Discuss ONE aspect of modern society that Mark Dunn satirizes in Ella Minnow Pea. Articulate what facet of society he is satirizing, why he is satirizing it, and how well he is satirizing it. Focus on 2 specific incidents from the novel as the vehicles of your analysis.
If you choose to piggy-back off of a classmate's topic, make sure you discuss new scenes and evaluate them in relation to those chosen by your classmate.
A reminder - all posts are due by 4:00 p.m. next Monday (12/22).
Monday, December 15, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

14 comments:
A facet of modern society that Dunn is satirizing in Ella Minnow Pea is the government and its involvement in our lives in the U.S. Sometimes, our government gets too involved in our lives, and tries to control the things we do a little too much. The government can also make some questionable decisions sometimes. They get involved and sometimes invade our privacy, such as the Patriot Act. Because of the Patriot Act, the government is allowed to tap our phone lines, check our mail, and many other things. This happened in Ella Minnow Pea when the government started checking the mail of the citizens to make sure the citizens were not using any of the forbidden letters. However, the U.S. is doing it protect it citizens, and the island of Nollop is doing it to punish its citizens.
I think Dunn might be satirizing the government because he might also think that it is overbearing and sometimes stupid. In Ella Minnow Pea, the government did a moronic thing in outlawing the letters that were falling instead of thinking logically that maybe the glue on the letters wore off. Some people feel that the government also makes questionable decisions, such as going to war with Iraq. I think that Dunn did a good job at satirizing the government. He brought out what needs to be changed and what he disagrees with about the government. Also, while he did this, he managed to use humor, which makes the satire better. Not only was it humorous, but it was also witty.
One aspect of modern life that Dunn satirizes is people who are a little advanced in age trying to remain in power over younger people. In league with what Jesse said about government, I focused more on his lampooning of the older generation and their fear of losing power to the newer generation. The High Council is comprised of people who seem to sit in the conservative end of the political spectrum, holding doctrine and rules over circumstances and change. Although it is natural to not want to lose power, these officials take their desire to a new extreme. Banishments, corporeal punishment and even execution play a major role in their offensive regime against free speech, another very critical aspect of the novel. Those in authority abuse their clout to scare the citizens of Nollop into not reacting to their extreme dictations. The very first letter that Ella writes to Tassie says that they ‘keep their assessments and opinions to themselves for fear of government reprisal.” It allegorizes the real world, where people are content to do nothing because at first it is ‘not so bad’, or not bad enough to warrant deportation or execution or any other such punishment. Dunn is making fun of these people in power to criticize our real leaders in the world, such as the communist Kim Jong-Il of North Korea, and al-Bashir of Sudan. His lipogrammic style also shows the humor in the absurdity of these old officials who tend to restrict basic functions to demonstrate the effectiveness and extent of their power. Using this method, Dunn does very well in satirizing his subject, because it is easy to draw parallels to real, modern society, as well as the past. Another incident that is a prime example of Dunn’s opinion could be Dr. Mannheim, who is murdered after refusing to be banished. Dunn is showing the audience that this government is afraid of being usurped of its throne, by eliminating any threats to it. As Mannheim neared the seemingly impossible goal set by the Council, they found arbitrary and false reasons to exile him from Nollop. Mannheim was an honest man, and tried to defend his name and reputation; for this he was shot, another jab by Dunn at police brutality. Dunn manages to keep the novel interesting with his characters and subjects, and even when only five letters remain, it is still readable. He breaks the ethics of those at the helm of society down into little tiny pieces, and appoints a young intelligent girl to carry the evidence she finds to the public. Dunn is subconsciously and openly encouraging self-revised thought and the quest for truth by exposing a corrupt and ugly government party afraid of losing control.
Letters are a thing of the past, text messages, IMs and the internet all are used and to send messages, they are all quick, short and to the point. They don’t have to spell right, be grammatically correct or have a diverse vocabulary as long as they get the point across. Dunn doesn’t like this idea of communication which is why we choose to satirize it in his novel. The few people who do you use letter writing as the primary source of communication like the characters of “Ella Minnow Pea”. By today’s standards in terms of communication, they themselves are on their own personal “island”. Which I think it was smart of Dunn to have the characters of “Ella Minnow Pea” live on the isolated island of Nollop. Nollop is its own private nation which has separated itself from the very society that Dunn is satirizing, our own. Dunn’s Americans now considers the people of Nollop weird and to be too formal. I think that by making Nollop be considered different socially and both geographically he shows our far he believes communication has decreased. He does it so it in a way that is clear but subtle enough so it isn’t being beaten over our heads and I think it works really well. Modern communication is meant to be as fast as possible; words are even being cut down to be as short as possible. Text messaging and IMs are the most obvious example of this; words are spelled phonetically more than being spelled correctly. Dunn definitely doesn’t approve of this, because he makes it the problem that his protagonists are up against. The novel starts out with very expansive and diversely written letters and as more and more letters fall off, the shorter the written letters become as well as the words. The longer the novel goes the more it becomes eerily similar to many text messages/IMs. Then Dunn takes it to an extreme, there are hardly any letters that can be spoken or written and it drives the people of Nollop insane. To Dunn though, I don’t think this is too extreme for him. I believe that is he thinks is happening to modern communication; more and more is being cut out of what Dunn thinks is great that he thinks that eventually there will be nothing left. The people of Nollop lived in an almost utopia society before the letters starts to fall and their communication failed. Dunn wants this for all of us and he is using the novel as message for that. This is also done the same as the island of Nollop obvious but not too much so.
I think a facet of society that Dunn satirizes in Ella Minnow Pea is how ignorant authoritative leaders can be and how the average citizens are forced to live by the ridiculous laws that they make. I agree with Jesse that sometimes the government gets too involved in our personal lives, and it does not benefit the majority of people. Dunn satirizes this particular aspect of our lives because it is very prominent in our modern day world. Many communist countries such as China censor what their citizens are allowed to say and read, and this book gives the readers a taste of how difficult that life must be. I think Dunn does a very good job satirizing that aspect of modern society because by taking out the letters from his own novel he shows us how frustrating it must have been in order for people to communicate. He shows us that without even a few letters it is hard for people to convey their thoughts and feelings to others. For example, since the people of Nollop are forbidden to say or write the fallen letters the government goes to such extremes that they even begin to read people's personal letters in order to enforce this law and thus punish the people who disobey. They are abusing their rights as leaders and infringing on people's privacy. Also the government gives the people of Nollop only three mistakes and on your third mistake you are exiled from the island, thus forced to leave your home and family behind.
Like Derek said, communication is about quick and easy ways to get your message across without using too much energy or wasting time, but that’s not what we’re supposed to do with our language. I think Dunn is satirizing the society itself as a whole and not as different groups and how they take for granted the alphabet. Dunn realizes that our society today takes for granted the letters we use and how we abbreviate our words. Dunn satirizes our abbreviations and shortened words because he knows that all the letters of the alphabet matter and shouldn’t be thrown out from our daily language. Dunn is very clear in his standpoint of how we take letters for granted, especially when the letters start falling. In the beginning everyone in the community wrote fluently and used the majority of the letters, but once the tiles started falling so did their writing. When the first tile fell, Z, the people went on with their routine because z was not a frequently used letter (they took its use for granted), but after letters such as D, R or T started falling, the people realized how important each letter was, individually and together with all the other letters. Tile after tile fell and the community found itself using abbreviations or substituting substitutes for their sound-alike letter brother/sister. After almost all of the letters fell, the community struggled to communicate and found itself in a hole. If the government or the people didn’t take the alphabet for granted in the beginning things may have worked out better (and if the government wasn’t so illogical in their assumptions, they too would have realized all the letters matter in the alphabet.) The second incident when Dun satirizes the Nollop community is when the government starts to punish the citizens for use of a forbidden letter. This is especially illogical because you need all of the letters to communicate effectively and you can’t just stop cold turkey when you’re not allowed to use a letter, its simple outrageous. It goes to show that each letter is important in communication and when you can’t use the particular letter anymore you realize how much you took that letter for granted in your daily speech or writing. Dunn shows us that even though some letters may not be used as frequently as others, each letter is important individually and with the whole alphabet. Once something is gone you learn that it was very important to both you and the society, just like all these letters are to our language. Dunn successfully satirizes our tendency to neglect letters and take them for granted, the road to realization was humorous as the letters dwindled and the language was down to five simple letters, L, M, N, O, and P.
Dunn tries to point out issues with the government by showing problems in education. He focuses on these problems specifically in language. I looked at the copyright of the book and it said 2001. Bush had just come into office and the Patriot Act had just been enacted in October of that year. I do not think Dunn knew what was in the act when he was writing the book so I think the criticism was directed at other governments as well as our own. Many dictators around the world were still in power, like Castro in Cuba. Dunn may have seen what was going on in those countries and may have realized the path that they were headed towards, illiteracy. The U.S. was headed to the same path but in a different way. Nollop was a combination of all the problems he saw in the world. There was no electronic means of communication for most in the countries that were under dictator’s rule and there was none in Nollop. They were being robbed of certain rights when the letters started to fall and because the rulers were in complete control nothing could be done to stop what was happening. But unlike the people who live under dictatorships, the people of Nollop were well educated, like people in America. He thinks that people who are educated should put a stop to the problem and not allow for something like illiteracy to become an even more widespread problem in the world. People try to get out of counties like Cuba everyday and get to America to start anew. People have their families leave Nollop as well, even if they do not have any offenses. Dunn realizes that unless government steps in to stop the problem it will only continue to get worse. He tries to give us a combination of both causes by giving us Nollop. They are educated but do not have access to technology. He is trying to say that any the cause of the problem does not matter, only that it is fixed before we can do nothing to fix it.
One facet of modern society that Mark Dunn satirizes in Ella Minnow Pea is religious fanaticism. Dunn is obviously satirizing this in the way that it is the cause of all the chaos that takes place in the novel. While it may seem like the letters falling off the statue in the first place may be what started everything, it was really the overzealous leaders of the town and their beliefs that did it. When the letters fell, the people in charge could have just let it go and just put them back on or replaced them, but because they were so religious that’s not what they did. Instead they took the occurrence as a message from God and made the ridiculous decision to ban the fallen letters. This is clearly showing what Dunn thinks of the gung-ho religious. He believes that they are blind, mindless people who only follow what they think their god wants. The leaders of Nollopton, blindly followed what they thought was Nollop’s desire. If they weren’t so naïve and they actually used a little logic, everything in the novel could have been avoided. Dunn is obviously against all the disputes, fighting, and foolishness that arises these days because of these people. By the way, it is important to realize that Dunn is not satirizing religion itself, it is the overzealous followers he’s talking about. So he’s not saying that religion is the cause, it’s foolish people, who are far too involved with religion. All in all I think Dunn was right to make fun of this, because these kinds are people are completely ridiculous and deserve to be satirized.
Mark Dunn satirizes many different facets of modern society, the governments, religious fanaticism, and language to name a few. In this idea of government, he satirizes dictatorships and the censorship and strict laws that they impose. Dunn is all for freedom of speech and freedom of the press. When someone takes that away, it is like taking away someone’s natural rights. An example of this is Communist Russia. The government would censor everything that was written in the press to make sure nothing bad was being said about the Russian government. That everything being said and heard or seen was building up the Russian government, and not allowing the people to see the freedoms that other people around the world had. This goes hand in hand with the Nollopian government reading letters that people were sending in the mail. These examples are total censorship to the extreme.
Another modern society example is the patriot act. Like Jesse said, it gives the government the right to tap any ones phone, email, text message, or read their mail. This is also an extreme form of censorship. Even though it was supposed to be used to help protect people it is used to invade the privacy of people who the government doesn’t even know are terrorists. They have limited the rights of suspected terrorists, not known terrorists. Even if there is no other proof then they contacted a known terrorist, they loose their rights of privacy. Dunn thinks this is a very bad thing and this book real shows an example of how this will turn out.
Going along with what Derek and Caitlin said, I think that Dunn is mainly satirizing our language. Today, text messaging and e-mail have greatly shortened our vocabulary. While modern technology is shunned on the island of Nollop in Ella Minnow Pea, proper grammar and high-english is used not only in writing, but in speaking. Writing, because of the lack of new technology, is the only way to communicate besides actual face-to-face communication. I think Dunn feels that this is the way our speech should be. Proper English and grammar should be used rather then our "vocabu-lazy" words. Our society takes such advantage of the new technology and letter writing has been shortened to things like "Thinking of you on your birthday" and "Merry Christmas" with a name signed on the end. No thought is put into the notes themselves, due to the fact that we now have Hallmark to write the notes for us. Other forms of letter-writing has also taken a nose dive. E-mail used to just be a letter sent from a computer directly to an inbox of another computer. The same grammar and language was used in the original e-mails. Nowadays, e-mails consist of shortened, phonetic words and small sentences, rather than paragraphs. Even shorter then e-mails, text messages and instant messaging has completely downsized our vocabulary. Rather then writing letters, these new forms of communication have made conversation easy without the need to even speak! Dunn shows toward the end of the novel how our language really is slowly diminishing due to our laziness and new technology.
Who writes letters anymore? When you can text message, email, or instant message a person in less then 10 seconds, what's the point? 'Ella Minnow Pea' was published in 2001, meaning that when Mark Dunn wrote his novel, the age of technology had already taken off and set. Dunn ridicules and mocks the idea that America is now a 'vocabulazy' (as Ms. Alexander says) country. The use of slang, slander, and misuse of language like cursing and swear words (which are NOT in the dictionary) is making our country seem like we are unintelligent and not as intellectual as many other countries. Abbreviating words such as 'u' for 'you' or 'ily' for 'i love you' not only is lazy and incorrect, but it also can affect our intellectual abilities later in life. Like what Derek said, things don't even have to be spelled right and people understand it completely! Is America as we know it faltering due to technology? Should language cease to exist all together and be replaced with slang and abbreviations? Well, that's what Mark Dunn writes about. Picture America, not allowed to use the letter 'X' anymore. Teenagers alone would have a hard time, because 'X' is so commonly used in text messages, emails, and IMs that probably everyone would be punished! (ex: Xmas, Xcept, Xcuse etc...) We need our language and grammatical strucure in literature. Without so, we would never be able to understand the past. People of the past never knew texting or IMing, so if the basis of our language revolves around that, how are ever supposed to learn about history and facts? Mark Dunn takes it to the extreme that our world would be changed forever, but it does put an idea in your mind that we NEED language to survive. It unites us as a country and as a people. An example of an incident is just the general falling tiles off of the Nollop statue. As each letter falls, language slowly but surely ceases to exist. Is this what will happen to our language? Another incident is how extreme the authorites of Nollopian government take the offenses. They arrest and expel people out of Nollop for saying one letter! Though it is an extremity to throw someone out of a country for saying a letter, Dunn is showing that losing our original language is bad. We need it to educate, learn, and teach others about us. Communication is important, why confuse it with abbreviations and slang?
Ella Minnow Pea describes a 21st Century society that lives without the use of the technology such as in computers, telephones and communication related to these two devices. The Nollopians choose to live without the aid of technology in order to preserve their language. One aspect of this book that Mark Dunn satirizes is the issue of censorship and freedom of speech as judged by the government. I believe Dunn chooses to satirize freedom of speech because of the way our American culture treats language. It seems that in today’s world we do not have the same respect for language that we once did. People use instant messaging, texting and emails more frequently everyday. As we continue to enter into a technology denominated world, these devices are used to help people communicate. Long distance or easier accessibility, whatever the reason we use the computer to relay messages. Due to this over reliance on technology we have found ourselves abbreviating words to the extent that three letter words such as ‘are’ or ‘you’ have become simply ‘r’ and ‘u’. We have also made up abbreviations to describe phrases such as brb for be right back or ttyl meaning talk to you later. What Dunn is trying to prove is that we abuse our language and are slowly losing it due to shortening of it to fit our culture. This is also evidence to how we have become such a lazy culture. The simpler communication becomes the better. Dunn uses this in Ella Minnow Pea as they lose letters from the statue of Nollop and are forced to eliminate them from their speech and letters. Dunn is using this fact that we do not appreciate language but the Nollopians do and they are affected by a few letters gone missing. Ultimately their communication is altered and life on Nollop becomes more difficult. For Americans however, it is as if we have already lost letters from our alphabet as we seem to eliminate words from our language everyday. We unlike the Nollopians do not realize what we have in language until it is gone. Censorship prevents us from saying certain that are judged accordingly. Our language is not very much censored unless you speak of curse words, which even then sometimes manage to find themselves heard on televisions or radio stations. An example of this is with Chase Utley. During the World Series Champions Parade, Utley dropped the f’bomb for all in attendance to here. Due to the unexpected nature of the use of this word, television stations such as abc were not able to censor, or bleep out the word, fox however did catch it and censored it appropriately. This idea of censorship can also be seen in Ella Minnow Pea when the Nollopians begin to lose more and more letters from their language. The High Council has censored their language by forbidding them from using the exciled letters. As censorship affects many Americans by being punished or in Utley’s and other celebrities case fined, the Nollopians also are affected heavily by censorship. Once an exciled letter is written or spoken a person receives a strike. After collecting three strikes a person is banished from the island of Nollop. However strikes one and two are not only strikes as they carry their own punishment with them. A public whipping is one of those punishments. Dunn makes fun of American society by comparing these issues of censorship. We should use the language we have been given and not take it for granted. We should try to speak the best we can and take advantage of the fact that our speech is not censored and that we do have freedom of speech. I believe Dunn’s message to us Americans is to not define our daily speech with lols, bbls, 4u and many other abbreviated words but to express ourselves in only a way Americans can, because we can express ourselves unlike in some countries where everything a person says is censored. Take advantage of our first amendment rights and allow ourselves to use of language properly because it is true what they say, you really do not what you have until its gone.
I forgot to mention, I beleive that Dunn does accomplish his purpose of satirizing censorship very well because his ideas are very factual and effective. At least to me I beleive that Dunn acheives his purpose and as a result will try myself to limit my use of what in today's world is called IM SPEAK, because why waste what a wonderful gift we have been given with langauge and the ability to freely express ourselves through words.
In “Ella Minnow Pea,” Mark Dunn points out the folly of government in its attempt to censor freedom of speech. However, I think the main issue that Mark Dunn satirizes in his epistolary novel is the ignorance of the people who live under the rule of the stupid government. In today’s world, people are often exploited by the power-hungry and corrupt rulers who lead them. Dunn noticed this and decided to confront the problem by illustrating the two extremes of knowledge (or lack thereof) and how they can lift up (or tear down) a community.
In “Ella Minnow Pea,” the people of Nollop are torn between fighting for their rights and displaying good citizenship (by obeying unjust laws). Realizing that they will be punished if they rebel, many citizens simply abide by these new, albeit outrageous, ordinances. Take the example of Georgeanne Towgate. Mrs. Towgate thought it would be a good idea not only to passively follow the government’s every demand, but also to serve as an agent to the government by reporting any infractions of the law. However, simply following the rules tears away at Mrs. Towgate’s livelihood; it takes away everything near and dear to her, beginning with her son Timmy (because little Timmy broke the precious rules) and then moving on to her speech (the means of communication that she, along with her fellow Nollopians, relies so heavily on). Towgate’s complacency in “going with the flow” led to her eventual suicide; because she was eventually cornered by the tyrannical Nollopian government that she refused to fight from the outset, Georgeanne Towgate paints herself to death in her despair. On the flip side, Ella Minnow Pea decides to fight the repressive Nollopian leaders. Ella bands together with other courageous souls around Nollop and together they attempt to save their hometown. Because Ella and her friends chose to fight, they had a reason to live. When all seemed lost, Ella managed to persevere and save her friends and family. By showing the two extremes of societal awareness—complete ignorance and a cautious doubt of authority—Dunn manages to effectively convey his point. Readers realize how ignorance can corrupt a perfect society and how constant awareness and caution can save a society from the depths of corruption.
The main ideas that Dunn satirizes in Ella Minnow Pea are already thoroughly discussed by everybody who already wrote in the blog before me. He satirizes the language very well like Derek said, showing that as we as a society are getting accustomed to text messaging and writing abbreviations for words that are not part of a real language. This makes American society seem dull and unintelligent. He also satirizes the complete control some governments have over their nations like Jesse said. I think that something else Dunn satirizes that might not be a main theme is the worship of false gods. In the book, all of the problems could have been avoided had they not considered Nollop a god. In the book, they decided to take it as a sign from him that they should stop using the letters in everyday life that fell from his statue, but if they thought logically and realized he was just a human being, they would have kept the usage of all of their letters of the alphabet. Like Steve said, there would have been no need for the people to constrict their language and freedom of speech and writing. All the people who got kicked off the island for using the banned letters could have been saved from being outcast, and all the stress it caused families and friends like Ella’s aunt being told on while she was teaching did not need to have happened. He’s showing that bad things come as a result from worshipping false gods.
Another instance where this satirizing of worship of false gods is shown in the novel is how the council agreed to “Enterprise 32,” which meant that if the citizens of Nollop found a phrase with all the letters of the alphabet like Nollop did himself, then he must not have been a god after all. This shows that the members of the council must have had a feeling that Nollop was not really a god if they thought it was okay for people to test his powers. If he really was a god, then he would not have wanted to be tested and could have punished them for their ignorance. However, the council agrees, possibly to reassure their own faith in him to see if he really is a god. Even though they are not thoroughly convinced of his divinity, they listened to his ‘wishes’ anyway when the letters continued to fall. This is like in modern society how people are obsessed with money or material goods and let them take over their life. People try to get as rich as possible that it is almost like money is their own false god. They try to get as much as possible because they think it will take care of them. What they don’t realize is that worshipping these false gods leads to trouble, and in the case of people who try to get rich, they are missing out on the joys of giving to others and living a simple and happy life. Dunn successfully satirizes this element of modern society and shows that people should realize not to take natural occurrences as signs from a false god like the people of Nollop did.
Post a Comment