Monday, January 11, 2010

Last Post of the 2nd Quarter!

We're going to keep this post pretty simple: respond to one of the following questions with specific, well-developed, and well-supported arguments. Interact with your classmates' responses but DO NOT repeat or rehash them; you need to present your own, unique ideas.

1. What would you do if you were in More's situation? Why? Make sure you incorporate specific arguments about both More and yourself.

2. When Robert Bolt wrote A Man For All Seasons, he said he chose More and the era of Henry VIII because he saw parallels with his society (during the 1940s and 1950s). Discuss 1-2 major similarities that you see between More's time and Bolt's time, as demonstrated through the play. Include the significance of these similarities as part of your discussion.

3. This question is quite similar to #2 (but not exactly): Discuss 1-2 major similarities that you see between More's time (as depicted in the play) and our time/ society. Include the significance of these similarities as part of your discussion.

All responses are due by 11:00 a.m. on Monday, January 18th.

12 comments:

MikeG said...

If I were in More’s situation, I would have opposed Wolsey but not take an open position against him, like what More did. I would be able to do more good from a higher position and not dead so I would work my way up the ladder until I have a lot of power. Once I have that power I would make an open stance against the divorce dispensation. Yes, I might be charged for treason, however; I could make a difference before I am brought to trial.

I would oppose the divorce because I believe that going against the Pope would not be good for the country. When your country is ruled under Catholicism and when your King is crowned by the Pope it’s a good idea not to upset the man with a lot of power over your state. Unlike More, I don’t agree that a statesman should follow their morals against what they think is the best for the state, only bad things can happen, especially when the person is misguided (I’m not saying More was misguided).

DavidN said...

Throughout the book A Man for all Seasons, there are many characters who deliberately go against the teachings of the Catholic church. King Henry, originally a strong Catholic of the 16th century, abandoned his faith in order for it to be “acceptable” to divorce his wife who did not produce a son for him. Roper, also another Catholic, renowned his Catholic faith and turned to Lutheranism. And the Duke of Norfolk cut himself away from Rome and the Pope. Similarly, many Catholic conspiracies have arisen in the modern world, with millions of people going against the Catholic Church. The two widely known debates in the modern world on Catholicism are abortions and gay marriages. These two acts are considered mortal sins that go against the Catholic Church’s teachings.
Why is Bolt writing about these anti-Catholic acts? Well, first of all the people in the book who support King Henry’s divorce could be considered the antagonists, since they are the ones going against More’s good conscience to uphold the Catholic teachings. Even though these anti-Catholics exist, heroes roam around us. More, in this case, is our hero; the hero that stood us for his Catholic faith and silently refused the king’s divorce. More is showing an example for us, as readers, to do what is morally right. If you’re going to follow the antagonists of the story or the supporters of abortion or gay marriage in our world, then you are following the group that stands out against Catholicism, and you may someday never make it to eternal happiness. And yet, these anti-Catholic acts have been being committed ever since Catholicism was first created: from the heretics of Jesus’ time to the political abortionist/gay marriage leaders of the modern world.

Unknown said...

If I was in More's situation, I would agree with the Pope and follow my church, not the new church of the king. I would oppose the king, even if he was my friend because I know that divorce is against the church and I have an obligation to follow the church of the Pope. I understand later it is a matter of life and death of which side I am on, but it is more important to follow your morals rather than something you know is wrong.

It is morally important to follow the Pope rather than the king because if you g oagainst the king then you will be charged with treason and later death, but if you go against the church then you must face God's decision for the rest of eternity. More's decision to follow the Pope rather than the King will benefit him because God knows that he made the right decision and that is why he is known as a martyr.

Unknown said...

If I were in More’s situation, I probably would have given in in the end. He stayed to his pride and kept with keeping silent. He refused to talk showing how strongly he was taking a stand for what he believes. The whole play he was always smart with what he said, he never gave anything away and never gave any one any information that may hurt him in the end. He thought through everything before he said it and made sure he was clever and particular with what he was saying and doing. If I were to make it as far as he did with keeping quiet about the situation, I may have given in at the final trial. I wouldn’t feel as strongly as he did about the situation and I wouldn’t have given my life up just to keep my pride. I know that may sound bad, but I would do anything to keep my life if I have the chance. I must give him credit for sticking to his beliefs but I don’t have the will power to do that.

Anonymous said...

I agree with Tori that if I was in More's position, I would have given in. I believe that More has made his point that he does not agree with the king's decision, and there is no use in giving up his life. He should have been more considerate of his family when he made his decision. His wife would be widowed and his daughter would be fatherless and the family would eventually become poor without More's income.

More thought that if he didn't speak out against the king, then he wouldn't be punished. Like More I would not have spoken out against the king, but I would just say that I agreed at the trial to spare my life. I believe that God could have seen in More's heart that he agrees with the Church and that he would have been forgiven.

natalieo said...

Like Tori, I would also have given in to the divorce in the end. If I was in More's position I wouldn't have agreed with the king and would have wanted to stay quiet as long as possible but in the end I would have given in. When More was imprisoned he could no longer provide for his family. They became poor; they barely had a decent meal and lost their social standing. If I had to choose between my own morals and my family's well-being I would have to choose the latter; no question. When he was beheaded (a death that is one of the last ways I would want to suffer) he left his wife without a husband and daughter without a father. I couldn't do that, especially to those who care about me.

Unknown said...

1) More was in a very difficult position, but if I were his position in the beginning, I probably would have given in. I usually try not to make any trouble, so if someone were to ask me if I would go with the divorce and go against the church I would yes. I think that if would be easier just to say yes then to start a whole fight. In ‘A Man for All Season’, More does stand up for his beliefs and he fights ‘til the end of his life, but why would you want to start all the aggravation? I do believe that More did put his family in danger because he lost his job and could not provide for him. I believe that you should think of others before yourself, and he did not think of that.

Anonymous said...

2.The defining event in the 40s was WWII, a time when dictatorships harshly ruled over their people. The two most famous dictators, Hitler and Stalin were not interested in having freedom of speech or thought. People that spoke out against either of these men were immediately sent to their death. Although Henry VIII was not as harsh as either of these men, he was not interested in having More speak out, or write against his "Divine Supremacy." More lost his life because he did not agree with the government just like what happened to many people in Russia and Germany during the 40s.

However, More did not speak his mind until the end of the play. He was actually sentenced to death in a faulty trial by people who wanted him to be terminated. This is also very similar to the totalitarian states of Russia and Germany. People just suspected of being against the Nazis or Communists would be killed. Often evidence would be fabricated, and what was supposed to be a trial would be people who had no intention of finding the accused innocent.

Anonymous said...

I agree with Natalie. I would have to give in if I were in More’s position. I do not think I would have wanted to go against what a king wanted if it cost me my livelihood. When More went against the king, he lost everything. If it were I, I would have watched my own back and given my consent for the divorce. Then the king would have left my family and me alone. Since More went against the king, silently, he lost everything and was imprisoned. His family did not have anyway to take care of themselves because More was not providing for them. I would have thought of my family first and my real opinion last.

Dan G. said...

My stance is somewhat similar to that of both Anthony's and Gallagher's. If I had been in More’s situation, I would have stepped down from my position in the government, thus completely removing myself legally from the situation, yet remaining opposed to the king. I believe this would have been the best option for both the state and for More himself. It would have avoided an open conflict in the hierarchy of the government, as well as allowing More to keep his integrity and not have to give-in to the king or lose his life. In addition, this would have allowed a movement to start among the people, rather than a smaller quarrel between 2 people in the government, which gives the people virtually no say in the matter. This would allow the king to see that either he needs to go with what the people demand, or the people of England would overthrow him.
Even though I believe this would have been the best option for More and the state, I don’t believe that it would have solved England’s problems. There can never be two kings, and a irreconcilable conflict between the Pope and the king of England was inevitable.

Federica C said...

In A Man for All Seasons King Henry VIII wanted a divorce from Catherine of Aragon. Everyone was behind the King’s decision except Sir Thomas More. More disagreed because the King’s nullification went against the Catholic Church and his faith too. Henry assumed More would come around in the end because they had a strong friendship. However, More stuck to his beliefs and didn’t give in.
In today’s society people feel they have to agree with a person of authority because they have a lot of power. If they don’t they feel they’re doing something wrong. I credit More for disagreeing with the King, but I disagree that he had to die for what he believed. More’s disagreement was hard to do because so many people supported the King and he was the only odd one out. I think it is important to voice your opinions because it makes you who you are.

Unknown said...

At the end of A Man for All Seasons, More is tried against jury, is found guilty of treason, and executed. Since More has already been found guilty, he owns up to what he has done, and is proud of it. If I were in More's situation, I would have done the same thing. If I had gotten into some sort of trouble for having certain beliefs and listening to my conscience and came to the conclusion that there was no way out of it, I would proudly admit to what I did without an ounce of denial.

I would admit whatever I had done because those are my beliefs and if I believe that I did the right thing then I would want everyone to realize that. More admitted what he did because he knew it was on the record and he broke his silence to share what had really happened. He got into this trouble because he stuck to his beliefs and kept his faith strong. I would do the same simply for that reason. I believe that what More did was the right thing to do.