purpose of this annoying advertisement is to simply spread the website around the World Wide Web. Otherwise, without annoying the Internet users, the website might remain hidden from society and have a tough time gaining customers. Other than annoying the Internet users, the creators of this advertisement stir up the emotions of the audience, as what most advertisements aim for, like in Mike and Tom’s political rhetoric. How can smiley faces stir up emotions? Well, a girl viewing this advertisement can see the “smiley dog cartoon” and respond by exclaiming, “Aw, how cute!”, thus stimulating her senses and possibly persuading her to inquire more information on how to use the smiley dog cartoon.
Honestly, I can admit that these types of annoying, loud advertisements do work persuading the audience, but mostly only for the open-minded, less experienced audience, who don’t know as much about the threats of potentially dangerous viruses.
It’s very rare that I refer to Barack Obama as a master of anything, but he is absolutely a master of rhetoric. After 8 years of listening to George Bush’s painful speeches, this country was ready for the young, charismatic, biracial, educated community organizer from Chicago. It seemed like whatever Obama said got applause. However, when one goes back and reviews these speeches, the can be quite frightening. How does Obama explain the quote, “We are five days away from transforming the United States of America”? He doesn’t. Why, you ask? Because he doesn’t have to. By using the power of rhetoric, Obama can appeal to a people that are unhappy with their government and take the emphasis off what he’s REALLY saying. It’s amazing how no one asked him what he was transforming the U.S. to. If he would have gotten up at that microphone and said, “In a week, we’ll be on our way to socialism”, the election probably wouldn’t have went in his favor. However, it’s not WHAT you say, it’s HOW you say it. A simple rephrasing goes a long way, and Obama knows how to use that to his advantage.
Obama did not stop using his rhetorical skills after he won. He rallied around the nation, suit jacket off, sleeves rolled up, giving mesmerizing speeches telling us how we’ll all have “a public option”, and how “everyone will have access to quality health care”. After all, I care about others, and I would like to see everyone have the same quality of life that I am so privileged to enjoy. Again, without Obama’s rhetorical skills, this bill probably would’ve never passed. “Government-run health care” and “socialized medicine” don’t sound nearly as appealing as “a public option” (even though it won’t really be an option at all).
Rhetoric has influenced literature and movies, and now it really is influencing the future of our nation. If one knows how to appeal to the masses of people, they can accomplish almost anything they want, after all, perception is reality.
On a personal note for President Obama, he may want to apply for Billy May’s job after his term’s over…I think he’ll be quite successful!
Proof for Obama’s “transform” quote: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_cqN4NIEtOY
In history, one place where we find strong examples of rhetoric is in speeches. There have been several people who are considered great speech makers such as Martin Luther King Jr. as Ant said and Barack Obama as Dan said. But one person who has been seen as one of the greatest speech makers of all time is, even though people don't like to hear it, Hitler. As Hitler came into power in Germany, he made many speeches and gained almost unanimous support from the people of Germany. He even persuaded the Germans that the Jews were evil and had to be killed. Anyone who could persuade millions of people to kill off an entire race most be good at making speeches. He made the people believe that it was the Jews fault that Germany lost WWI. He did this because he was a eugenicist; he wanted to make the human race better by eliminating all he thought were unfit. He mastered speech making and mastered the rhetoric necessary to make a great speech.
I must agree with Mike, Tom, Anthony, Dave, and Dan in that rhetoric is all around us, especially in advertisement. I find one main source of rhetoric in music around the world today. Music tends to have effects on everyone, whether positive or negative. Many people are influenced by all the different types of music. Some people are moved by rap music and tend to dress like rappers. Some people are more into rock n roll music, and are influenced by this music. The main thing that catches listeners' attention is the lyrics and the sound. Lyrics are the main message in a song and are what people hear the most. Whenever I hear a song the lyrics are what get stuck in my head and are what I think about. The next influenctial thing in music is the beats. The instrumentals of music always get stuck in my head also. Instrumentals can persuade people into listening to more of that artist's music are the same song over and over.
Post a Comment