Thursday, March 11, 2010

The American Dream and 21st Century Culture

In the mid-1800s, Ralph Waldo Emerson theorized about the American psyche and the Dream that allowed men to pull themselves up in society . . . and he considered the West with its irresistible allure. In the mid-1920s, Francis Scott Fitzgerald worried that the American Dream was slipping away, that society had allowed the Dream to warp into something destructive and unattainable.

How does society in 2010 view the American Dream? Is it more warped than in Fitzgerald's time? Have we reworked this Dream into something beneficial and attainable? Can we have the Dream without an unsettled West? Does anyone care about the Dream anymore? Do people still consider the United States to a land of opportunities?

Choose ONE recent work (novel, play, movie, or TV show) and discuss how that work portrays American life and, more importantly, the American Dream. Make sure you spend PART of your analysis explaining whether or not you agree with the position developed in the work.

*As always, interact with your classmates, but do NOT repeat them.

** All responses are due by 6:00 p.m. on Wednesday, March 17th.

9 comments:

Anonymous said...

The Blind Side is a very recent film about Michael Oher, a current offensive lineman for the Baltimore Ravens. The film is a true story about how Michael Oher grew up in terrible conditions without parents, and went from one bad foster home to another. Eventually, he was taken in by a family who cared for him, and was noticed for his tremendous football skill in high school. However, he still must overcome a learning disability he has in order to have a high enough GPA for a football scholarship. After working hard in high school and at Ole Miss College where he had a scholarship, he gets drafted in the first round of the NFL Draft by the Baltimore Ravens. The film shows that America is far from perfect. There are many kids and teens with no real parents who live in terrible conditions just as depicted in the movie. However, it also shows how with hard work, anyone, even a poor boy with a learning disability, can become successful using his/her talents.

It is clear from this film that the American dream can be attained, and that Americans still care about the American Dream. It does not matter that some people are greedy, or that there is no more land in the west. One of the lead actresses, Sandra Bullock, won best actress for the film, and the film was successful in the box office. This shows Americans still care about stories in which a person goes from a "no one" to a "someone." Yes, there are greedy extravagant people now just as there were when The Great Gatsby was written. Obviously if people gave as much as they could to the poor, there would not be as many situations like Oher found himself in when he was a kid. But I believe in the message this film brings: anyone, whether they are smart, athletic, musically talented, a good craftsman, or even just average can work their way up in society with hard work the ACHIEVE the American Dream.

Unknown said...

"The Pursuit of Happyness" is a relatively recent film from 2006 about a man, Chris Gardner, who comes from literally nothing in his salesmans job to later be a rich, successful stockbroker. This was entirely based on a true story. Gardner is trying to support his son with the minimal money that he makes because he cannot sell his merchandise. Will Smith stars in this role along with his son. This depicts the American dream as it has been said to be; come from nothing and obtain unimaginable success. Gardner works incredibly hard for the job taking every class/test that he has to, along with working his job and having to find a place to live for his son and himself.

The American dream, though it can be seen differently, still has the same message; everyone has the equal opportunity to succeed in this country. It is just a matter if people give the time, effort, and determination to reach their goals and dreams. Chris Gardner gave it all that he had for the love of his son and that lead him to become a very successful man in the stockbroking department. Not bad for a guy who was living on the streets to later be a millionaire.

Bianca D said...

Precious is a movie that came out in 2009 based off the novel Push by Sapphire where an obese African-American girl names Precious Jones becomes pregnant with her second child wants to find a way to make her life better. The life she is born into is a life no one wishes for, a father who is the one who got her pregnant both times and a mother who emotionally and physically abuse her, as well as being illiterate in the ninth grade. As she goes on living this life she is offered to transfer to a new school, unsure if what she sees is the right way to go, she listens to her instincts and transfers. Once there a teacher by the name of Ms. Rain helps Precious move on from her painful life to a new and happier one. This is sadly how a lot of people live their life and only some have the will power to surpass it. Like Tom said in his, the movie and novel shows where hard work can get you; nothing is given, everything must be achieved.
I believe people still try to reach the American Dream, some just go about it the wrong way. The novel or movie can be seen as Precious going for the Dream the right way by bettering herself and focusing on help rather then harm; whereas her father or mother went about it the wrong way by harming poor Precious. The American Dream is out there just waiting to be reached; however, money still and probably will always be the problem, beat is this and the American Dream will be yours.

Federica C said...

“The Pursuit of Happyness” is the true story of a man named Chris Gardner, played by Will Smith, who invests all of his savings in a device much like an X-ray, but with a higher resolution. He eventually becomes bankrupt which causes his wife to leave him. With no money, no job and no wife, Gardner was forced to care for his son. They both faced many hardships and were forced to stay in a homeless shelter that did not guarantee a bed to sleep in. Being a clever guy, Chris uses his intellect to apply for the position as a stockbroker, which required six months unpaid training. One thing that is ever present throughout the entire movie is Chris’s motivation to get the job. He wants to succeed and make a better life for his son. Finally, at the end of his six months, Chris’s hard work paid off. He was offered the job as a stockbroker and the weight of the world was finally lifted off his shoulders because he knew that everything was going to be ok.

“If at first you don’t succeed, try again.” This is exactly the motivation Chris had that got him where he is today. He did achieve the American Dream but not because he was chasing his goals and desires, but because he cared about his son so much that he would not rest until he got this job. Chris wanted his son to have the best life he could and he made sure that he would meet that goal. “The Pursuit of Happyness” also did well in the box office and Will Smith was nominated for best actor. This shows us, like Tom said, that people love to hear success stories. Seeing people come from nothing and progress into something great, gives hope to those who think they are worthless and can’t do anything. I too agree with the message of this movie: If you are trying to reach your goal and you fail, try and try again because every time you fail you learn something new which just brings you one step closer to achieving your dream.

Anonymous said...

The American dream can be many things. It can be finding a home, getting married and living a good life or it can be to bring together two broken halves of a nation and put them together. This is what happened in “Remember the Titans”. Two southern schools decided to combine with each other. The only problem was that one school was for African Americans and the other was for whites. They decided to end the segregation that was keeping these two schools apart. The football teams fro these two schools needed to combine. Initially, the players thought that they would never be able to come together as a team. But their coach, who is played by Denzel Washington, takes them to Gettysburg for a football camp. By the end of the camp they have become a united”nation”. When they return back home there is still lots of tension in the town about the desegregation. The boys on the football team are an example of how people can come together and get over whatever differences they might have. By the end of the movie, the team and the town are joined together as a strong “nation” of people.

The purpose of this movie is to show that whatever your differences maybe you can overcome them. This is an American dream. No one wants to be told they are different and because they are different they will be treated badly. Everyone wants to be treated the same as everyone else. Like Bianca said people are still trying to reach the American dream. They can get it through hard work and determination.

Unknown said...

The Pursuit of Happiness and Precious are two excellent movies that convey an accurate portrayal of what the American Dream appears to be in The Great Gatsby. The American Dream that appears in The Great Gatsby is basically that money can buy happiness. Although I believe this statement is false, this version of the American Dream still exists in some people's lives today. This American Dream being that money is the most important thing in life.

In the movie Notorious (2009), we experience the life and death of the song writer and artist, Christopher Wallace, aka Notorious B.I.G., aka Biggie Smalls. This movie shows the struggles and problems that Christopher came across in his journey of fame and fortune, and achieving his version of the American Dream. A lot of these struggles consisted of family issues and drugs. The most dominant cause of his struggles was money. Money revolved around every decision that was made and led to greater issues. At one point in the movie, Christopher is at his prime and has made the most money and is the happiest he has ever been. Immediately after this, he is murdered in the streets of L.A. I believe this movie shows us that money cannot buy happiness, and if it does, this happiness does not always last. As well as the Blind Side and the Pursuit of Happiness, you see that sometimes certain versions of the American Dream can be reached, but in the long run, if you do not appreciate the more important things in life, then there isn't much that money can do for you. As they say, money won't keep you warm at night.

Unknown said...

‘Chicago’ is a movie and/or musical about a woman named Roxie who always dreamed of becoming big in Vaudeville and a woman named Velma who was on Vaudeville. They both have one thing in common they both killed people. Roxie wanted to be on Vaudeville so badly that she had an affair with a man, who said that he could get her an audition, and after he said that she was just using her she killed him. Velma was on Vaudeville and had a husband and her life seemed great, but one night she walked in on her husband and her sister having an affair and killed them. They are both put into jail and desperately want to get and make it big or come back to Vaudeville. They would try anything to get out of jail and have the wonderful life they are suppose to have.

Even though this movie/play was set in the 1920’s, it shows that the American Dream is still in people’s minds. ‘Chicago’ represents that anyone would do anything to try and get the American Dream. The characters in ‘Chicago’ thought that money was everything and they dreamed of making it big and that’s what would make them happy. Like Fitzgerald, this movie shows the wrong ways to go and try and achieve the American Dream.

Billy G said...

In the modern world, the American dream is attainable. The problem to getting the American dream is that most people don't know what it is. We often believe that it is material things that will make us happy. But what will truly make us happy are things like family and friends and helping others. Company has a great way of making us happy. The same effect can come making others happy.
Many movies and other works have touched on this subject. But one that I see does it very well is Iron Man. Although it wouldn't seem that a comic book action movie would have a message like this, it does. When Tony Stark only cares for himself he wasn't really happy. he was always wanting more, but you know when you achieve the dream when you are happy with what you have. When he becomes Iron Man and saves the world and falls in love, that is when is happy.

Dan G. said...

The American Dream is multi-faceted for some, but very simple for others. Much of one’s view of the American Dream is based on their background, because success for one person might be failure for another. In the hit TV show “Undercover Boss”, a man named Igor gives a very inspiring view of the American Dream that should instill a sense of pride for all Americans. Seven years ago, Igor immigrated the U.S. from Kazakhstan, a small, poor country in the Middle East. He works as a truck driver on the overnight shift for 7-11, making local deliveries to many busy convenient stores. In the show, the CEO of 7-11 rides along with Igor on his route. However, Igor thinks the CEO is just another truck driver in training. In the course of the night, the CEO finds out that Igor’s wife works the day shift, so he only is able to spend time with her on weekends. This surprises the CEO because Igor has a true passion for his job, and has a lot of fun in a job that many would find miserable. The CEO asked Igor how he stays so motivated and upbeat, and Igor responded that he is “living the American Dream.” The things most valuable in life weren’t money or possessions, rather it was the ability to live a free life and make an honest living. Igor went on to say how not all Americans fully appreciate the opportunities that this country has given them, and he tells of how he is so thankful for the opportunity to live in the U.S. He truly shows how blessed we all are to live in such a great nation.
I think Igor’s description of the American Dream is absolutely true. The REAL dream for most people is not to have huge houses, expensive cars, and gaudy jewelry. The real dream (for most) is the basics- to have a family, to make an honest living, and to do what you love. With the current economic downturn, the “back to basics” approach to American life is prevalent. It seems ironic to say that the best interpretation of the American Dream comes from a foreigner who immigrated here 7 years ago, but perhaps we cannot truly grasp how blessed we are because we’ve always had it so good.