Tuesday, March 23, 2010

Ideal Irony

** This post is for blog 7; if you are looking for blog 6 (due 3/24), please proceed to the correct assignment!

Oscar Wilde loved irony - verbal, situational, dramatic, he incorporated them all into his plays. Consequently, irony abounds in An Ideal Husband. Choose ONE instance of irony in the play, provide a very brief context (act and explanation of what's happening at that point - just one sentence), identify the type(s) of irony found in this example, then analyze the purpose and effect of the irony in this particular example . Your job here is two-fold because you must discuss the character's/speaker's purpose and the reaction (or non-reaction) of the other characters in that scene, AND you must discuss Wilde's purpose and its effect on his audience.

NO EXAMPLE MAY BE USED MORE THAN ONCE . . . in other words, choose your own example; don't steal from a classmate!

* All responses are due by 5:00 p.m. on Wednesday, March 31st.

10 comments:

natalieo said...

Well this isn’t exactly a scene but it strikes me as the most ironic. The title of the play is An Ideal Husband. So far we know that Sir Robert (the husband) is living a lie. He made a fortune on a scheme that no one knows about expect Mrs. Cheveley. Mrs. Chiltern, Sir Robert's wife thinks her husband is perfect and honest but in reality he's been lying to her for years. Sir Robert is anything but ideal. I suppose this would be verbal irony, maybe situational.
The only reason I can think of why Wilde would give this title to his play it to show that audience that there is no such thing as An Ideal Husband. Even when you think someone is perfect, they most likely have something they are hiding from you. This makes the audience aware of the fact that no one is perfect, that you can’t have an ideal spouse.

Unknown said...

In An Ideal Husband, there is a scene when Lady Chiltern and Mrs. Cheveley are speaking and Mrs. Cheveley shares with Lady Chiltern her plan and that her husband, Sir Robert Chiltern is going along with it. Lady Chiltern knows her husband and his beliefs and tries to explain to Mrs. Cheveley that he would never go along with such a scheme. Mrs. Cheveley is assuring Lady Chiltern that he is. This is dramatic irony because we know something that Lady Chiltern doesn’t. We know that Mrs. Cheveley has blackmail on Sir Robert and knows something about his past that would be threatening to his reputation if people found out. Mrs. Cheveley threatened him, saying that if he doesn’t help her with her scheme, she would reveal to the public his past and how he came about his wealth. Lady Chiltern is saying that he would never do such a thing because she isn’t aware he is being threatened. I think Wilde is using this irony to show us that people are very decisive and to show us how fights start. This is going to cause a fight with Sir Robert and Lady Chiltern because initially, Sir Robert lies to her, telling her that he has changed his views on the idea; simply because he is afraid to tell her that Mrs. Cheveley threatened him to go along with this.

Anonymous said...

The definition of condolences is to comfort someone suffering from grief. Lady Markby is paying a visit to Lady Brancaster and it is a visit of condolences. Why are condolences being given? Did someone die? No Lady Brancaster’s daughter is going to marry a curate, a helper priest in the Anglican Church who has very little money. I don’t think people usually give people their condolences about someone’s daughter getting married. I found this ironic. They are mourning something that should be happy. It’s like being sad that you won the Nobel Peace Prize. It’s just not how things are. Weddings are supposed to be happy occasions. You are supposed to be glad your daughter is getting married to whomever she chooses, not mourning it.

Anonymous said...

In the beginning of Act III, Lord Caversham uses Sir Robert as the perfect example of how his son, Lord Goring, should be. He says Sir Robert got where he is today by working hard and marrying a sensible woman. This is dramatic irony because the entire audience now knows at this point in the play that Sir Robert obtained his wealth and stature through illegal dealings.
Caversham merely wants to show his son how to live, not knowing what kind of a man Robert really is. Goring can have no reaction but agreement, because he too believes Robert gained his wealth through hard work. Wilde is likely trying to get across the message that most the people around Robert have no idea what he is really like, and that many people in our lives who we look up to may not be who they seem. The audience now sees how deceitful Sir Robert really is, because not even his closest friends know his past, and as we saw before, his wife did not know his past either.

Unknown said...

One instance of irony is in the scene that we read just yesterday continuing into today as well in Act III. Robert Chiltern and Lady Chiltern are arguing over the whole scheme that Mrs. Cheveley has convinced Robert to get involved with. Robert is blaming his wife for everything that has happened thus far, but later when he goes to speak with Lord Goring, he claims that it is his own fault. Robert first blaims his wife, but then tells Goring, who knows about the situation and Mrs. Cheveley's nature, that its his own fault.
The irony here is that Robert is willing to sacrifice his love for Lady Chiltern by lying to his wife by blaiming her, yet he tells Goring that he loves her and cares for her. Wilde is most likely trying to get across that the supposed "ideal husband" can never fully be honest with his wife, but it is easy for him to be honest with others. It doesn't make much sense considering honesty is the basis of all loving relationships.

Dan G. said...

In Act One, Lady Chiltern and Lord Goring discuss Mrs. Cheveley’s plan to corrupt Sir Robert into endorsing her scheme. When discussing this, Lady Chiltern refers to Mrs. Cheveley as “stupid” because they believe they are sure that Sir Robert would never do anything dishonorable. This is an example of dramatic irony because we, the audience, know that Robert did in fact sell a political position for money, which is extremely dishonorable. Lady Chiltern is so steadfast in her trust for Sir Robert because she believes he would never do anything wrong because she is not yet aware of him selling his political seat. Lord Goring also goes along with what Lady Chiltern is saying, which further encourages her already false beliefs. Wilde used this instance of dramatic irony so he could heighten the suspense of the decision of Sir Robert. When the audience knows the truth and Lady Chiltern doesn’t, it makes the audience want to become a part of the play so we could let poor Lady Chiltern know the truth before Sir Robert tells and devastates her.

Unknown said...

In Act III Lord Goring and Sir Robert Chiltern are talking and then a chair falls from the other room. Sir Robert is convinced that there is someone listening to him in the other room, and Goring keeps telling him that there is no one in there. Goring knows that there is someone in there and he thinks that it is Lady Chiltern, when we, the audience, know that it is Mrs. Cheveley.
This irony is a type of dramatic irony because we know that it is Mrs. Cheveley, and Goring thinks that it is Lady Chiltern. When Sir Robert hears the chair fall, Goring starts to get worried. If Sir Robert were to find out that it was Lady Chiltern in the drawing room he would think something was up with those to and get angry. Goring’s reaction to the chair falling is that he will try anything to try and get Sir Robert out of the house. I think that Wilde’s purpose of this was to have his audience laugh at Goring’s reaction and to understand how much Goring does not want to upset Sir Robert.

Billy G said...

In Act three, when Lord Goring and Sir Robert Chiltern are talking in the smoking room, Mrs. Cheveley is listening in the drawing room. Goring thinks that it is Lady Chiltern, whom he wanted to listen to their conversation. This is dramatic irony because we know that Mrs. Cheveley is listening, Goring thinks it is Lady Chiltern and Robert doesn't know anyone is there. He used this irony to make his audience laugh. When Robert finds Cheveley, he talks bad about her. Goring thinks he is talking to his wife so he is confused. to watch this play out would be pretty funny.

Unknown said...

In Act 3, Sir Robert Chiltern and Lord Goring are talking about Robert's situation with his wife being mad at him, while Mrs. Cheveley is listening to the whole thing. Lord Goring thinks that Lady Chiltern is the one in the other room listening, while Robert sees Mrs. Cheveley and thinks that Lord Goring set him up. The irony is situational because Lord Goring thinks that one person is listening in the other room when it is a completely different person. This is humorous because Robert then goes on to call her "a vile, an infamous thing!" Lord Goring has no idea why he would say this about his wife, until he sees Mrs. Cheveley and realizes what has happened. Lord Goring had intended Lady Chiltern to be listening in on the conversation because he wanted to fix things between her and her husband, but in the end because Lady Chiltern was not the one listening in the other room, Sir Robert Chiltern is mad at Lord Goring because he thinks that he has been set up by his friend. Oscar Wilde's purpous of this irony is to show that Mrs. Cheveley is very sneaking and seems to be ruining Robert's life. The effect on the audience is humor, because the audience knows Mrs. Cheveley is the one listening.

Unknown said...

In the very first scene of "An Ideal Husband", Mrs. Marchmont and Lady Basildon are having a discussion. They are at a party, and Lady Basildon is telling Mrs. Marchmont how she went out to dinner with a man and he talked about his wife the whole time. Mrs. Marchmont proceeds to tell Lady Basildon that went she went to dinner with a man he talked about her the whole time and how it was quite uninteresting. The irony is this scene is very verbal. You would think that when a man takes a woman out, he would not talk about his wife, and that if you went out with this man, you would not want to tell people that he has a wife. Some British women are stereotyped, and you would think that if any man carried out a conversation about the woman herself, she would be quite satisfied. Mrs. Marchmont is completely turned off by the topic of herself and refers to it as "trivial".