Mark Dunn satirizes American society in Ella Minnow Pea; while he does satirize the government, his satirical commentary on ordinary people is, perhaps, even more potent. Now that we have discussed various elements of Dunn's satirical purpose, you have the opportunity to choose your own satirical target (not necessarily one with a direct connection to the novel).
Some restrictions: You must focus on some aspect of society in the United States. Do NOT satirize the government (I'm a bit bored with this topic at the moment). Your satirical target could encompass ALL of society OR some small segment of society; it could focus on people, on institutional structures, on cultural establishments/rituals, etc.
The actual guidelines: Discuss the target you chose, explaining why you chose it and how you would satirize it. Option for Later posters: Instead of posting your own object of satire, you may (but are not required to) choose someone else's post and argue AGAINST satirizing that element of society.
Tuesday, January 6, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

10 comments:
If I had to choose one aspect of United States society to satirize, it would be advertising, more specifically, car commercials. As I am sitting here writing this, a commercial for a Chevy truck came on. The commercial was trying to show how much more “manly” Chevy’s trucks were than the competition’s trucks. In the commercial, Howie Long, who is a former professional football player, is criticizing other men for having, among other things, a heated steering wheel. I think this might be the stupidest advertising technique I have ever seen. Who would not want a heated steering wheel to keep their hands warm when it is fifteen degrees outside? I guess this may work on some people, but I think those would be the type of guys who get in bar fights just to prove that they are the toughest guy in the bar. Chevy has other commercials like this one, including Howie Long again making fun of another man for having a step to help him get down from the bed of his truck. To me, it just seems that Chevy is advertising features that their trucks do not have, which would steer me away from their truck.
I would satirize this by making a commercial for my own vehicle, and make fun of the competition for having necessary parts for the car. I would have the actors be a bunch of rugged Grizzly Adams look-alikes that would be making fun of regular folks. The rugged guys would make fun the regular guys for having “fancy” things like windshield wipers and seats.
One aspect of American society that i would satirize is college football. To be more specific I would satirize the “playoff” system of college football. For many years now college football has used a computer ranking system to choose who plays for the National Championship. For many years now there have been arguments over how it has played out. I think the only way to correct this issue is to institute an eight team playoff series, almost like the NFL.
I choose this topic because for many years now I have watched this ranking system. I have seen how some teams who deserve a chance to play for the Championship, get stuck with the short end of the stick, and miss out on their opportunity to play for the National Championship. This system has been a total disappointment.
I would satirize this by making a movie that follows a team who has had several bad seasons in a row and becomes the laughing stock of the league. But then, they have a turnaround and finally have a good one and deserves to be in the playoffs, but because some new ranking system, they don't. This would express the disappointment that I and so many other people have felt after following a team for the entire season just to have their hopes ripped away at the last second by a computer.
If I could satirize and subsequently broadcast my opinions, I would choose to make fun of the self-entitled customer in retail. Although I am not really a veteran in this subject, I have worked retail since July 2008, and the lack of respect for fellow human beings and the air of superiority that some people radiate is truly astonishing. I have read magazines which encourage grown people to throw tantrums in order to gain 'free stuff', or to 'right a wrong', giving 'helpful' phrases like ' how are we going to fix this?' or 'I will never shop here again', even 'this is bad customer service'. Well, maybe my service would be better if you would treat me less like a subhuman creature and more like someone of your egotistical status, Miss GiveMeEverythingIWantOrIWillNeverShopHereAgainSoHelpMeGod. Working in fast food is really pretty great, because I work in a very hospitable place where every employee is friendly and nice, if not overtly peppy. Instead of getting a smile back, or even the use of articles and appositives in their speech, orders are usually barked at me harshly, and complaints arise over things I haven't even done yet. To all those people out there who encourage loud screaming and foot stomping to 'get your way', I have some thoughts. If you are nice to me first, I'll be nice to you back; I will always be nice first, it's really your reaction and response afterward. It seems like people have lost all sense of etiquette and public manners. If you yell at me to go faster, I will in fact go slower, because your anger is directly proportional to my happiness (the angrier you get, the happier I become).
The way I would satirize one of these people is a very well thought out plan. Once the person, let's say 'Shandra', is done with their emotional hemorrhage, make sure that she will be able to recognize my face if she were to see me again, and tell her my name. Find her place of employment. Subsequently after seeing and distinguishing Shandra, throw a fit that rivals any spoiled brat who didn't get that last Bratz doll for Christmas, complete with all phrases and actions Shandra herself carried out. Direct emotions at Shandra, just like she did to me; Quote Oprah's magazine about how to lower prices and get things for less. Once I get my purchase for free, stop my emotional tirade and become calm, make a speech about how absurd and disgusting it is for grown people to act this way (directing this all towards Shandra), give back my merchandise, apologize, and walk out. Hopefully, she and anyone else in the shop, will have learned a lesson.
As I sit here and watch the Golden Globe Awards, I realize that celebrities' styles could easily be satirized. I notice how we emulate celebrities, even though they are just doing their jobs as actors, actresses, and singers. We watch as they walk down the red carpet and get interviewed on who designed their garment, or how it was working with a specific actor. We are so concerned with the lives of these stars, that try to be like them, wearing a similar dress so we can be in "style" or reading trash magazines to see who caused the most drama that week.
I will not be satirizing the celebrities themselves, but rather the goofballs, including myself, who are actually watching these poor people walk down a carpet, eat, and win an award similar to "employee of the month." Of course, the winners are extremely talented, but why are we so mesmorized by these wealthy performers? A movie titled "In and Out" actually does make fun of the watchers of the award shows. It shows how a town comes together with their popcorn to decide who looked the best and who really deserved the award. They are shown yelling at the TV, hoping that the actors, interviewers, and those people who decided who won the awards, could hear their frantic cheering or angry screaming.
I would like to satirize the people in American society who deal drugs to young kids. This goes on all over the world, but mostly in poor countries where the dealers need the money to live and eat. In their countries there may be no other method of income to turn to. However, in the United States, there are plenty of opportunities to get jobs and pay the bills. Dealers in the U.S. give kids drugs just for extra cash, for the fancy new car or big home. They don't care that drugs are bad for all people, or that kids are very susceptible to doing drugs at such a young age due to peer pressure and the desire to appear cool to their friends. The dealers just want to gather as much money as possible without thinking of the consequences and harm they are doing to the young people’s lives. One time I was walking around some carnival and I remember seeing a bunch of kids probably around the age of ten all smoking cigarettes. There's no way that they all just decided one day to go smoke them; some adult or older kid had to go offer it to them first. I would satirize this through a commercial by showing someone give a young infant a cigarette and have some type of caption saying "How young is too young?" or "Is this how we want to treat our future?" I think that would get across the point that there are kids at very young ages getting into drugs and other types of narcotics. Since it is so widespread, I know I am not the only one who notices kids getting into drug abuse, and I think that this would be a good way for people to realize that something needs to be done about it.
One thing I would satirize would be the baseball "fan." This "fan" is one who thinks baseball season takes a break in Augst when NFL training camps begin and only starts back up again if their team makes the playoffs in October. This "fan" focuses too much on Ryan Howard striking out because in the words of Mitch Williams, "Y'all should be happy he's not grounding into double plays. Strikeouts are the same as any other out." They love the flashy stat like the homerun and forget that there's more to the game, like the importance of a walk. This kind of "fan" also believes Jose Reyes is the best player in the game because he's "exciting." He's a very good player and because of his youth, he has a shot at getting better. But he's not the best player in the game; he's not even the best shortstop in his division. They are also very likely to only follow a team based on recent success and is very quick to drop them as soon as something goes wrong. In Philadelphia, they're usually the ones who can be found calling into 610 WIP.
The reason I chose them is because they're always coming out of the woodwork. With the Phillies' recent success, they seem to be everywhere. They weren't there in the cold nights of early April but you better believe they were at that parade in October. But they're not only in Philadelphia but also in every city with a baseball team. They know the "star" players but don't seem to recognize the lesser-known heroes. One way I would satirize them would be through some type of cartoon or comic. It would show the "fan" doing any of the things I mentioned above. One specific cartoon could be of a person saying, "That's the end of the season!" in August, only to jump back on the bandwagon and act like they've been there all along when their team is playing in October.
The aspect of American society that I would choose to satirize would be some people’s obsession with celebrities and how the celebrities live their lives. There are shows that are devoted to reporting on whatever celebrities are doing, no matter how stupid it is. Washed up celebrities just get their own reality TV’s shows or join competition reality shows to get money. The saddest part about this is that they continue to be successful and people continue to watch these shows and follow the events so seriously. This is the most moronic thing anyone could do in my opinion.
I would satirize this disgrace by trying to present it in the same way it is fed to us. I would make a show about an average person. He or she would have people following them around all day and recording everything that person does. Whenever that person does anything I would make it like it was a breaking news story. It would be all over the papers, magazines and TV. I would just try and make people realize celebrities are just trying to live their lives and we should not be that interested in it. After all, we try and do the same thing every day. Just because they are in movies or commercials does not mean we have to follow the rest of their lives on film too.
One thing about our American society that I would satirize is politics, mostly the mudslinging campaigns that have become key components of elections. Being only sixteen years I am not yet able to vote, but this year I took note of the kinds of things I will have to be aware of in order to be an educated and prepared voter. I watched debates and listened to different ideas on political reforms and read articles about the election, but the one thing I would have rather not seen were the political advertisements. These advertisements could not be avoided as they were aired on almost every non cable network and many cable networks. I have seen political advertisements before and have not liked the way that they are designed, but this year I was extremely disgusted in how these candidates resorted to these tactics to win. I would like to say that President Elect Obama won this election because he is the better man for the job, but due to other factors besides the odds, it seemed to me either candidate had a 50/50 shot at winning. Unfortunately, a good amount of voters are not as educated as they could be, with their political knowledge coming from these slanderous campaigns. These votes affect the election and ultimately who will lead our nation.
The existence of political advertisements cannot be avoided as they began in the 1930s. However in today's world it seems that more elections are based on the ads. Whoever has the best, most convincing ads that totally defimate their opponents character, wins the election. It is unfair for the candidates to try to win votes this way and unintelligent for the people who beleive them. After seeing ad after ad after ad I began to grow irritated with how the candidate being targeted was made to seem incapable of being president. I also did not see how bringing up a person's past as a way to get them elected (aka- John McCain's past of being a naval hero makes him qualifed to be president or the fact that a poor and young Obama found money to go to Yale, saying that he worked his way up in the world.) Although these are good qualities for both men, I do not beleive it qualifies them to be president of the United States. Another thing i dislike about these ads are they spend more time trashing their opponents policies then they do supporting and strengthening their own. If the ads talked about ideas of the candidate maybe I would take that into consideration when voting. After seeing so many of these ads and what the candidates resulted to in order to win the election, I started to think none of them deserved to be president. I want to know the full truth when voting and not the slander put forth by the opposing candidate in an attempt to gain votes.
I understand that sometimes these ads are geared towards certain voting groups and maybe to other people they are effective. I would satirize political ads by making a miniseries with several episodes about ads. This series would center around a president who gets elcted solely based on the strength of his PR campaign. After being elected this president does not know how to manage the job. He ultimately ends up making alot of mistakes which greatly affect the country. This series would be a huge stretch of what political ads could cause. However due to their importance in today's elections. a very real possibility. As in Ella Minnow Pea, this series would describe the extremes of the situation but hopefully teach a lesson. This would be a lesson for the advertising team to spend less time on slander and more on strengthening their candidate and for the American people who use these as their key voting device to learn to base their voting more on debates and speeches, and the planned reforms of the candidates.
The American ego is an aspect of American society that i would satirize. America seems to have the attitude of superiority among its global counterparts. In a sense this is true in that our military forces are superior and we are a leading manufacturing country. America can be considered a very rich country filled with useful goods and many opportunities. This country has many jobs to offer, as well as, numerous opportunities for the young of the nation to take advantage of and become successful. However, aside from all these positives about America some people may take their egos to the far extremes. I believe it is not essentially a good aspect to look down upon other countries. Although many americans do not agree with this feeling, there are quite a few who support this characteristic. In this way, parts of the American ego are at wrong.
The way I would satirize this aspect of American society is to write a novel from the viewpoint of a Frenchman. This main character would travel to the United States and become disgusted with the overpowering attitudes of some Americans he would come in contact with throughout his trip. The book would show how certain attitudes may take the true power of America too far, and therefore show it as a somewhat “cocky” nation.
One aspect of the American culture I would like to satirize would have to be the heatlh conscience American. Just coming back from working out for about an hour, I think about how many tv shows, commercials, and advertisements you see about being heatlhy and ,more importantly to the average person, skinny. Our culture imprints in our minds the way we should loo, how we should, dress, and what we should wear, rather than embracing wha we look and try to work together to try and improve a heatlier style of writing. The ironic part in satirizing the heatlhy American is that they make up the minority of our population. The U.S. is quickly becoming, if not already, the most obsese country in the world. So that is my main focus in chosing this topic. I believe that it is ridiculous that Americans try and push others to use enegry drinks that dangerously burn to many calories, to look up to under-weight and anorxic celeberites, and to shove in our minds that the only way to be beautiful is to be under 100 lbs.
I would satirize the obseisity problems by introducing more health friendly shows like "The Biggest Loser", and to feed more health conscience foods in schools, public or private. If you have not seen "The Biggest Loser" is a competition show, where about 15 over-weight NORMAL, AVERAGE, people try to lose the weight, survive the weekly eliminations and the workouts! At the end of three months the show has 3 contestants left. They then battle for the biggest weight lost and then one of them is crowned "The Biggest Loser" and recieve a money prize.
Also I would change school diets and the cafeteria foods. I would replace the vending machines, and ban soda from being sold inside the school. With these simple ideas, our country can protect ourselves from dieing from liver and kidney failures, prevent the diagnoses of Diabetes, and save ourselves from being obsese.
Post a Comment