Thursday, October 29, 2009

The Crucible: Movie vs. Play

Compare a scene or element from The Crucible (1996, movie) with a related scene from the play*. Evaluate the rhetorical effectiveness of these two scenes or elements; to evaluate the effectiveness, you must consider the purpose of each version. Essentially, you need to determine which version is more persuasive and discuss WHY that scene is more persuasive. Make sure you indicate which rhetorical appeal(s) is(are) incorporated into the scene.

*Generally speaking, you will be comparing the SAME scene/element in both the movie and the play, but this scene/ element must contain significance differences between the two versions. ONLY choose different scenes/elements if the play does not have a corresponding scene/element for the movie scene/element (in other words, if you have chosen a scene added for the movie).

** "Significant" does not necessarily mean that the movie scene/element must have been greatly revised from the original; sometimes a seemingly minor change can totally alter your reaction to a work.

Two final reminders: Do not discuss in isolation from each other - reply to your classmates' evaluations (disagree or add in new insight to support the other person). Do not discuss your scenes/elements in a vacuum - they are not placed into the play/movie at random, so consider their surroundings.

All responses are due by 8:00 a.m. on Friday, November 6th.

7 comments:

Unknown said...

One thing between the movie and the play that was different which really helped with the understanding of the circumstances of what started the chaos was the beginning with the girls dancing in the woods. At the beginning of the play the scene where the girls are dancing in the woods is only mentioned before the actual lines of each character, while, on the other hand, the movie starts with that scene. In my opinion, this gives the viewer, compared to the reader, an actual point of view of how this “witch-craft”, so to speak, comes out. Hearing what the girls have to say really shows that they are not there for casting spells or doing anything else that involves witchery; it is merely them trying to get Tituba to see if the certain boys they like, like them back. Once Mr. Parris stumbles upon what’s going on he immediately claims that its witch-craft. Jumping to immediate conclusions is what started this whole fiasco.

Now the book did mention what happened, but if it were to actually act out the scene then this whole dilemma would be much easier to follow. Considering this is the beginning it is crucial to make sure the reader/viewer is able to comprehend what is taking place. So in all, I believe that the movie is easier to understand because it actually gives the viewer the scene in which all the chaos in Salem derives from.

Unknown said...

One scene from the movie and play that I would compare is the scene of Elizabeth and Proctor talking alone. In this scene, Proctor and Elizabeth share their last conversation before Proctor is ultimately hanged. I think the movie portrayed this scene as more persuasive because in the movie there are more emotions and actions that help you to realize how the characters may feel.

Elizabeth and Proctor seem to encounter many problems during the movie and play, such as Proctor's affair with Abigail and Elizabeth being falsely accused of witchcraft. In this scene, they seem to put all of their differences aside and show what they mean to each other. You can see that they truly do love each other, that they care deeply about one another, and are concerned for themselves. I think this appropriate as well because this is the last time they will ever speak with each other and they had time to reconcile and make things better.

Billy G said...

The scene in which Tituba is questioned changes from the play to the movie because in the movie she is beat in the movie but not in the play. I think that the change makes the seen more effective because it makes it seem more likely that Tituba would confess. In the play, Tituba is just questioned and her fear of death is what made her confess. In the movie, though, she is beaten with a rod, causing pain, which increases the fear. I believe that Miller changed it because of the change in audience. The people of today might not see hanging as less likely.

I believe that the movie scene is more persuasive than the play because you are more likely to do something while in pain. The logos in the scene is the same in both scenes, the fact that she would hang if she does not confess and give names, she will hang. The pathos, though, changes from movie to play. In the play, fear is the main emotion. In the movie, fear, pain, sadness and anger come from the beating.

Anonymous said...

One thing hat was different between the play and the movie was when Proctor met Abby on the woods outside of Salem. This was originally in the book but was taken out. I think this scene would have been important to the book because back then married men didn’t meet unmarried girls in the woods. But considering the Proctor and Abby had already been together this wasn’t too bad. If the village had found out they probably would have been cast out of their town. This really shows the chaos of that time like Anthony said. If there hadn’t been any accusing then I doubt Proctor would have met Abby in the woods. In the movie it shows that maybe Proctor still has feelings for Abby even though he is telling her this witch business is ridiculous.

Also this could be showing that proctor wants no one to know that he was talking to Abby because he is ashamed of what they did. In the book I think this would have been an important scene because maybe Proctor could have stopped Abby if they had met in the book. I know that that would have been historically incorrect but for the purpose of this book and movie it could have been important

Unknown said...

I agree with Katie that the scene where Abigail and John Proctor met outside was very persuasive and shoud have been in the play. I feel that this scene made the relationship between these two characters even more apparent and intense. It showed that John not only commited adultery, but that Abigail was actually in love with him. This talk in the woods made me see why John was so burdened by what he did with Abigial and why he couldn't recite the Ten Commandments.
When reading the play I was aware of the secret relationship between John Proctor and Abigail, but I did not know how much of a serious problem it was to John's relatioship with his wife Elizabeth. I thought that after Abigail was dismissed from her job working for the Proctor's, Abigail's feeligs for John would have went away. The scene in the movie of them talking in the woods when Abigial kisses Proctor made me realize that her feelings were still very much there.

Unknown said...

The scene at the end of the play and the movie with Proctor confessing and then ripping up the paper is the one I would like to compare. While we were reading the play I didn’t really understand it, but when I saw the movie I understood the emotion that Proctor and the rest of the characters were going through. When I reread the this scene I felt like Proctor didn’t really know what he was doing at the end and that he wasn’t sure with his decision that he made however; in the movie I felt like Proctor was sure of his decision and that he was doing the right thing.
Anthony said that they just jumped to conclusion, meaning they didn’t think before they acted. In both the movie and the book you can tell that Proctor didn’t think before he confessed, but in the movie you can really tell when he finally thinks it through that this was not the right thing to do and that he shouldn’t confess. While we were reading the book, you couldn’t tell right away that was what he thought, maybe because I didn’t read any of the stage directions and that when we were reading it we showed no emotions. When I reread it I still felt like Proctor didn’t fully understand what he was doing right away.

Anonymous said...

One scene that was left out of the pay but was added in the movie was the scene where Abigail was trying to blame Hale's wife for witchcraft. This scene was a big turning point in the movie because it shows the chaos and how people were just blaming each other. Abigail blamed Hale's wife because he was suspicious of her and was not believing what was going on. This point in the movie also shows how widespread and ridiculous the whole thing was because Abigail never met Hale's wife and she claimed that she saw her.

Probably the biggest effect that this scene has on the audience is showing how Danforth is finally realizing that the trials are going to far. In the play, there is no scene like this, so you don't really see how the judges realize that they have gone to far. I think it is better to have this scene because it made the ending easier to understand. You can see why Danforth is trying so hard to save Proctor's life because in this scene, Danforth notices how this whole mees was an act.