Respond to ONE of the following questions:
1) When do we misinterpret other cultures (other countries or even other communities or schools) because we do not know enough about them? Why do we do this? Provide a few general thoughts, then discuss and evaluate a specific example in which you - or someone you know - misinterpreted another culture. DO NOT recycle someone else's example!
2) Pretend that you come from a culture that knows nothing about the United States or its citizens. Describe (in detail) 1 ritual of the United States society, including your theories about this ritual (such as its purpose, origin, etc.). You may recycle someone else's ritual ONLY if you describe if from a totally different perspective than your classmate's.
*All responses are due by 4:00 p.m. on Monday, September 28th.
Monday, September 21, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

16 comments:
(Response to Question 1)
I believe that everyone in this world misinterprets another culture simply because we don’t understand them. Everyone is different, and especially in today’s society, we tend to frown upon those who behave differently from the rest of us. I think that everyone is afraid of the unknown, and of what is to come, and that is why we misinterpret or misjudge those cultures we don’t know or trust. We tend to judge people even before we get to know them, and I think that when we do this, we are taking the chance of never truly and fully getting to know them and understanding and accepting the differences between us.
A typical example of people misjudging others in the present day is of the way we view Amish people. I think that we all find it hard to believe that anyone could live without the necessities we have in our household and still be content with the way they live their lives. Yet the Amish people do it every single day. Personally, I know that I misinterpreted them asking myself why anyone would put themselves through such hardships day in and day. But after analyzing their lives, I realized that maybe my misinterpretations could be very wrong. I first believed that the Amish have no idea what they’re missing out on, but in truth, perhaps we are the ones that are missing out. The Amish have gotten rid of anything that might be a distraction in their lives, and as a result, they have a strong sense of a family bond and love that will hold them together through anything. Their lives may be simple and difficult at times, but maybe they serve as a lesson for all of us and how we view our lives.
1. I do believe that many people in this world today misinterpret and incorrectly judge other cultures, not only because we do not know about enough about them, but we think that they are different than we are. Some other cultures, when in the same environment as us Americans, sometimes tend to act as outcasts, excluding themselves from the crowd. Therefore, we do not always have the chance to talk to the other cultures and get to know them, because we feel that we are better than the "outcasts". Meghan's statement, "We are afraid of the unknown," is very believable and true, but I think that we are being more ignorant than we are being afraid, since we often refuse to interact with other cultures.
An example of this social separation is the Koreans at our school. At lunch, I see every Korean at one table, only talking to each other. Not once have I seen them interact with us Americans, nor have I seen us Americans interact with the Koreans. The factor separating the two cultures is ignorance. We do not appreciate how these foreign people act, talk, and look differently than us. The Koreans tend to focus more on school than being social, and yet we still refuse to interact with them and create bonds. However, if we just look deeper inside of the Koreans, we can eventually understand that they are just as friendly as anyone else. We just need to look past the appearances and into the personalities of these other cultures.
I believe we do not know enough about other cultures for the same reason we do not know enough about other things, we were simply never taught. Everyone, even people in the same area such as Norristown are raised very different ways. We are just not used to what other cultures or even other households do. The ignorance and misunderstanding really are not our fault. I disagree with Dave when he says we are ignorant and shun other cultures like the Koreans. We ask the Koreans about their lives all the time. We simply do not sit with them at lunch because it is difficult for them to speak English well. The US has always been accepting hence the name “Melting Pot.”
I agree with Meghan that sometimes we look down upon another culture because we are not used to it or put people in a stereotypical group. For example, after the 9/11 attacks, many people in the US thought all Muslims were terrorists. They may have been uneasy if they say a man with a turban on their bus or plane. In turn, Muslims in the US began to hate non- Muslims for their stereotyping. The Americans did not realize most of the Muslims in this country were just as sad by the 9/11 attacks as us, and some of the Muslims failed to realize that when you look like you're from the group that committed a terrorist attack, you will be categorized as such.
Question 1
I thought about this question while trying not to generalize. I do believe that people misinterpret other cultures for different reasons. Some people believe its ignorance and I feel that most of it is, however; I can’t speak for every one but I know that some people know about a culture but still view the culture in the wrong way. Why, there are many reasons, nationalism, subconsciously, and even supremacy. Nationalism, if you believe that your country is the best wouldn’t you speak of your “rituals” in a better way than another countries’. I know this happens because I have done it, I’ve spoken of European ideas and “rituals”, not in an offensive way, but; in a way that makes them seem barbaric in nature. Then there are the people who misinterpret a culture without even knowing it. Subconsciously one might speak without thinking. Now let us focus on an evil, extremist supremacy. These people know enough of the culture to hate it and because of their hate (most times completely irrational) they do more than just misinterpret the culture. I noticed what Meghan said, “I think that everyone is afraid of the unknown, and of what is to come, and that is why we misinterpret or misjudge those cultures we don’t know or trust”. I’m not saying that Meghan is completely wrong, I’m trying to show how generalizing can lead to being wrong. Meghan said that everyone is afraid of the unknown, I’m not afraid of the unknown and I strongly doubt that all six and a half billion people alive are xenophobic. By generalizing, she focused on one idea and this kept her from looking into the human psyche and figuring out other causes.
An example of misinterpreting and even misrepresenting a culture can be found in our back yards. I know, that back in Mexico, Mexicans are businesspersons and government officials (I know I’m not the only American who knows this). If we know that Mexicans are intelligent and capable of doing office jobs, why do we make jokes about them being landscapers? I can’t argue ignorance because even I understand enough of the Mexican culture, but I also make jokes about them cutting lawns and being illegal immigrants. The point I’m trying to make is that ignorance isn’t the only reason why humans, not just Americans, misinterpret cultures. We all do things for different reasons.
I believe that we misinterpret other cultures because we are simple not part of them. We did not grow up believing what another culture believes, thinking what they think. Everywhere, the people of different cultures learn from the adults, friends, and (maybe) media around them what they should believe. If you grew up with everyone important to you telling you that the only way to survive in the world is to go to school and get a job, that is what you will grow up believing. But if everyone told you that the only way to survive is to learn how to hunt, you will believe that. These two cultures would see each other as strange and think that what they believe is wrong because that is what they were taught. It is neither person’s fault that they are different or see each other as different. It is there upbringing. And we can trace all cultures back to a single goal: making life better. That is our goal and that is one way we can bring us all together as a single culture of human beings (and in fact all living thing). If we just look at that then we are not so different after all.
But after this thought, I still misinterpret other cultures. One example is Native Americans. I see their culture as a bit weird. They worship gods of nature and (sometimes) reject the modern world. I think it is a bit weird that they would reject the advancements in technology, knowledge and medicine that is common to us. If they knew what we knew, they might be safer and healthier. They would understand how nature works, instead of explaining it with deities. They could be more productive if they used inventions such as steel. But the reason that they do this is explained up above. They do what their parents tell them. They are trying to make their lives better, but they are doing it how the know they can.
Throughout the course of history and even until today people have misinterpreted other cultures in the world. We Americans are no exception. The reason I think that most people cannot comprehend other civilizations’ cultures is because there is not enough interaction between countries. It’s not like everyone can travel the entire world to see other cultures for themselves. So, because not everyone can travel the world most people misinterpret other societies based on stereotypes. Stereotypes lead to horrible misunderstandings of other cultures.
A good example of a misleading stereotype is the eating habits of Asians, typically the Chinese and Japanese. One of the biggest stereotypes is that their cultures involve them eating dogs and cats. I don’t know from personal experience that they actually eat those animals, but we still have no right to judge them. I especially agree with what Meghan said that “we tend to frown upon those who behave differently from the rest of us.” Just because they are different from us doesn’t mean we can judge them. In the eyes of the Asians our culture is weird to them just as their culture is to us. We shouldn’t frown upon these people and we should just accept them for who they are and vice-versa. In essence I’m saying that this should go for all countries and nationalities that people should not be judged based on their stereotypical backgrounds. They say you should never judge a book by its cover; maybe more people should follow that.
I think that we misinterpret other cultures because they are not what we are used to. We get so used to doing things the same way all the time that when something out of the ordinary comes along, we do not know how to respond. Because it is foreign to us, we think that it is bad. But in reality it's just a different way of doing something.
I agree with Tom, that many people don't understand the Muslim culture. Muslim women cover up head to toe, only exposing their eyes. They do this no matter how hot it is outside because that is their culture. People who are unfamiliar with this may say that doing that is weird and strange but Muslims believe that women should not expose their skin in public.
Question 1
I think we misinterpret other cultures because we find some cultures to be strange and we turn away from anything that we are unfamiliar with. The reason we may find another persons culture strange is because we do not know enough about their culture to make our own opinion of them. Instead of researching someone else's culture we judge them according to what we hear from someone else or what we see in the news. I agree with Anthony when he says "we shouldn't judge a book by its cover" because you never know who you might be affecting when you call someone else's culture strange.
An example of people misjudging a culture was when I came to America. People thought I was strange because I had this accent that they weren't used to hearing everyday and vice versa. When I heard the American accent I remember thinking that these people talked funny as I'm sure that's what everyone was thinking about me. I also made some not so great judgments of my own.
Thanksgiving is not a holiday that is celebrated in England. When I was told how the holiday came about, I thought it was strange that people celebrate this. However, Because I have lived in America for so long, I've come to appreciate the culture a lot more than when I first moved here. I judged Americans before I even had the chance to get to know them and I think this is what a lot of people do today. I understand it and when I'm in England and somebody attacks American culture, It's only instinct for me to defend it because I've experienced it for almost half of my life. This is exactly the same thing I do when someone in America attacks English culture. To conclude, I think that if we took the time to understand and experience someone else's culture then it's safe to say that we can make a better opinion on that culture and appreciate it a lot more.
Question 1
I believe that we do not understand other cultures and we misinterpret them because we don't care about any other cultures besides of our own. Most people aren't interested in the way that other cultures behave or the reasons why the do the things that they act this way. People only notice the huge differences that seem weird to them, and that is how stereotypes begin. stereotypes are generally negative towards other cultures.
One example of the way we misinterpret other cultures is the way some people view the Jewish people. All throughout history the Jewish people have been looked down upon since the Egyptians enslaved them all the way up until World War II. They never did anything wrong, they just have different religious beliefs. Many stereotypes have been created that are offensive towards their culture. We shouldn't judge other cultures or other people just because they are different from us. We should treat everyone the same way no matter their cultural heritage.
Question 2
If I was from another country, and I came to live/visit the United States, one thing I would find extremely weird is how Americans are obsessed with weather. In countries that are not the U.S. they could care less about the weather, but Americans have to have the weather channel on every hour of every day. They even have a T.V. channel that tells you what the weather is or is going to be in the future. In Europe you don’t care about the weather, unless there is something extremely important going on.
In the American culture, they seem to be focused on the future not the present. They always have to plan ahead, and everything has to be prefect. If one of their weather men/women says anything about rain or bad weather, they immediately change their plans, or even cancel them. If you think about it, the weather that is predicted is usually almost always wrong, if it is almost always wrong why Americans still watch the weather channel 24/7?
2.) I was observing some natives from the country America and I saw something that was very strange. A large percentage of the population spend many hours watching television. But the weird part each family or person has a spacific show they watch that usually last an hour, sometimes there are two shows so it would be two hours. The thing the people have in common are the shows they watch continue from the week before, so they have to watch every week in order to know what happens next. From the time the show starts until it ends the people do not want to be disturbed. They get so rapped up in the shows that for some people it's all they talk about. The conversations are all about what happened, what will happened and if the person they are talking to can believe what just happened.
What I found out is watching these shows give the people something to look forward to and they can just relax without worrying or thinking about what's heppening in their life at the moment. I'm not fully sure the logic behind this ritual, yet but I have some ideas. One, it is what the people said a way to relax or two, this population doesn't have enough places to go during that week. The problem with the second idea is now with OnDemand and other things like that the people can watch their show whenever they find time. This ritual of watching television serise started many years ago, back when the television first came out. And i don't see it stopping any time soon.
I believe that we misinterpret other cultures more due to human nature, and less because of shear ignorance. I do not think that we have no interest in learning about other cultures, but we just aren't comfortable with the unknown. If I were to go into a room and there are groups of Americans, Mexicans, Indians, and Koreans, without thinking, I'd go to the group of Americans without even thinking about it. I think many people would do the same because we don't know what to expect when we go to the group of Indians, or Koreans, or Mexicans. We know, generally, how Americans will act and receive us. The same is true for understanding other cultures. We know American culture and its rituals, and we probably practice them. However, when we see others practicing their rituals, we turn our heads and think of how strange they look. It's not that we dislike or want to ignore them, it's just instinct and human nature.
I think a good example of this is how Muslims pray. I once saw a Muslim, in the middle of a public place, take out a rug and start bowing up and down. I remember thinking to myself, "Is he trying to fly away or something?" I thought it was weird, turned my head, and walked away. I was not purposely being ignorant; it was just that what he was doing had no effect on me. I never really thought about it until I learned in school about them facing east and praying at certain times during the day. It was simply human nature to turn and walk away from the man, not blatant ignorance or discrimination.
I wrote this on Friday so i could only read Meghan's response
question 1
Megan has a good point. We all misinterpret other people even if we don't intend to or realize that we are doing it. If a person is seen doing something that might be considered out of the ordinary it's hard not to judge that person. Most of the time we don't think about why that person is doing what they're doing, we just think it is strange and leave it at that. Like Meghan says, it has a lot to do with being afraid of what is unknown to us. I also think that we sometimes need to see someone's culture as unusual to make our own culture seem normal or even better.
The people that I know I misjudge are the Canadians. On the outside they are a seemingly peaceful people who enjoy hockey, the maple leaf and oddly shaped bacon. But I believe that they are planning an invasion. They have already established a bank here (TD Bank) and a Canadian doughnut chain store has entered the US. Before we know it there will be Canadians everywhere. The good thing is that if that happens we should be able to get rid of them because, well, they're Canadians
response to question 2
If I was to describe one ritual of the U.S. society to someone foreign, I would describe the purpose of and how to use make-up. I would explain that we like to put emphasis on the eyes when getting dressed up. We tend to put lots of colors on the lids, and use dark colors to line the eyes. I think we do this because you cannot only listen to someone by words but by expression too, and the eyes show most expression on the face. We put blush on the cheeks, and try to cover up any blemishes. I believe we do this because our society believes in perfection, and a blemish-free, rosie-cheeked face is perfection. We also put glosses and different colors on our lips. I think we do this because, like the eyes, the lips are also a main focal point of the face. Lips are also used to show affection, and a glossier lip would look more inviting than chapped lips.
Like Tori said, the U.S. is constantly thinking of the future. We are always thinking of new styles. We also tend to bring back some of the past. Make-up is like clothing. We can come up with new styles and ways to wear it, or bring back old ideas. Like when red lipstick was in style in the past. Some people try to bring back dated styles that could potentially be a huge hit again. Although make-up is used world wide, it isn't used quite the same everywhere, which is why this may seem different to other cultures.
response to question 2
If i were coming from a different culture and looking upon American culture there would be many things i would find wierd. On Jenna's idea of makeup, i would go with the more general idea of how we look. We are always worried about impressing people and always trying to look the best. This inclused hair, makeup, clothes, personality, etc. Americans are always getting their hair colored or cut a new way. We are always trying something different with our makeup and trying new styles of clothing. We are also worried about how we act around others. We are so worried about being in the "in crowd" that we sometimes aren't true to ourselves. Also, Americans try to keep up with the latest trends, even if they don't really like them. For example, people wear a type of clothing or act a certain way that they may not necessarily like just so they can fit in. This isn't a good way to live our lives.
All this worrying can also cut into the more important things. School, for example, teenagers are so worried about how they look in school. They make sure their hair and makeup look good at all times because they never know who they will run into. This can begin to cut into our education because if we are so focused on other things, we aren't focusing on the important things which includes our education. Although I must admit I do sometimes partake in these acts I think it is something that should be changed because society is losing focus on the big picture.
Question 1:
I think that Americas especially misinterpret other cultures. We are constantly at war with other countries and we just step in when we think a country could be a threat or when we don’t like how they are running their country. As Americans we should be most accepting of other countries cultures because we have people from all over the world who live here because the living conditions and quality of life might be better than in their own country. People escape to America all the time to leave warn torn countries or dictators. We should be most accepting and understanding of other cultures because America is called “The Melting Pot” for a reason.
I agree with Tom for what he said about all Muslims being called terrorists. We know that they all aren’t terrorists yet people still think this way. When I see a Muslim man or woman I will admit that the thought does cross my mind that they could be a terrorist. But if every Muslim man and woman was a terrorist then I’m sure that they would have done something by now. We can’t just assume that they are all trying to blow us up with suicide bombing and I’m sure it hurts them to know that they are all put into the same category as the men who will strap a bomb to their chest and blow other people up.
Post a Comment