Respond to ONE of the following questions. The questions offer you a variety of paths to follow in your analysis. As always, DO NOT repeat your classmates' ideas, but DO build upon them:
1. What would happen if our entire government was dissolved tomorrow? What would life be like? Why?
2. Discuss 1 inconsistency that you see within the Declaration OR between the Declaration and actual life during the Revolutionary period. Evaluate the purpose behind and the significance of this discrepancy - does it strengthen or weaken the Declaration?
3. If you were a colonist in 1776, would the Declaration have persuaded you? Explain, taking your age, your position in society, and your geographical location into consideration (you can fictionalize these elements, of course, but be specific when articulating them).
All responses are due by 8:00 a.m. on Wednesday, December 9th.
Wednesday, December 2, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

14 comments:
1. If the government was to dissolve tomorrow, the United States of America would be an anarchist country. In fact, we wouldn't be united at all; we would be a country torn apart, from the sudden loss of the government. First of all, the government is responsible for our safety, happiness, and justice. Without the government, these privileges would be gone; there would be no government to protect us or keep us happy. All of the laws would basically be abolished, since the government did pass the laws in the first place. The government provides certain career fields with money, including the police force, firefighters, non-profits organizations, soldiers, transportation systems, etc. Therefore, a large percentage of the United States of America will be laid off of their job, since the government can no longer give them money. Speaking of soldiers, the 300,000 troops getting deployed to Iraq and Afghanistan will most likely not be deployed without the government. And the soldiers currently fighting in Iraq/Afghanistan would weaken from the lack of incoming soldiers. And here comes another 300,000 people in search of jobs in the nearly jobless economy of the United States of America! …But who needs jobs? Without the government and without laws, chaos will spur, and millions of people will steal food and goods from supermarkets and stores. After all, who will catch them? There are no police forces, no trials (Judicial branch), and, most importantly, no laws (Legislative branch)!
Without the government, our country would be prone to terrorist attacks and groups of people trying to set up new governments to control the country. There would be no security in our nation; therefore, terrorists could simply disguise themselves, fly into the United States of America, and bomb everything they please. We would never feel safe anywhere, being constantly alert for terrorists in disguise and even burglars who would never get caught. A country without a government provides a great opportunity for people to settle the citizens down and re-establish peace and democracy (and possibly even dictatorship or such). With nearly every person in the country in extreme stress, panic, and fear, any person can easily become well-known by promising a better world as promised in the Declaration of Independence. But, you never know… this person may not be trustworthy; this person may even be a terrorist trying to take over the country. All this person has to do is get the support of the country by promising safety, happiness, and justice, which was lost after the collapse of the government. Remember: these people are all drowned in their fear. That means that they may easily be persuaded to support a person that will "supposedly" grant them their security and happiness back, which is what all people desire.
1. If the government was dissolved tomorrow this country would not be in as bad of shape as everyone would think. Dave was right in saying at first we would fall into anarchy, however; we would not be torn apart. Dave’s argument was that the government is responsible for our safety, happiness, and justice. He is forgetting about the most important variable of this equation, we are the United States of America. There would be tremendous amounts of looting and rioting along with the greatest panic the world has ever seen. But we would persevere, amongst all the violence and chaos a great leader would emerge and unite us.
Unlike Dave’s scenario of someone manipulating the peoples’ fear and taking over, this leader would inspire the people to take action in their own way. Our tradition of freedom would not dissolve with the government. The sense of freedom would grow stronger and would be what finally unites this country. Our experience in democracy would allow for an easy transition from our anarchist state. In these trying times, all the differences between people would be forced out of the minds of our new leaders. The disbanding of today’s government would strengthen this nation in the end leading to an American Pax Romana.
(In response to the third blog option)
The news of this document has finally reached this small town in Boston. Shouts of joy and independence can be heard everywhere, and all of this is simply caused by the newly significant document titled the Declaration of Independence. We have been suffering under King George’s binding rule for far too long, and this declaration justifies our rebellious thoughts. Once the news of this document spreads, no country can deny our justification for rebellion, for it can also be applied to them. The long list of grievances in the document proves that even though we have suffered greatly, it is our right and duty to go against the King. We have especially felt the injustice of the King’s overwhelming laws here in Boston when he ordered that all of our ports were to be closed. With my father being a merchant, this close on the ports has made life especially difficult for him and my family. I may only be 17 years of age, but I am old enough to see the effect this binding law has on my family.
Even though King George has taken away most of the colonies’ rights and freedom, he cannot take away our unity. For when he took away our trading rights here in Boston, the other colonies were extremely supportive and sent supplies to aid us in these troubled times. And this idea of unity is also stated in the Declaration, for when the government takes away our rights and freedom, it falls on all of our shoulders to regain our rights. Hearing cries of war and the sound of gunshots in the air is not something we wished for, but we feel it is the only other way for us to have the natural rights and freedom that belong to us. As it is also stated in the Declaration, King George exists to protect our natural rights, but as soon as he began to abuse his power as described in the long list of grievances, my loyalty to the King immediately diminished. King George and his Parliament are unfit to rule, and they need to be stopped in their path of tyranny, and as the Declaration of Independence states, we must resort to the only option left to regain our freedom: rebellion. And as the Declaration concludes, we will all fight for our lives, fortune, and honor.
1. I agree with Mike that if the US government was dissolved the people of our country would not be torn about. We would likely try to get a new emergency government in place either run by the military or former politicians. The police and firefighters would still attempt to do their job. There would of course be disagreement over who would run the country, and there would be some people who would break the law, but for the most part, Americans are smart enough to realize that if they did not band together, we would fail as a nation.
However, this sense of community would only last for a very short period of time. Like Dave said earlier, terrorists would attack the US full force within days. Radical Islamic groups would now have no obstacles whatsoever in attacking our country. With no US Intelligence Agency or CIA we would have no knowledge of terrorist attacks. Al-qaeda would organize and carry out attacks within days of the government being dissolved. This would cause destruction of industry, and make many of the US's citizens move to Canada. The only US citizens that would stay would be an emergency military run by America’s current generals used to help combat the terrorists and some citizens that want to defend their homeland. Needless to say, our economy would be in ruins, production of food and goods would come to a standstill, and a very long period of violence would drag out in the US.
3. The reactions by me would be much like Meghan’s except living in Philadelphia the news was every where almost immediately. When we heard the Declaration of Independence some where right on board others, hesitant. I was in support. Every one of us is annoyed and sick of the taxes, wars, and all the other laws set on us by King George! And the Declaration protects us from the laws that take our freedoms away from us. How could any one not be behind something as great as this? All other countries can relate to our Declaration of Independence thanks to the way it’s worded, I mean Great Britain isn’t even mentioned until the last few sentences in the second paragraph. The Declaration caught my support by the time it listed the grievances. When it’s written down and put right in front of you, you see just how horrible these laws are if you didn’t realize it before hand.
The grievances went on as if they would never finish, I was shocked to hear all the things he does to us as were my friends. Being sixteen we haven’t realized all the awful laws and regulations King George has ordered. Now the Declaration shows the world what Great Britain has done to us and why we are rebelling. With a government like the one forced on us there is no need to explain the reason for our rebelling. We are a country who wants our natural rights returned and we will unity together to prove it to King George and his legislative body.
1. I agree with Mike and Tom that if the government was to dissovle tomorrow that the country would not fall apart as Dave put it. I believe that the United States citizens would be smart and sophisticated enough to put another form of government in place of the old, just as other countries have done before them. Perhaps at the very beginning of the dissolving of government there may be some panic at to what the country as a people are going to do about it, but that would be resolved over time. As Mike said, there would be one person amongst everyone to stand up to reunite this country.
Now, Dave does have a point that someone could attempt to manipulate the fears of others, but he overlooked one main fact. This country was founded on freedom, and for someone to try to motivate people based on anything else is impossible. Yes, they may offer freedom then take it away, but the American society is too smart to settle for that. We as a people would revolt against him/her, and, as I've stated before, establish a stable government that would fit the needs of the people and society as we know it.
One inconsistency that I saw between the Declaration and life during the Revolutionary period is that the founding fathers were attacking King George. They were blaming the King for the wrongs that the Parliament has committed. The King of England hasn't had absolute power to govern his people since the signing of the Magna Carta in 1215. Since then, Parliament has set up the laws and governed their people, both in England and around the world.
The purpose for the founding fathers to blame King George for what the Parliament has done is to try and get the colonies against a king. The founding fathers wanted to set up a government like Parliament, without the king. They decided to put all of the blame onto the king so they can have a similar government, but still get the colonies to rally against England. This discrepancy strengthened the Declaration because it got the people to go against King George, and ultimately, England.
1. I agree with Dave that the country would completely fall apart if our government dissolved tomorrow. I think that many different people would try to rise up and become dictators of our country, trying to make it their own. This would cause complete chaos and civil wars in America. Eveyone would be picking different sides and we wouldn't be one nation anymore. I don't think that any of these attempts on dictating our coutry would be successful because so many people would be trying to defeat each other. This lack of unity is not what America was founded on, so it would definitly not work after our government was gone. I think this shows that the government is the glue that keeps us from going completely insane. All the laws that are passed are for our own benefit, to keep us united.
Only just recently has the Declaration of Independence been issued. Philadelphia still talks of this document that states our separation from the crown. Being a teenager not many of my friends are interested. However because the issue of being a free country is constantly discussed at home I have formed my own opinion about the document. It is a very well written document that relates to America as well as other nations that are oppressed. As I was reading the grievances, I thought to myself: you know we weren’t treated fairly and our natural rights weren’t protected. I think it’s great that we are taking a stand and not allowing King George to rule over us anymore. Talk of war has been a big topic at home and at school. This I am not too happy about because there are other ways we can go about getting our freedom.
The list of grievances went on and I was surprised to find some of the awful things King George was doing to us. Transporting mercenaries to kill people was just one of them. I think at this age I have a well enough understanding to say that what King George did to us was totally and completely wrong. Like Bianca said this Declaration shows the world how we really feel.
1. If the government were to disband tomorrow we would be immersed in crime and violence. The laws would no longer be in place like Dave said. We would be in a state of total chaos. This might not last long though because a new government would take over because no one really wants to live in a state of total crime and chaos. This might take a while but it would happen eventually.
Having no government for some people could be a God-send. These criminals who have been careful about their crimes would be given free reign to commit crimes. The government is around to protect us. They keep these criminals under control. If the government were to dissolve then all the murders and robbers would be released back into society. This is not something we want to happen.
I agree with Ant, Tom, and Gallagher in saying that the U.S would not be left totally and irreversibly devastated if the government were to collapse tomorrow. I strongly disagree that our country would become divided and it would be outright chaos. I also disagree with Dave that the government is responsible for the happiness of its citizens. The government is just responsible for our freedom, so that we can engage in the “pursuit of happiness,” they’re not responsible to give us what makes us happy.
If the government were to dissolve, I believe that a council would be formed consisting of the strongest politicians, which would enact martial law. From there, the council would elect a person to head the new government (essentially, the new President). This process would be very similar to that of which the Founding Fathers went through. As a result of this new government, life would go back to what it was like during the Revolutionary War. Our citizens would live a much more disciplined life than today because money and luxuries would be hard to come by, and we would go back to the core values and principles of this great country. The government would swiftly extinguish any domestic threat because they would have to concentrate on foreign threats. I believe that there are enough genuinely good citizens remaining in this country to restart it back to the way it was meant to be, and our history would generally repeat itself again.
If the entire government was resolved tomorrow I think my life would change but not too much right away. I think it would take some time for it to have any huge impact. I think that little things would change because we wouldn’t necessarily have to follow the laws. This means people would start driving faster and more careless which would lead to more accidents. People may also start to do more drugs and things along those lines. I believe that people would just rebel on all the laws or rules they hated or didn’t agree with. I think all these things would be rebelled against because we would want to prove a point. All this rebelling would lead to a bad outcome. There would be more deaths and simple daily activities may not be possible. There would be no enforcement on anything and everything would just go crazy. I think at first people would love not being told what to do. However, I then see this having affect on people and people will finally see it. Once they finally realize this, they will begin to maybe try putting the rules back in place. I think people would strike and maybe try and push for the government to get back in power. I think this would have a very bad outcome. The only positive thing that would come out of this is that people would see why these rules are in place. I know there are some things I disagree with and definitely in others, but I know if these rules were taken away and I saw the negative affect, I would no longer disagree or mind abiding by it. I think overall, it would leave a great scar on us but if the government was able to get back in power, it would teach us all a good lesson by helping us see why these rules or laws are in place.
With Mike, Tom and Anthony, I too agree that the country would not be destroyed. There would be a brief state of anarchy (because anarchy is just a lack of government) where people might act as if they were in a zombie movie, amassing arms, looting and fearing for their lives because they are trying to make their lives better. Other countries, such as Canada, Mexico and some strong European nations might attempt to conquer us because we are a new nation-less land. Some people in the South might even try to secede from the North because they do not have a government to hold them back.
But, even though there will be many bad things happening, I believe that they will be outshined by the good. Almost immediately, there will be people who will reinstate the government. In under a year campaigns will have been held and new government officials will be elected. In this time, business will continue as normal because this will be a chance for tax-free production and purchasing, and because business is in large part not necessary on the government. Law enforcement will still fighting crime, but will be overworked because of the increase in thievery and people who believe that, because there is a lack in law, that the police cannot enforce it. The military will still be fighting because they are separate from the government, but there will renegade officers who will do what they think is right in the war. I do not think that terrorist attacks will arise because, as said before, we still have a military. I think that the only affects this momentary lack of government will cause is new politicians, a few people arrested and a small shortage of taxes.
Freedom! We have just received the Declaration of Independence in our small little town outside of Philadelphia, and we could not be happier. We have suffered too long under the rule of King George! Every little thing that he did just made everyone angry, but just wait till he sees this document he’ll he the one who’s angry! That’s what he get for taxing us on every single thing, being a seventeen year old girl I don’t have a lot of money so these taxes where horrible!
As I read the Declaration, I was surprised at how many things he did to our ‘country’, I did not know of that many! As you read you see how many grievances there really are! I did not know that King George was trying to stop foreigners from coming into America. Why would he want to stop our population from growing? He even sent officers from his country to come and harass us! If we did one thing against one of Their rules we were punished! I just could not stand that! He tried to take away our freedom, but he will not be victorious, We will!
Post a Comment